UltimateDisney.com | DVD Review Index | Disney / Buena Vista TV Shows Page | Search This Site
Desperate Housewives on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5
"Desperate Housewives" The Complete Second Season:
The Extra Juicy Edition DVD Review - Page 2
A star ( 16. There Is No Other Way (43:10) (Originally aired March 12, 2006)
17. Could I Leave You? (43:15) (Originally aired March 26, 2006)
19. Don't Look At Me (43:10) (Originally aired April 16, 2006)
20. It Wasn't Meant To Happen (43:13) (Originally aired April 30, 2006)
DISC 5
VIDEO and AUDIO
Each episode is thankfully presented in the 1.78:1 aspect ration in which it was originally created and enhanced for 16x9 televisions. Outside some very light and occasional edge enhancement and a couple of instances of the moiré effect, the video quality is near-perfect. The show's up to cinematic quality and quite pleasing to look at. The extra episode on each disc (there are five each here as opposed to the first season's four) doesn't seem to have had any negative effects. A lot of work already goes into the series' visual presence during production and it's a beautiful thing on DVD.
The audio is equally pleasing. It's presented in Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround Sound and makes full use of the available channels. Dialogue of course comes from the front but it's accompanied by beautiful scoring that emanates from all around and amazingly detailed sound effects that arrive from the rear. The sound is delivered with wonderful tone thanks to a rich and sensible bass track that allows the viewer to not only hear the music, but feel it too. Watching "Desperate Housewives" on DVD is truly a surround sound experience and as with the video quality, is on par with feature films.
I was fully prepared to give this release UD's highly coveted 5-star award before realizing that the full-length episode audio commentaries -- you know, the ones that appeared on the first season's DVD and were advertised for the second's in its press release -- are nowhere to be found. Generally speaking, audio commentaries are the most valuable and substantive bonus features that TV-on-DVD can see and those produced for the first season of "Desperate Housewives" were particularly enjoyable. Whether Marc Cherry or Buena Vista were less enthused about the second season following its mixed reception with critics and fans or whether the new five episodes-per-disc organization prevented their inclusion, the studio clearly changed its mind (or else just lied) in between the initial DVD announcement and the actual release. That's a real shame but it's fortunate that missing commentaries aside, there's a whole slew of great bonuses and this time they're all easily accessible from one location: Disc 6.
First up is an interview with Marc Cherry and his mother, Martha Cherry, aptly titled "Marc & Mom" (8:47). It's no secret that "Desperate Housewives" is in no small part based on Marc's childhood experiences and his mother's personality in particular. Therefore, it's extremely interesting not only to get her perspective on what is not always a flattering portrayal, but to hear the two of them chat about the life that inspired the series and the specific elements that have found their way into storylines.
Next up is "Directing Desperate Housewives" (16:33), a making-of featurette for the episode "There's Something About A War" that focuses on multiple aspects of production with an emphasis on direction. It's a well-made and revealing piece, the kind one would like to see more of and at greater length.
"Desperate Role Models" (7:31) is an example of a creative bonus feature for a show like this, which has been lauded by many critics as revolutionary (or at least a little less than conventional). Famous housewives from classic TV series of the past share their thoughts on the series and how the depiction of women differs from their own experiences in television.
"Cherry-Picked" is a section filled with various scenes from the second season (inexplicably presented in fullscreen) that Marc Cherry has personally selected as his favorites. They can be viewed with or without commentary from Cherry (so at least some commentary made it to the DVD) and a "Play All" option has thankfully been made available. There are 11 scenes in total, which run 27:47 together.
"Unaired Story Lines" is another very exciting inclusion. Here, two complete storylines -- that is, a sequence of scenes shot with the intention of running throughout a particular episode -- that were later deleted for either creative reasons or time constraints are presented in their entirety. Talk about your deleted scenes! It's just too bad that they're presented in fullscreen, when they were surely also framed for widescreen along with the rest of the series. One involves Susan's plans to vent her frustration by writing an adult novel (10:52) and another involves a troublesome incident for a frantic Lynette aboard an airplane (4:05). Though there are only two of them, they're available with a "Play All" option and once again, optional audio commentary from Marc Cherry. The deleted scenes don't stop there, though, as 11 conventional ones from various episodes are included as well (with -- you guessed it! -- a "Play All" feature and Cherry's commentary), running 15:45 altogether.
"Fashion & Couture" (10:46) is a featurette about (read: "virtual shrine to") the series' costume designer, Catherine Adair. It's actually an informative piece about the thought and development that goes into the selection and creation of the vast "Desperate Housewives" wardrobe and includes plenty of interviews from cast and crew.
In "Juicy Bites" (2:38), each of the main housewives (save Alfre Woodard and Brenda Strong) recall the moments in the second season that they consider to be their character's "juiciest." It's something of a fluff piece, but still fun and interesting. After all, it's always nice to hear an actor or actress share their own experiences with the characters the audience knows and loves.
"The Whole Story" (1:04) is a brief TV spot that ABC ran in the weeks leading up to the premiere of the second season. In it, the multitude of revelations and plot twists that developed in the first season are reviewed at break-neck speed It hardly counts as a bonus feature, but there's also a commercial (0:56) for the upcoming "Desperate Housewives" computer game that doesn't provide much information but does show off some of the graphics. Aside from that, there's the standard platter of Buena Vista sneak previews, atypically presented on the sixth disc on this set. The disc openers: a new promo for Apocalypto that includes the commentary of Mel Gibson, Kinky Boots, Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest, Keeping Up With the Steins, "Lost": The Complete Second Season, and "Grey's Anatomy": The Complete Second Season (Uncut). Additional previews for "Scrubs": The Complete Fourth Season, "The Golden Girls": The Complete Sixth Season, "Alias": The Complete Fifth (and Final) Season, the Disney-owned SoapNet network, and the upcoming third season of "Desperate Housewives" on ABC can be accessed from the main menu.
MENUS, PACKAGING, and DESIGN
The DVD packaging for "Desperate Housewives" is as creative the second time around as it was the first. Once again, it comes in eight-paneled Digipak case inside which six single-sided discs can be found. The Digipak itself is housed inside a clear plastic slipcover that, when in place, creates the cover design that can be seen at the top of this review. When removed, however, the lovely ladies that grace the cover "disappear" and an entirely new design is found on the back cover. They don't appear to lose their clothing this time, but it's still a nice touch. The entire Digipak and slipcover are designed with the series' opening credits sequence's apple motif in mind. I guess the fruit and the "Extra Juicy Edition" title are supposed to go together too.
Inside the case, one can find an eight page booklet that outlines the discs' contents in detail, several ads for products from the show and its sponsors, a flyer for select Buena Vista TV series on DVD, and a peel-able sample of the new "Desperate Housewives" perfume, "Forbidden Fruit." The six discs continue the apples-and-seductive-poses theme. Disc 1 features Lynette, Disc 2 - Susan, Disc 3 - Bree, Disc 4 - Edie, Disc 5 - Gabrielle, and Disc 6 - Betty (who takes the place of Mary Alice Young on the disc art just like she did in the series). Behind the discs, one finds a montage of interesting stills from the second season. When placed upside down, two of the panels bear a very appealing photo spread of the central housewives (again save Brenda Strong and Alfre Woodard).
As previously noted, all the bonus features and sneak previews have been reserved for the sixth disc, on which there are no full episodes. That leaves five episodes per disc for all but the last, which has four (well, really just three but one is presented as double-length... more on that in the episode descriptions above). That's a huge improvement over the scattered and hard-to-find bonus features of the first season's release.
The main menu from the first season, in which the theme song sequence is re-imagined with animation of the housewives, is repeated here on all six discs. That shows a general lack of effort, especially when given that Bree's can of soup no longer labels the disc number as it did with the first season set, but at least the menus are creative to begin with. The sub-menus are all identical to the last release as well, still frames set to music. For some reason, in my player, once an episode is selected, it takes a particularly long time to begin playing. Naturally, each disc's episodes feature a "Play All" option. As with the last time, the font used for the menu is thematically appropriate but a little hard to read and navigate.
CLOSING THOUGHTS
The second season of "Desperate Housewives" is much stronger than its reputation suggests. Watching an entire season of television in the span of a week is an entirely different experience than watching it over the course of a year. My experience with this particular series lies only in the former but as far as it is concerned, I can vouch for its remarkable entertainment value. There are certainly problems to be found but when all is said and done, the series is able to take great strides in its second year and thrill the audience nearly as much as it did in its first.
Though the "Extra Juicy Edition" DVD lacks complete episode-length audio commentaries and is packaged under a ridiculous title, it otherwise boasts a full platter of worthwhile supplements and spectacular audio/video quality. This is by no means the kind of series that one can launch into without having already seen the first season but to those who have, the Complete Second Season of "Desperate Housewives" is heartily recommended without hesitation.
More on the DVD / Buy from Amazon.com
Page 1: Show Discussion, Discs 1-3
|
Related Reviews:
Desperate Housewives: The Complete First Season
Commander in Chief: Part 1 • Commander in Chief: Part 2
Grey's Anatomy: Season One | Lost: The Complete First Season
Scrubs: The Complete Second Season | The Golden Girls: The Complete Second Season
Home Improvement: The Complete Second Season | Ellen: The Complete Season Two
Dinosaurs: The Complete First and Second Seasons | Boy Meets World: The Complete Second Season
The Muppet Show: Season One | The Tick vs. Season 1
"Desperate Housewives" Cast Members in Other Disney Films:
Alfre Woodard: A Wrinkle in Time • Dinosaur
Mark Moses: The Golden Girls: The Complete Fifth Season
Andrea Bowen: Bambi II | Shawn Pyfrom: The Shaggy Dog (2006)
Mehcad Brooks: Glory Road | Roger Bart: Lady and the Tramp II: Scamp's Adventure
Joely Fisher: Inspector Gadget | Sam Lloyd: Scrubs: The Complete Third Season
Kurt Fuller: Angels in the Infield | Paul Dooley: Angels in the Endzone | Carol Burnett: Once Upon a Mattress
Lesley Ann Warren: The Happiest Millionaire | Bob Newhart: The Rescuers
UltimateDisney.com | DVD Review Index | Disney / Buena Vista TV Shows Page | Search This Site
Desperate Housewives on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5
Reviewed September 17, 2006.
UltimateDisney.com Top Stories: