UltimateDisney.com | DVD Review Index | Disney / Buena Vista TV Shows Page | Search This Site
Desperate Housewives on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5
"Desperate Housewives" The Complete Second Season:
The Extra Juicy Edition DVD Review - Page 1
By Aaron Wallace
The second season of "Desperate Housewives" had a tough act to follow. The first year had swept the nation and fascinated millions, a bona fide phenomenon. It quickly became one of television's most popular series and is credited in part with the salvation of its previously fledgling network, ABC. Through a darkly comedic and mildly satiric lens, At the end of the first season, Wisteria Lane welcomed a new resident, the shady Betty Applewhite (Alfre Woodard) and her son. In the Season Two premiere, it becomes apparent that these newcomers have an enormous secret to hide, one involving the murder of a young woman and a mysterious prisoner in their basement. The Applewhites are clearly designed to fill the void of Season One's "Oh, Mary Alice, what did you do?". Theirs is not the only source of intrigue in the second year, however.
Bree Van De Kamp (Marcia Cross) comfortably moves into position as the show's lead with the devastation of her husband's death (which she soon learns was murder), a treacherous pair of children, and a psychotic suitor to propel her. As she is continually betrayed by those she loves, her torment becomes nearly unbearable for the compassionate viewer, which, in the realm of TV drama, equates to irresistible suspense.
Susan Mayer (Teri Hatcher) loses emphasis as there's no longer a Young family secret to investigate, a blackmailing neighbor to elude, or a thriving romance with neighborhood plumber/good-natured undercover assassin Mike Delfino (James Denton), who also sees a little less screentime. Both characters spend most of the second season as part of a four-way love... rectangle?... that also includes the resident slut with spunk, Edie Britt (Nicollette Sheridan), who officially joins the cast as a regular and Susan's ex-husband, Karl (Richard Burgi), who also comes around a lot more often.
Having spent the entire first season in a state of perpetual motherly anxiety, Lynette Scavo (Felicity Huffman) does a one-eighty in Season Two, returning to the high-powered executive career path she had left several years before. That does little to alleviate marital tensions with husband Tom (Doug Savant), whose desire to return to work only complicates their children's dislike for an employed mother and the competitive edge that often gets the best of both of them.
Finally, feisty ex-super model Gabrielle Solis (Eva Longoria) begins to cope with the prospect of being a mother and the lifestyle change that pregnancy demands of her. She finally calls it quits with her teenaged lover, John Rowland (Jesse Metcalfe), but with a husband in prison and a baby on the way, her marriage remains threatened by more than the now-exposed affair.
A whole summer, commercial breaks, and one-a-week installments can go a long way to dilute suspense and as a result, "Desperate Housewives"' return to TV in the fall of 2005 was received with less enthusiasm than its first time out had been. To be sure, there are problems in Season Two. For starters, the Mary Alice Young mystery had been entirely organic, emanating from inside Wisteria Lane. Its successor, the case of Betty Applewhite, arrives from somewhere else and thus feels disconnected until things begin to meld about halfway through. The fact that the riddle that had established the series had been seemingly solved so quickly was disappointing to many as well. Additionally, the seven central housewives spend most of their screentime in their own isolated storylines and characterization is less than consistent from episode to episode, with their personalities and motivations sometimes bent to suit the plot's need.
Despite all that, though, the second season largely succeeds. Most of the missteps outlined above are corrected before the season's end and there's so much else going right that the ups outweigh the downs. Perhaps most importantly, the mystery of the Young family has not been forgotten, though the first season's resolution and the early part of the second suggest that it has. "Desperate Housewives" benefits from one of the strongest ensemble casts on television. With a host of Emmys, SAG awards, Golden Globes, and even Oscar nominations among them, their talent shouldn't come as a surprise but it's difficult to sit through nearly fifty episodes in rapid succession, as I did, and not be impressed with their performances. That's true not only for the stunningly beautiful main cast, but also the supporting roles that are nearly as important to the story. The addition of Alfre Woodard, who commands a screen like few others, further enhances the roster. The show is neither entirely a drama nor a comedy -- it's most reliant on the conventions of the former but incorporates many elements from the latter -- and the cast capably performs on both ends of the spectrum.
Of course, even a stellar cast can't save a poor script, but when good writing is given to great actors, the results can be spectacular. Save the few foibles of the second season that have already been addressed, that's the case thus far with "Desperate Housewives." At this point, it may be safe to say that creator Marc Cherry, who also does the bulk of the writing, is a creative genius. Few have so masterfully grasped the television drama and though his show is one that revels in flair and sensation, it centers around characters who are believable, accessible, fully realized, and rooted in reality. Two seasons of one show already put him at least in the company of contemporaries Aaron Spelling and David E. Kelley. Of course, his tele-visual roots are in comedy and those sensibilities are put to excellent use as well. Each episode manages to bundle emotion, humor, and suspense into one theme that unites the various stories told within, a feat attempted by many but rarely met with success. That it consistently ends with gasp-eliciting cliffhangers that lead to jaw-dropping revelations the next week is all the more gratifying.
The show's most attractive quality, however, is not its story or its performances, but its tone. As already explained, the one-hour series blends comedy and drama, producing its own brand of dark irony. It must be noted that the series is not the tawdry sleaze-fest that its title suggests nor is it a condemnation of conservative suburban life. In fact, it's far more reverent to that lifestyle than almost anything else on TV. In poking at the silliness and hypocrisies of the painted-perfect life, the show also celebrates the upper middle class suburbia in which Cherry himself was raised. As he reflects on his own experiences in both appreciation and amusement, he invites his audience to do the same -- regardless of their background -- in the lives of his characters. By coloring in both the good and the bad in each role and parodying everyday social interactions, the noblest acts are made suspect and the most sinister deeds can unfold in jest. Fresh, funny, resonant, involving, and utterly contemporary, the show's magnetism is inescapable and its appeal undeniable.
Just in time for viewers to squeeze in twenty-four episodes before the third season's ABC premiere, Buena Vista has released the The Complete Second Season to DVD under the inane moniker of "The Extra Juicy Edition". Don't let such silly marketing fool you; there's only one release of the second season on DVD and its contents are covered in detail below.
A star () denotes my ten favorite episodes from the season.
DISC 1
1. Next (43:12) (Originally aired September 25, 2005)
2. You Could Drive A Person Crazy (42:53) (Originally aired October 2, 2005)
3. You'll Never Get Away From Me (43:07) (Originally aired October 9, 2005)
4. My Heart Belongs To Daddy (43:05) (Originally aired October 16, 2005)
5. They Asked Me Why I Believed In You (42:58) (Originally aired October 23, 2005)
DISC 2
6. I Wish I Could Forget You (43:07) (Originally aired November 6, 2005)
7. Color and Light (41:59) (Originally aired November 13, 2005)
8. The Sun Won't Set (43:06) (Originally aired November 20, 2005)
9. That's Good, That's Bad (43:07) (Originally aired November 27, 2005)
10. Coming Home (43:12) (Originally aired December 4, 2005)
DISC 3
11. One More Kiss (42:58) (Originally aired January 8, 2006)
12. We're Gonna Be All Right (43:15) (Originally aired January 15, 2006)
13. There's Something About A War (43:06) (Originally aired January 22, 2006)
14. Silly People (43:07) (Originally aired February 12, 2006)
15. Thank You So Much (43:12) (Originally aired February 19, 2006)
Buy Desperate Housewives: Season 2 from Amazon.com
Page 1: Show Discussion, Discs 1-3
|
UltimateDisney.com | DVD Review Index | Disney / Buena Vista TV Shows Page | Search This Site
Desperate Housewives on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5
Reviewed September 17, 2006.
UltimateDisney.com Top Stories: