UltimateDisney.com | DVD Review Index | DVDizzy.com: New and Upcoming DVD Schedule | Disney / Buena Vista TV Shows Page | Search
Home Improvement on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5 • Season 6 • Season 7 • Season 8
"Home Improvement" The Complete Third Season DVD Review
Buy Season 3 from Amazon.com / Buy The Complete Series Collection
A star ( Disc 3
19. Too Many Cooks (23:33) (Originally aired March 16, 1994)
20. It Was the Best of Tims, It Was the Worst of Tims (23:05) (Originally aired March 30, 1994)
22. Swing Time (23:34) (Originally aired May 4, 1994)
23. What You See Is What You Get (23:34) (Originally aired May 11, 1994)
25. The Great Race II (23:18) (Originally aired May 25, 1994)
VIDEO and AUDIO
In line with the show's first two DVD season sets, "Home Improvement" is presented in its original 1.33:1 "fullscreen" aspect ratio and looks mighty fine. The element is thankfully clean - shot on high grade video, "Home Improvement" holds up with nary an visual intrusion. Once again, the DVD comes equipped with just one sound option: Dolby Stereo. This is more than sufficient and fairly robust as far as two-channel presentations go. Via Dolby Pro Logic, the rear speakers are capably employed for the steady laughtrack and music which is present but mostly unnoticeable (the exceptions being the instrumental themes for both "Home Improvement" and "Tool Time"). Dialogue is perfectly crisp and understandable. As far as sitcoms go, the show stands out a bit, offering better sound design than you may remember (assuming you weren't watching it on a home theater system twelve years ago), with Tim's on-air blunders and the increasingly elaborate scene transitions making good use of the sound field.
BONUS FEATURES
Bonus material is the one area where Buena Vista's "Home Improvement" season sets continue to disappoint. The only supplement provided, appearing on Disc 3, is "Tim's Tool Corral", an interactive garage of clips. The feature is touted as being hosted by "Tool Time" girl Debbe Dunning, but the actress has merely supplied narration for this, namely a handful of one-liners. The interactive nature, a design which suggests the slightest bit of inspiration, and the fact that it features a cast member (however minimal Dunning's contributions may be) all put "Tim's Tool Corral" a few pegs above the past "Loose Screws" season highlight reels, but it still doesn't amount to much. Disappointingly, the studio has yet to treat this series (one of their longest-lasting and most popular) to great shakes in the way of bonus features. Fans who were underwhelmed by the handful of creator audio commentaries on Season 1 a year ago would probably settle for more reflections with those creators and surely must be hankering for some genuinely original supplements with the starring cast. I doubt many would prefer "Tool Corral" to an interview piece with Dunning. And can it really be that difficult for Disney to get Tim Allen to sit down for a day (or even a few hours) to record commentaries or an interview? The studio has employed him regularly over the past few years especially right now, from the upcoming remake of The Shaggy Dog to now-in-production The Santa Clause 3 and you'd think both parties would be interested in taking a bit of time to reflect on the highly successful property that did great things for each. Then there are Allen's supporting cast, all of whom are substantially less busy in the entertainment industry and whom have been willing to participate in unofficial documentaries from E!'s "Behind the Scenes" to A&E's "TVography."
Disc One opens with the customary Disney previews, starting with a new trailer/featurette hybrid for the studio's upcoming remake of The Shaggy Dog starring Tim Allen. Other promos tout Buena Vista TV on DVD (highlighting season sets of "Home Improvement", "Lost", "The Golden Girls", "Scrubs", "Alias", and "Desperate Housewives") and the upcoming Complete Third Season DVD of "Scrubs", while the Sneak Peeks menu adds looks at "Home Improvement": The Complete Fourth Season, "The Golden Girls": The Complete Third Season, "Alias": The Complete Fourth Season, and ABC's primetime sitcom "According to Jim."
MENUS, PACKAGING, and DESIGN
The 16x9-enhanced menus differ from the design employed for the last two seasons' selection screens, but illustrate that sometimes change can be good. The Main Menu features an animated wrinkled blueprint backdrop and is accompanied by the theme song. Submenus, now thankfully unadorned with music, feature similar backgrounds, with the Episode Selection menu holding relevant images from the various shows, arranged three per page. It's worth mentioning that a couple of episodes have slightly different titles than the ones most commonly found online ("Frozen Moments" instead of "A Frozen Moment", etc.). Spelling discrepancies aside, they are properly presented in the order of their original airings. Each episode is equipped with 8-10 chapter stops for quick scene access.
Like the first two seasons, the three discs are held in a six-sided Digipak. Two of the sides hold discs (Discs 1 and 2 overlap), one side contains episode listings for each disc (the show titles appear on the label artwork as well), and two sides feature snazzy artwork (one offers the Tool Time trio, the other features Tim, Jill, and Al). The final side contains a note on the Third Season from Elliot Shoenman, who joined "Home Improvement" as an executive producer in the featured year. While the note only briefly discusses some of the season's highlights and the writers' intentions for that year, it's nice to see the tradition of a creative crew member's message unique to the season has continued.
Once again, Buena Vista has shown some creativity in the outer box design. It features the three Taylor boys taking a break from a messy paint job and has a hole in the center, allowing Tim to show through from the Digipak within. Jill becomes the third character featured on the spine, following Wilson and Al. Kudos to the studio for maintaining some packaging consistency, while still giving each season some unique design traits. The only two inserts inside the box are the studio's typical TV-on-DVD library sweepstakes entry form and now-dated TV on DVD catalogue.
CLOSING THOUGHTS
I gave the first two seasons of "Home Improvement" hearty recommendations and, on the whole, Season Three offers an even better time than them. While this season takes a little while to consistently deliver top-notch episodes, it never fails to provide laughs and amusement the way only the best sitcoms do. When it hits its stride (near the end of Disc 1), the show is pretty much at its apex. In spite of some minor changes in focus and secondary cast, the series does not drastically alter anything from its previous years. That was fine then (the Third Season gave the show its greatest viewership and made it the highest rated non-news program on television) and it remains so now, as comedy from both the family and workplace settings hold up better than plenty of last decade's shows.
Disney's three-disc collection does not merit any of the complaints that plague many season sets; music has not been replaced, abbreviated syndicated cuts have not been used, packaging is consistent and well-done. The episodes themselves have been treated to unceasingly solid picture and sound, chapter stops, and faultless menus. That it comes at a price tag $10 lower than the previous two season sets makes the Third Season even easier to recommend. The only area where the studio continues to fail the show's large fanbase is in bonus material, offering again just one brief collection of highlights with only slight innovation. Few enthusiasts would argue that rounding up the cast for commentaries and retrospectives would be a wasted effort. Even less ambitious inclusions (like easily-accessible archival footage) would fill the void in a big way. Paying tribute to this extremely popular sitcom with bonus features is something that undoubtedly needs to be addressed before the entire series is out on DVD.
In spite of another missed opportunity for talent and viewer reflection on the featured show, The Complete Third Season of "Home Improvement" is a no-brainer purchase for fans. With preorder discounts, it amounts to about $1 per episode of one of the best family sitcoms to ever grace the television. Between its strong digital presentation and the excellence of the show itself, this is certainly one sitcom season set to buy and enjoy for many years to come.
More on the DVD / Buy from Amazon.com / Buy Complete Series Collection
|
Home Improvement on DVD: Season 1 • Season 2 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5 • Season 6 • Season 7 • Season 8
Related Reviews:
Reviewed November 21, 2005.
UltimateDisney.com | DVD Review Index | DVDizzy.com: New and Upcoming DVD Schedule | Disney / Buena Vista TV Shows Page | Search
Home Improvement: The Complete Second Season • Home Improvement: The Complete First Season • Jungle 2 Jungle
Boy Meets World: The Complete Third Season • The Complete Second Season • The Complete First Season
The Golden Girls: The Complete Third Season • The Complete Second Season • The Complete First Season
Scrubs: The Complete Second Season • Scrubs: The Complete First Season
Ellen: The Complete Season Two • Ellen: The Complete Season One
The Muppet Show: Season One • Tales from Avonlea: The Complete First Season
Chip 'n Dale Rescue Rangers: Volume 1 • DuckTales: Volume 1Page 1: Show Discussion, Disc 1, and Disc 2
Page 2: Disc 3, Video/Audio, Bonus Features, Menus & Packaging, and Closing Thoughts