Tangled vs. Frozen

[frankf3]

With the debates that I have seen on the Frozen thread, I felt this was deserving of its own personally thread. The two CGI musicals that are Disney's most successful animated movies since The Lion King. Both are very well received from critics and audiences. So which do you like better and why?



For me, I really do like both movies quite a bit, both I have to side with Tangled. I felt Tangled's pacing was much smoother for me and it had the right amount of character development. Frozen's pacing isn't as strong and I wish Kristoff had more development along with his relationship with Anna.

However, I think Frozen has much better music. I find myself listening to the songs to Frozen much more than the ones in Tangled. So I'll probably would say that Frozen is a better MUSICAL if that makes sense lol.

[moviefan12]

I like them both but I prefer Tangled much more. Just look at my list of favorite Disney movies in my sig and you'll see that it's my second favorite Disney film. Both films had great characters and I do enjoy the music in both of them but I think overall I enjoy Tangled's supporting cast more then Frozen's and the big thing that almost killed Frozen for me was the the twist with Hans that felt unneeded and going by that, Tangled had the better villain. I love both of them a lot but Tangled has a special place in my heart. After all, Rapunzel is one of my all time favorite characters as I love watching her journey from being scared of Mother Gothel to finally standing up to her and how Rapunzel is able to get Flynn to open up about his past and accept Eugene as a part of him. Again, I like Frozen and I love Elsa but I like Tangled more. It was very close as they are both great films and I love Rapunzel, Anna, and Elsa equally in terms of being great leads for their films.

[Disney's Divinity]

Before seeing Frozen, I expected my opinion would be "I dislikehate both equally," but now I just hate Tangled.

I do like Rapunzel and Maximus, but I feel Tangled also has Disney's worst prince, its worst (non-sequel) villainess, and its most forced romance. It doesn't help that Menken's music was held back by the directors' desire not to be too theatrical (hence "Mother Knows Best" being trimmed down in-film despite being the best song in the film) and Mandy Moore/Zachary Levi's singing voices. I suppose it is better-paced that Frozen, but not sure why that makes much difference overall when the story/characters are much less interesting.

[RyGuy]

Before seeing Frozen, I expected my opinion would be "I dislikehate both equally," but now I just hate Tangled.

I do like Rapunzel and Maximus, but I feel Tangled also has Disney's worst prince, its worst (non-sequel) villainess, and its most forced romance. It doesn't help that Menken's music was held back by the directors' desire not to be too theatrical (hence "Mother Knows Best" being trimmed down in-film despite being the best song in the film) and Mandy Moore/Zachary Levi's singing voices. I suppose it is better-paced that Frozen, but not sure why that makes much difference overall when the story/characters are much less interesting.

I think interesting depends on the person. I grew up in a conservative family, homeschool, worked for the fundamentalist organization that published our homeschool curriculum, etc. I've seen firsthand where parents/authority figures are overprotective/disingenuous or blatantly exaggerate about the "outside world" so I personally loved Tangled because I identified with a lot of its themes - figuring out the truth, breaking away, finding a happy ending after years of your life were stolen . . . It's probably why I love Mother Gothel as a villain. Because it's subtle and takes Rapunzel awhile to even realize that she is a villain (mirroring my own experience).

On the other hand, I don't have a sister and no one in my family is gay or has a mental illness (other than one in law I have little affinity for) or any of the other parallels folks on this board have drawn. I don't identify with Elsa in terms of having the weight of a secret you feel you can't reveal, or with Anna in terms of being the sibling who wants to support the family member who won't tell you what is going on.

Perhaps that is why I enjoy Tangled a little bit more. It feels a little bit more personal/interesting/emotional to me, based on my background (but others here, I could understand why Frozen resonates more).

[adamw92]

I really love both but for me, I prefer Frozen just a little bit more. Tangled will always remain one of the best DAC's in my opinion but I think something just clicked with me for Frozen, the music is far better and I think the characters are slightly more interesting, I prefer Mother Gothel as a villain but the overall story of Frozen and it's message as well as the characters as a whole just, for me, are a better package.

[Linden]

I think interesting depends on the person. I grew up in a conservative family, homeschool, worked for the fundamentalist organization that published our homeschool curriculum, etc. I've seen firsthand where parents/authority figures are overprotective/disingenuous or blatantly exaggerate about the "outside world" so I personally loved Tangled because I identified with a lot of its themes - figuring out the truth, breaking away, finding a happy ending after years of your life were stolen . . . It's probably why I love Mother Gothel as a villain. Because it's subtle and takes Rapunzel awhile to even realize that she is a villain (mirroring my own experience).

On the other hand, I don't have a sister and no one in my family is gay or has a mental illness (other than one in law I have little affinity for) or any of the other parallels folks on this board have drawn. I don't identify with Elsa in terms of having the weight of a secret you feel you can't reveal, or with Anna in terms of being the sibling who wants to support the family member who won't tell you what is going on.

Perhaps that is why I enjoy Tangled a little bit more. It feels a little bit more personal/interesting/emotional to me, based on my background (but others here, I could understand why Frozen resonates more).

Interesting you should bring that up. I was homeschooled from the 4th grade up. It's something I never talk about if I can help it. But, it's true that I can really relate to Rapunzel's character arc. The "bipolar" scene after she first escapes the tower is SO accurate. Mother Gothel is also one of my favourite villains because I know what it is to be isolated and afraid of the world and how dependent it makes you. To me, Mother Gothel is one of the most realistically scary villains.

That said, I still like Frozen better. I can absolutely relate to it, maybe even better than Tangled, because it's something that's currently going on in my life. The plot of Tangled is cliched, and even though I love Rapunzel's struggle, her personality and Flynn's seem more like tropes than personalities. That came across pretty harsh, but I actually love Tangled too. I just love Frozen more.

[RyGuy]

Interesting you should bring that up. I was homeschooled from the 4th grade up. It's something I never talk about if I can help it. But, it's true that I can really relate to Rapunzel's character arc. The "bipolar" scene after she first escapes the tower is SO accurate. Mother Gothel is also one of my favourite villains because I know what it is to be isolated and afraid of the world and how dependent it makes you. To me, Mother Gothel is one of the most realistically scary villains.

That said, I still like Frozen better. I can absolutely relate to it, maybe even better than Tangled, because it's something that's currently going on in my life. The plot of Tangled is cliched, and even though I love Rapunzel's struggle, her personality and Flynn's seem more like tropes than personalities. That came across pretty harsh, but I actually love Tangled too. I just love Frozen more.

Yeah, it's a part of my life I like to keep on the down low . (you weren't ATI, were you?).

I agree the music is better and Frozen is a GREAT movie (I've seen it NINE times so far). I love them both, but love Tangled slightly more just because of the way I personally related to it.

[Kyle]

Tangled. I think Glen keane had a lot to do with that for me. Also, I think Frozen had a few too many songs for my liking. Most were pretty good on their own but felt like filler in the context of the movie.

[Musical Master]

While I still really like Tangled in certain elements, Frozen is still my obvious choice due to reasons I have mentioned on the Frozen thread.

[disneyboy20022]

The Big reason I chose Frozen is because of the music that I just can't get out of my head. I really don't have the songs from Rapunzel in my head (except for when I have to go to the bathroom, I sing out loud deep inside everyone has to pee changing a couple lyrics to aggravate my girlfriend)

[sunhuntin]

frozen, by a country mile. ive always, always loved snow, ice and the whole winter world so this movie fills that longing within since we dont get it the same down here. the nearest snow for me is 3-4 hours away.
tangled is very well done, and i do love it, but frozen just has something more for me. there are a few too many songs for my tastes, but they are all enjoyable and catchy. the opening sequence with the ice men, and elsas castle... man, i was nearly crying from the beauty of it. and i do NOT cry. ever.

[rodis]

Frozen.

Animation - equally beautiful and expressive in both, with stunning visuals.

Music - Frozen, hands down. "Do You Wanna Build A Snowman?", "For The First Time In Forever", "Let It Go" and even "Fixer-Upper" are some of the best Disney songs in a long, long time. The reprise for FTFTIF is truly beautiful.
I like the music in "Tangled", but only thanks to "When Will My Life Begin" and "I See the Light".

Characters - Frozen. I don't like Rapunzel and can't stand Flynn Rider. He's the most annoying Disney prince out there.

Story - Tangled bores me starting with the "Snuggly Duckling" sequence until after she reunites with her mother. With Frozen, I was glued to the screen from start to finish.

[Atlantica]

Tangled. I think Glen keane had a lot to do with that for me. Also, I think Frozen had a few too many songs for my liking. Most were pretty good on their own but felt like filler in the context of the movie.

Very much agree with the above. Tangled is my favourite of the two, but thoroughly enjoy Frozen and love the film as well.

[Old Fish Tale]

'Rapunzel' (I'm still calling it that). It was better written (especially when it came to its climax) and had a better soundtrack and villain (I believe Hans worked too well as a nice man and, in my opinion, he should have been just that).

[DisneyEra]

I like both films, but you all must remember this: The only reason we got Frozen is because of the success of Tangled. Before that, Princess & the Frog, not only blamed for the death of 2D animation was also blame for killing the 2D verison of The Snow Queen.

http://www.blueskydisney.com/2010/02/ki ... ncess.html

When I read this the first time, I was pissed

[TsWade2]

I like both films, but you all must remember this: The only reason we got Frozen is because of the success of Tangled. Before that, Princess & the Frog, not only blamed for the death of 2D animation was also blame for killing the 2D verison of The Snow Queen.

http://www.blueskydisney.com/2010/02/ki ... ncess.html

When I read this the first time, I was pissed

Oh God! Please let's not go there! This makes me want to rant about the lack of hand drawn animation again.

[DisneyEra]

I like both films, but you all must remember this: The only reason we got Frozen is because of the success of Tangled. Before that, Princess & the Frog, not only blamed for the death of 2D animation was also blame for killing the 2D verison of The Snow Queen.

http://www.blueskydisney.com/2010/02/ki ... ncess.html

When I read this the first time, I was pissed

Oh God! Please let's not go there! This makes me want to rant about the lack of hand drawn animation again.

Atleast Disney's animated shorts are still 2D. Little Match Girl, Paperman & Get a Horse are amazing. I hope with BH6, they will release an original 2D animated short. This is the best place to start for 2D to attempt a comback as a feature film. And isn't this were 2D animation started at Disney, as shorts?

[Musical Master]

Oh God! Please let's not go there! This makes me want to rant about the lack of hand drawn animation again.

Atleast Disney's animated shorts are still 2D. Little Match Girl, Paperman & Get a Horse are amazing. I hope with BH6, they will release an original 2D animated short. This is the best place to start for 2D to attempt a comback as a feature film. And isn't this were 2D animation started at Disney, as shorts?

Walt Disney did begin his animation studio with nothing but a small crew of people, and a more than a decade after Steamboat; Snow White appeared, and changed everything. 2-D animation will return with a bang, I'm sure of it!

[TsWade2]

Oh God! Please let's not go there! This makes me want to rant about the lack of hand drawn animation again.

Atleast Disney's animated shorts are still 2D. Little Match Girl, Paperman & Get a Horse are amazing. I hope with BH6, they will release an original 2D animated short. This is the best place to start for 2D to attempt a comback as a feature film. And isn't this were 2D animation started at Disney, as shorts?

Well, of course. I just hope Get A Horse gets nominated and win a Oscar for Best Animated Short.

[Walter]

I chose "Frozen", as I find myself relating to Elsa better. Often isolating myself from having friends or getting into a long term relationship, as I tend to be my own worst enemy. Though the times when I do go out on my own, I do "let it go" and try not to care what others may think of me. Though if asked years ago, I would have related better to Rapunzel, as I used to ask myself the similar question, when will my life begin?

Also, I like the characters and songs better in "Frozen", and the voice acting was a lot better, as it did not annoy me at all. If there was any problem with it, it was that there were one too many songs at the first half of the film, but I did like all of them.

With "Tangled", I did like the story and some of the songs, and the animation is very nice. But it was the voice acting that took me out of the film. While I thought Mandy Moore was good, Zachary Levi stuck out like a sore thumb, making me feel like I am watching an animated version of Chuck Bartowski. And whenever he sings, that ruins the songs for me. "I See the Light" starts out as a beautiful song, but then, it nosedives. Also did not care for Donna Murphy either.