Most of them are, but So Dear to My Heart is that rare exception. The transfer/restoration was made for the cancelled-in-R1 Gold Collection DVD, and is better than some of the catalogue titles that came since. Mark Probst actually provided two comparison screencaps in this thread when it was first announced that the movie was a DMC exclusive:The_Iceflash wrote:I mean quality-wise. I know DMR/DMC exclusives tend have a track record of poor-quality transfers, etc.AliceinWonderland wrote:I enjoy it. Use to watch it on VHS when i was little. Same boy used in Song of the South and the voice of peter pan
Unfortunately, one of the extras prepped for the Gold Collection DVD wasn't carried over (thte 25-minute "Lost and Found" featurette), and was replaced with two cartoons that really have nothing to do with the movie aside from featuring trains ("Out of Scale" and "The Brave Engineer"). "Lost and Found" is on the R2/R4 releases, as well as Brazil's R1/R4 releasePoppins #1 wrote:Based on my experiences with other Disney Movie Club exclusives, I was afraid this might be another retread of an old transfer. But rest assured it’s not. It’s been remastered and looks wonderful. I assume this remastering effort is from some years back when it was prematurely announced that So Dear To My Heart was coming to DVD, then the region 1 release was mysteriously aborted. It is probably the same transfer that is currently available in Brazil and Europe. Colors are bright, the image is sharp and black levels are accurate, though there are a few blemishes here and there but nothing terribly obtrusive.
left: Disney Club DVD, right: 1990s Laserdisc
Even though I don't care for cover art, I dislike the Disney Movie Club version as it puts young Jeremiah in the background even though he's the main character. Makes it seem like Tildy is the main character. The Gold Collection cover was better.



albert