farerb wrote:This feels like a cash grab, but I guess 99% of all the production revealed the this investors day. I also always thought that starting with the remake of Beauty and the Beast, Disney has started a new era and it was pretty much confirmed yesterday. I never thought that a day would come where I'd feel put off by Disney, but I guess yesterday was that day. Disney just doesn't feel innovative and artistic to me anymore (Pixar included). It's really depressing to say it but that's how I feel.
Farerb, don't lose hope.
Remember that WDAS and Pixar ≠ Corporate Disney
Yes, both animation studios may need to bend their heads to the commercial demands of the parent company. They cannot operate like Cartoon Saloon or the other European studios, making movies for primarily for artistic reasons, and for commerce second. However, I believe that there is nevertheless no shortage of passion at both places.
It is very easy to write off mainstream American animated films as soulless, generic and unoriginal. And yes, often they can be. However, I would never blame this on the people that actually make them. The filmmakers tend to be faced with many limitations and I believe that even on the most commercial projects (think the Cars franchise) they truly give their all to create worthwhile, even great films.
I am not saying that we should celebrate mediocrity or that the American animation studios are absolved of subpar films "because they are faced with limitations so they can't help it."
It is more about appreciating the good things about the WDAS and Pixar films and understanding that when they do not satisfy you it is not a black or white assessment of "This film sucks! The character designs are generic! The concept is so lazy!"
God knows what goes on behind the scenes of these movies' production. I simply don't think it is realistic to expect Cartoon Saloon or Studio Ghibli poetic filmmaking from these studios. I am certain the people there are more than capable of delivering an "arty" film like those studios, but I know they cannot (unless there's a major shift in the parent company.

) So, I evaluate mainstream American animation accordingly, and I don't think it is fair to compare them with foreign animated films.
Also, try not to dislike a movie too much based on its premise, or even trailer.
I firmly feel that on this board we tend to grossly over-analyse based on a three-sentence premise and with nothing else at hand. (I'm thinking of
Luca.) I truly think it is a waste of time and energy to write reams of text speculating based on a vague synopsis, and actively disliking the movie at that early stage. People jump to conclusions so quickly here! I wouldn't do that even an hour before the film's release and with a bajillion released teasers and trailers at my disposal, let alone with just a text description!!
So people, please calm down.

Enjoy the announcements and don't write movies off 2+ years prior to release. Even when you know for a fact that they contain story elements that are not your cup of tea, you may be surprised because in the finished film those "disliked" story elements may be executed in a way you actually like and not as you predicted!
I've been wanting to get that off my chest for soooooo long!

I think I should repost this in some other threads to make sure everybody reads it! I'll spam this place up!
