All About Eve
I rewatched it all the day before yesterday. I think my issue is, well, the entire crux of the movie. It presents the ageism and sexism women face in the entertainment industry and lays the blame for those ills squarely at women’s feet. The movie says there is a vicious cycle of steely-eyed ambitious women out to manipulate the men in their lives and throw other women under the bus to get what they want which is a particularly vain brand of stardom. To break the cycle, a woman must leave her profession and become a “real woman”— a wife, a homemaker, ultimately kept. But this is, well, bullocks then and now. “All About Eve” is about the theatre, but in the movie world which the film is just as much about, women were bullied and pitted against one another by and for the benefit of the movie moguls who were men. But in this film, men are the real victims, like sailors drawn in by sirens, like Adam to Eve, they cannot be held responsible for succumbing to the wiles of women. Unless they are gay men— over which women can hold no power and may assume a sort of omnipresent puppet master status and could almost be revered if they weren’t otherwise so contemptible. And I still don’t think the script is very funny.
Bette Davis gets lost in the movie, which is a shame. I haven’t watched a Davis movie in awhile so I almost forgot that her staccato way of speaking was a thing she actually did— not just an over exaggeration by later female impersonators. I wish we still had movie stars like her— unique, authentic, original personalities. Bette Davis in particular was a force of nature.
I don’t care for Anne Baxter much— I remember her from The Ten Commandments and I always thought that Cecil B. DeMille had directed everyone to act as though the movie was being made in the 1920’s, with a big sort of over dramatic acting style which is perfect for a biblical epic. But she plays Eve Harrington the same way— she is going at 100% all the time which makes some of her later scenes confusing. If she’s such a capable person, such a smart, manipulative wit— she never loses her cool acting as Davis’ puppy dog— how can she make so many strategic mistakes that unravel her in the end? I think it would have been a lot more interesting to have seen an Eve Harrington who actually was an unassuming doe, a character who never had some ultimate plan, but instead gradually became intoxicated with the stardom surrounding her and became more manipulative as the plot progressed. Obviously, this wouldn’t have fixed the inherent sexism of the character but it would have at least been an actual character arc— but that is more on Mankiewicz’s head than Baxter’s.
George Sanders is very good in a role which is uncomfortably gay coded. Celeste Holm’s character seems very stupid for a person we are told is very smart, or at least sophisticated— but at least she and her husband appear to deserve one another. I agree that Davis and her onscreen and apparently offscreen (thanks for that info, I didn’t know that, Divinity) husband have pretty wonderful chemistry. I didn’t mind Eve messing around with the playwright, but I was going to be heartbroken if she succeeded in splitting up the actress and the director.
Thelma Ritter is delightful and her presence is missed when her character disappears. I always forget Marilyn is in the movie until she’s onscreen and... I don’t know why, but I’m always struck by just how much of “Marilyn” she already is at this point, starring in one of her first movie roles.
Unfortunately, All About Eve is still not for me but I am eager to hear what people think of my take. It’s such a beloved and revered film I’m convinced I’m missing something or not understanding something about the movie. Maybe in another 10 years I’ll at least get the jokes.
Escapay wrote:
Parasite better with Best Picture at the Academy Awards next week. It's pretty much a lock for Best International Feature Film, but imagine if it won both.
Ever since IMDb shuttered their message boards, I no longer closely follow the Oscar race. I’ve tried Gold Derby a few times, but their online community didn’t impress me compared to the posters I used to read on Oscar Buzz/Movie Awards. So nowadays I just let the nominees and winners surprise me.
This is all just to say: I don’t know who is likely to win, and because I haven’t seen most of the films nominated for the top prize, I can’t really say which one I think most deserves it. But Parasite would definitely be a worthy winner.
Disney's Divinity wrote:I feel bad that I haven't seen Sunset Boulevard. I've heard they're making a new version of the film with Glenn Close, aren't they? I need to keep the look out so I can catch the original next time it's airing.
It is meant to be a movie version of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s musical adaptation of the movie. But the movie was announced a year ago before Glenn Close surprisingly lost the Oscar to Olivia Colman and before Lloyd Webber’s Cats bombed, so I doubt we will ever see it come to fruition. There hasn’t been any announcements since then.
But the original Sunset Boulevard is an excellent movie. There’s a great story about the director Billy Wilder initially wanting Mary Pickford for the main role and going to her home to pitch the film. Over the course of their conversation, Pickford complained about the degeneracy of contemporary filmmaking and he then knew then she’d never agree to the role so he ended up just not pitching it to her. But with Gloria Swanson ultimately landing the role, it is hard to imagine anyone else being quite so perfect. I like the musical, too, my favorite Norma onstage is Patti LuPone.
Do you watch these movies on TCM, Divinity?
The Princess Diaries series
I rewatched the Princess Diaries and part of its sequel yesterday. The first film has actually aged pretty well, I think, or it could be my nostalgia speaking. So far, PD2 isn’t quite as bad as I remember but it’s still a lackluster follow up to its predecessor.
Mary Poppins
I want to come back to the Mary Poppins discussion because I have a lot of thoughts on that and it will take some time to write out.