Rate The "Other Animation" Features!

[AwallaceUNC]

Ok, we did it for the Animated Classics, now I say we rate the "Other Animation" list, as we all have strong opinions on these two! There aren't as many (see the list: http://www.ultimatedisney.com/ultimateanimated.htm)

On a scale of one to ten...

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 8/10
James and the Giant Peach - 8.5/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 10/10
A Goofy Movie - 7.5/10
Doug's 1st Movie - Haven't Seen
The Brave Little Toaster - 6.5/10
The Tigger Movie - Haven't Seen
Recess: School's Out - Haven't Seen
Return To Neverland - 4/10
Piglet's Big Movie - Haven't Seen
The Jungle Book 2 - Haven't Seen
Teacher's Pet - Haven't Seen
Dinosaur - 8/10
A Bug's Life - 8.5/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Monsters, Inc - 5.5/10
Finding Nemo - 9.5/10

-Aaron

ADDENDUM: These are all rated in comparison with the others in their genre for me, not against the animated classics. That wouldn't be fair.

[Jack]

UPDATE!

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 6.75/10
James and the Giant Peach - 6/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 7.5/10
A Goofy Movie - 8/10
Doug's 1st Movie - Haven't Seen Yet
The Brave Little Toaster - 7/10
The Tigger Movie - Haven't Seen Yet
Recess: School's Out - Haven't Seen Yet
Return To Neverland - Haven't Seen Yet
Piglet's Big Movie - 5.75/10
The Jungle Book 2 - Haven't Seen Yet
Teacher's Pet - Haven't Seen Yet
Dinosaur - 6/10
A Bug's Life - 10/10
Toy Story - 9.5/10
Toy Story 2 - 8.5/10
Monsters, Inc - 9/10
Finding Nemo - 7/10
The Incredibles - 9/10

[castleinthesky]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 9/10
James and the Giant Peach - 8/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 10/10
A Goofy Movie - 8/10
Doug's 1st Movie - 7/10
The Brave Little Toaster - 8/10
The Tigger Movie - 6/10
Recess: School's Out - Don't care about
Return To Neverland - 5/10
Piglet's Big Movie - Haven't Seen
The Jungle Book 2 - 8/10
Teacher's Pet - Don't care about
Dinosaur - 9/10
A Bug's Life - 2/10
Toy Story - 3/10
Toy Story - 2/10
Monsters, Inc - 1/10
Finding Nemo - 0/10

[Sekaino Jasmine]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - Haven't seen yet(am I lame or what? Wait, don't answer that! )
James and the Giant Peach - 8/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 10/10
A Goofy Movie - 7/10
Doug's 1st Movie - 4/10
The Brave Little Toaster - 9/10
The Tigger Movie - 7/10
Recess: School's Out - 3/10
Return To Neverland - 7/10
Piglet's Big Movie - 5/10
The Jungle Book 2 - 9/10
Teacher's Pet - (Haven't seen yet)
Dinosaur - 7/10
A Bug's Life - 8/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Monsters, Inc - 10/10
Finding Nemo - 6/10

[Disneykid]

Monsters, Inc - 5.5/10

You really didn't like Monsters, Inc.? Needless to say I'm in shock.


Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 8/10 (Haven't seen this in ages, though)
James and the Giant Peach - 9/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 6/10
A Goofy Movie - 7/10
Doug's 1st Movie -Haven't seen it
The Brave Little Toaster - 8/10
The Tigger Movie - 7/10
Recess: School's Out - Haven't seen it
Return To Neverland - 5/10
Piglet's Big Movie - 7/10
The Jungle Book 2 - 6/10
Teacher's Pet - Haven't seen it
Dinosaur - 6/10
A Bug's Life - 9/10
Toy Story - 9/10
Toy Story 2 - 9/10
Monsters, Inc - 10/10
Finding Nemo - 10/10
The Incredibles - 10/10

[wwwjim]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 6/10
James and the Giant Peach - 6/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 6/10
A Goofy Movie - 7/10
Doug's 1st Movie - 6/10
The Brave Little Toaster - 8/10
The Tigger Movie - 5/10
Recess: School's Out - 4/10
Return To Neverland - Haven't Seen
Piglet's Big Movie - 5/10
The Jungle Book 2 - Haven't Seen
Teacher's Pet - Haven't Seen
Dinosaur - 8/10
A Bug's Life - 8/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Toy Story 2- 8/10
Monsters, Inc - 8/10
Finding Nemo - 10/10

[MickeyMousePal]

Here's my rate for Other Disney Animated films


Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 10/10 ( I'm a DuckTales Fan)
James and the Giant Peach - 8/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 10/10
A Goofy Movie - 9/10
Doug's 1st Movie - 7/10
The Brave Little Toaster - 7/10
The Tigger Movie - 8/10
Recess: School's Out - 8/10
Return To Neverland - 7/10
Piglet's Big Movie - 8/10
The Jungle Book 2 - 9/10
Teacher's Pet - 8/10
Dinosaur - 8/10
A Bug's Life - 8/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Monsters, Inc - 9/10
Finding Nemo - 9/10
The Incredibles- 10/10

[Jordan]

Here's my opinion :

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 5/10
James and the Giant Peach - 8/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 8/10
A Goofy Movie - 5/10
Doug's 1st Movie - Haven't Seen It
The Brave Little Toaster - Haven't Seen It
The Tigger Movie - Haven't Seen It
Recess: School's Out - Haven't Seen It
Return To Neverland - 3,5/10
Piglet's Big Movie - 3/10
The Jungle Book 2 - 4/10
Teacher's Pet - Haven't Seen It
Dinosaur - 8/10
A Bug's Life - 8.5/10
Toy Story - 9/10
Toy Story 2 - 9,5/10
Monsters, Inc - 9,5/10
Finding Nemo - 10/10

[AwallaceUNC]

Monsters, Inc - 5.5/10

You really didn't like Monsters, Inc.? Needless to say I'm in shock.

Yeah, I just wasn't crazy about it. However, I've gotta say I didn't give it enough of a chance. I went into it thinking I wouldn't like it, and was also distracted with doing things and didn't give it full attention. That's something I normally wouldn't do for a movie, but like I said, I didn't think I'd like it anyways. I plan on going back and rewatching it some time to give it more of a chance.

-Aaron

[orestes.]

The thread has been revived!

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 10/10
I'm a huge DuckTales fan and this movie just helped me feed my love of it.

James and the Giant Peach - 9.5/10

The Nightmare Before Christmas - 10/10

A Goofy Movie - 9.5/10

Doug's 1st Movie - I haven't seen it but I really liked the shows.

The Brave Little Toaster - 6/10
I was never really a fan of the toaster movies.

The Tigger Movie - 8.5/10
I love it but it can't compare to the mighty original Pooh.

Recess: School's Out - Have not seen and don't care if I ever do.

Return To Neverland - Not seen but want to.

Piglet's Big Movie - Haven't see and I'm a Pooh fan.

The Jungle Book 2 - Meh, not sure if I want to see it.

Teacher's Pet - Have not seen yet.

Dinosaur - 8/10

A Bug's Life - 8/10

Toy Story - 9/10

Toy Story 2 - 9/10

Monsters, Inc - 8.5/10

Finding Nemo - 10/10
Faveourite Pixar movie.

[Jack]

Updated my earlier post with revised grades, as well as new ones for movies I've seen since March 18, 2004 (including The Incredibles!)

[Siren]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 8/10
James and the Giant Peach - 4/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 10/10
A Goofy Movie - 8/10
Doug's 1st Movie - Haven't seen it, don't plan to
The Brave Little Toaster - 8/10 I love the scene with the junk cars
The Tigger Movie - Haven't seen it, don't plan to, when is Eeyore gonna get a spotlight? No wonder why he's depressed
Recess: School's Out - Haven't seen it, don't plan to
Return To Neverland - 8/10, I actually liked this one. Though I hated the Octopus
Piglet's Big Movie - Haven't seen it, refer to Tigger Movie
The Jungle Book 2 - 3/10
Teacher's Pet - Haven't seen it, rather see Tigger Movie
Dinosaur - 8/10 Beautiful animation, but same old Land Before Time Story, and their scientific inaccuracies bothered me.
A Bug's Life - 6/10 cute, but it was...eh
Toy Story - 9/10
Toy Story 2 - 8.5/10 Jessie annoyed me at times, but I loved her song
Monsters, Inc - 9/10 KITTY! Movie came out when my daughter was about that age and she looks just like Boo. How could I not be drawn to it?
Finding Nemo - 9/10
The Incredibles - 9/10

[Key]

Duck Tales: The Movie - N/A
James and the Giant Peach - 8/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 10/10
A Goofy Movie - 7.5/10
Doug's 1st Movie - N/A
The Brave Little Toaster - 7.5/10
The Tigger Movie - N/A
Recess: School's Out - N/A
Return To Neverland - N/A
Piglet's Big Movie - N/A
The Jungle Book 2 - N/A
Teacher's Pet - N/A
Dinosaur - N/A
A Bug's Life - 8.5/10
Toy Story - 9/10
Toy Story 2 - 9.5/10
Monsters, Inc. - 8.5/10
Finding Nemo - 9/10
The Incredibles - 10/10

Jeez... I havne't seen quite a few things!

[Satoshi]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 8/10 (haven't seen in ages though)
James and the Giant Peach - Haven't seen
The Nightmare Before Christmas - Haven't seen
A Goofy Movie - 8.25/10
Doug's 1st Movie - 7/10 (it's been a while)
The Brave Little Toaster - Haven't seen
The Tigger Movie - Haven't seen
Recess: School's Out - 7.75/10
Return To Neverland - 7.75/10
Piglet's Big Movie - Haven't Seen
The Jungle Book 2 - Haven't seen
Teacher's Pet - Haven't seen
Dinosaur - Haven't seen
A Bug's Life - 8/10
Toy Story - 9/10
Toy Story 2 - 9.25/10
Monsters, Inc - 9/10
Finding Nemo - 7/10
The Incredibles - 8.75/10

[akhenaten]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp
- 8/10 <--based on memory.last saw it in 1994

James and the Giant Peach
- 9.5/10 <---live action sequence is a bit off.

The Nightmare Before Christmas - 10/10

A Goofy Movie - 10/10

Doug's 1st Movie
- 4/10

The Brave Little Toaster
- 5/10

The Tigger Movie
- 5/10

Recess: School's Out - Haven't Seen

Return To Neverland
- 2/10 <---an insult to Peter Pan, one of my favs.

Piglet's Big Movie - Haven't Seen

The Jungle Book 2
- 1/10

Teacher's Pet - Haven't Seen

Dinosaur - 5/10

A Bug's Life - 10/10

Toy Story - 10/10

Toy Story - 10/10

Monsters, Inc - 10/10

Finding Nemo - 7/10

The Incredibles - 8.5/10

[Wonderlicious]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 7.5/10
James and the Giant Peach - 7/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 9/10
A Goofy Movie - 5/10
Doug's 1st Movie - Haven't Seen
The Brave Little Toaster - 7/10
The Tigger Movie - 5/10
Recess: School's Out - Haven't Seen
Return To Neverland - Haven't Seen
Piglet's Big Movie - Haven't Seen
The Jungle Book 2 - Haven't Seen
Teacher's Pet - Haven't Seen
Dinosaur - 7/10
A Bug's Life - 9/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Toy Story 2- 10/10
Monsters, Inc - 9/10
Finding Nemo - 9.5/10
The Incredibles- 8.5/10

[ichabod]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp - 6.5/10
James and the Giant Peach - 4/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas - 9.5/10
A Goofy Movie - 7/10
Doug's 1st Movie - Haven't Seen
The Brave Little Toaster - 6.5/10
The Tigger Movie - 8.5/10
Recess: School's Out - Haven't Seen
Return To Neverland - 7/10
Piglet's Big Movie - 6.5/10
The Jungle Book 2 - 6/10
Teacher's Pet - 8/10
Dinosaur - 8/10
A Bug's Life - 10/10
Toy Story - 9/10
Toy Story 2 - 9.5/10
Monsters, Inc - 5.5/10
Finding Nemo - 9/10
The Incredibles - 7/10

[DDMAN26]

Duck Tales: The Movie- Treasure of the Lost Lamp -5/10
James and the Giant Peach - 7/10
The Nightmare Before Christmas -9/10
A Goofy Movie -7/10
Doug's 1st Movie - Never Seen
The Brave Little Toaster - 6/10
The Tigger Movie - 7/10
Recess: School's Out - 5/10
Return To Neverland - 6/10
Piglet's Big Movie - 6/10
The Jungle Book 2 -4/10
Teacher's Pet - Never Seen
Dinosaur - 7/10
A Bug's Life - 8/10
Toy Story - 10/10
Toy Story 2 -10/10
Monsters, Inc - 9/10
Finding Nemo -10/10
The Incredibles - 10/10

[MickeyMousePal]

Just Updated my post...