Rank Disney's 2-Disc Sets!

[Jack]

Rank the 2-Disc sets released by Disney! Since the Walt Disney Treasures are quite different in nature than all the other DVD sets, we'll leave those out.

Please make your judgement based on Video, Audio, and Extras - not the movie itself.

Here's a list of all the movies that have 2-Disc Sets. They are indexed in chronological order, which the movie titles followed by the 2-Disc Set's label.

ANIMATED CLASSICS
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Platinum Edition
Alice in Wonderland Masterpiece Edition
Sleeping Beauty Special Edition
Beauty and the Beast Platinum Edition
Aladdin Platinum Edition
The Lion King Platinum Edition
Mulan Special Edition
Tarzan Collector's Edition
The Emperor's New Groove Collector's Edition
Atlantis: The Lost Empire Collector's Edition
Brother Bear Special Edition

PIXAR
A Bug's Life Collector's Edition
Monsters, Inc. Collector's Edition
Finding Nemo Collector's Edition

DIRECT TO VIDEO
The Lion King 1 1/2
The Lion King 2: Simba's Pride Special Edition

OTHER ANIMATION
Castle in the Sky Special Edition
Kiki's Delivery Service Special Edition
Dinosaur Collector's Edition
Spirited Away Special Edition

LIVE-ACTION
20,000 Leagues Under the Sea Special Edition
Old Yeller Vault Disney Collection
Pollyanna Vault Disney Collection
Swiss Family Robinson Vault Disney Collection
The Parent Trap Vault Disney Collection
The Love Bug Special Edition
Tron Anniversary Edition
The Princess Diaries Special Edition
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Collector's Edition
Ghosts of the Abyss
Miracle

[Jack]

My Top 10 (I'll post 11-20 later):

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Platinum Edition
2. 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea Special Edition
3. Atlantis: The Lost Empire Collector's Edition
4. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Collector's Edition
5. Swiss Family Robinson Vault Disney Collection
6. A Bug's Life Collector's Edition
7. Aladdin Platinum Edition
8. Sleeping Beauty Special Edition
9. Monsters, Inc. Collector's Edition
10. Tarzan Collector's Edition

[Disneykid]

Awesome thread idea, Jack!

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Platinum Edition
2. Aladdin Platinum Edition
3. Atlantis: The Lost Empire Collector's Edition
4. Dinosaur Collector's Edition
5. Monsters, Inc. Collector's Edition
6. Beauty and the Beast Platinum Edition
7. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Collector's Edition
8. The Emperor's New Groove Collector's Edition
9. Sleeping Beauty Special Edition
10. Tarzan Collector's Edition
12. Pollyanna Vault Disney Collection
12. The Parent Trap Vault Disney Collection
13. A Bug's Life Collector's Edition
14. The Lion King Platinum Edition
15. Mulan: Special Edition
16. Alice in Wonderland Masterpiece Edition
17. Finding Nemo Collector's Edition
18. The Princess Diaries Special Edition
19. Brother Bear Special Edition
20. Spirited Away
21. Kiki's Delivery Service

[Luke]

<i>Aladdin</i> Platinum Edition
<i>Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs</i> Platinum Edition
<i>Monsters, Inc.</i> Collector's Edition
<i>Finding Nemo</i> Collector's Edition
<i>A Bug's Life</i> Collector's Edition
<i>The Parent Trap</i> Vault Disney
<i>Swiss Family Robinson</i> Vault Disney
<i>Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl</i> Collector's Edition
<i>The Lion King</i> Platinum Edition
<i>Dinosaur</i> Collector's Edition

I definitely need to revisit several of these sets. It's been years since I watched some of the extras, and I haven't finished going through a few.

Just a couple that you're missing in your lists (though they might not be people's choices)
<i>Tron</i> 20th Anniversary Edition
<i>Ghosts of the Abyss</i>
<i>The Princess Diaries</i>

[MickeyMousePal]

Here's my ranking:

1. The Lion King Platinum Edition
2. Aladdin Platinum Edition
3. Beauty and the Beast Platinum Edition
4. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Platinum Edition
5. Mulan Special Edition
6. Sleeping Beauty Special Edition
7. Brother Bear Special Edition
8. Monsters, Inc. Collector's Edition
9. Finding Nemo Collector's Edition
10. Alice in Wonderland Masterpiece Edition
11. A Bug's Life Collector's Edition
12. Castle in the Sky Special Edition
13. Kiki's Delivery Service Special Edition
14. The Lion King 2: Simba's Pride Special Edition
15. Spirited Away Special Edition
16. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Collector's Edition
17. Miracle
18. Old Yeller Vault Disney Collection
19. 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea Special Edition
20. The Lion King 1 1/2

[ichabod]

1. Aladdin Platinum Edition
2. Beauty and the Beast Platinum Edition
3. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Platinum Edition
4. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Collector's Edition
5. 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea Special Edition
6. Atlantis: The Lost Empire Collector's Edition
7. Dinosaur Collector's Edition
8. The Emperor's New Groove Collector's Edition
9. Pollyanna Vault Disney Collection
10. The Parent Trap Vault Disney Collection
11. Old Yeller Vault Disney Collection
12. Finding Nemo Collector's Edition
13. Sleeping Beauty Special Edition
14. Monsters, Inc. Collector's Edition
15. Tron Anniversary Edition
16. The Lion King Platinum Edition
17. Tarzan Collector's Edition
18. The Love Bug Special Edition
19. A Bug's Life Collector's Edition
20. Spirited Away Special Edition
21. The Lion King 2: Simba's Pride Special Edition
22. The Lion King 1 1/2

Whew! That was hard!

[DisneyChris]

1. Aladdin Platinum Edition
2. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Platinum Edition
3. A Bug's Life Collector's Edition
4. Monsters, Inc. Collector's Edition
5. Beauty and the Beast Platinum Edition
6. The Lion King Platinum Edition
7. Spirited Away Special Edition
8. Finding Nemo Collector's Edition
9. Mulan Special Edition
10. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Collector's Edition
11. The Lion King 1 1/2

Haven't got the others.

[Jack]

Just a couple that you're missing in your lists (though they might not be people's choices)
<i>Tron</i> 20th Anniversary Edition
<i>Ghosts of the Abyss</i>
<i>The Princess Diaries</i>

Thanks, Luke! I just KNEW I missed something. Added those titles to the Live-Action list.

[2099net]

I'm only going to do my top 5:

Altantis: The Lost Empire
Tron: 20th Anniversary Edition
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Sleeping Beauty
Aladdin

[ThiagoPE]

1- Aladdin
2- Beauty and the beast
3- Finding nemo
4- Monsters Inc
5- The Lion King
6- The lion king 1 1/2


At least, for a while, that is my list

[Wonderlicious]

Of the ones I've seen-

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs: PE
2. Aladdin: PE
3. Beauty and the Beast: PE
4. Alice in Wonderland: ME
5. Mulan: SE
6. Sleeping Beauty: SE
7. The Lion King: PE

I've only started to collect/watch Disney DVDs, so bare that in mind.

[Joe Carioca]

Considering that I still have to get "Mulan", "Dinosaur" and "The Love Bug" and that the remaining others have no interest to me (at least not until I get rich and am able to buy every region 1 release, hehe) , this is my list of favorite two-disc sets so far.

I'm not judging the films themselves, only the DVDs (and that includes picture, sound and extras quality). By the way, I've included the French "Peter Pan" in my list.

1 - Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs: Platinum Edition
2 - Atlantis, The Lost Empire: Collector's Edition
3 - Aladdin: Platinum Edition
4 - 20,000 Leagues Under The Sea: Special Edition
5 - Tarzan: Collector's Edition
6 - Swiss Family Robinson: Vault Disney
7 - Sleeping Beauty: Special Edition
8 - A Bug's Life: Collector's Edition
9 - Beauty and the Beast: Platinum Edition
10 - Monsters, Inc.: Collector's Edition
11 - The Lion King: Platinum Edition
12 - The Emperor's New Groove: The Ultimate Groove
13 - Pirates of the Caribbean: Collector's Edition
14 - Alice In Wonderland: The Masterpiece Edition
15 - Finding Nemo: Collector's Edition
16 - The Parent Trap: Vault Disney
17 - Pollyanna: Vault Disney
18 - Brother Bear: Special Edition
19 - Who Framed Roger Rabbit: VISTA Series
20 - Peter Pan: Collector's Edition
21 - Old Yeller: Vault Disney
22 - The Lion King 2, Simba's Pride: Special Edition
23 - The Lion King 1 1/2: Special Edition

In my opinion, all of these are great sets and it was difficult to rank them according only to the quality of the DVDs, since some of my favorite films got some of the lowest grades (like Brother Bear, Peter Pan and Old Yeller).

Some of the sets lost a few points due to a few problems with the picture (Beauty and the Beast, Pirates of the Caribbean, Brother Bear and Old Yeller), while others, even if they are great releases indeed, didn't have all the care in their production like some of the top titles (Alice in Wonderland, Peter Pan). All in all, I'm very satisfied with all the releases above and hope Disney will continue its trend of quality with the next DVDs.

[Ciaobelli]

-Fantasia Anthology (can this one count??, it is basically 2 discs per movie, kinda)
-Snow White
-Aladdin
-Tarzan CE
-Bugs Life CE
-Sleeping beauty (alot of great superfluous material)


S you can see the CEs are the best of ALL!! No fluff, all great stuff!!! I wish they would be back

[Condor Hero]

1) Beauty and the Beast Platinum Edition
2) Aladdin Platinum Edition
3) Mulan Special Edition
4) Finding Nemo Collector's Edition
5) Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl Collector's Edition
6) The Lion King Platinum Edition
7) Monsters, Inc. Collector's Edition
8) Alice in Wonderland Masterpiece Edition
9) A Bug's Life Collector's Edition
10) Sleeping Beauty Special Edition
11) Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs Platinum Edition
12) Brother Bear Special Edition

[Jack]

Okay, here's my 11-20 listing. Some of these I don't own, but through reviews, its easy to tell they are high in quality.

11. Beauty and the Beast Platinum Edition
12. The Emperor's New Groove Collector's Edition
13. Dinosaur Collector's Edition
14. Tron Anniversary Edition
15. Old Yeller Vault Disney Collection
16. The Parent Trap Vault Disney Collection
17. Brother Bear Special Edition
18. Finding Nemo Collector's Edition
19. Mulan Special Edition
20. Alice in Wonderland Masterpiece Edition

[Sh00tingstar]

you forgot the grave of the firelies 2 disk set...that one is awesome

[Disneykid]

Grave of the Fireflies isn't a Disney DVD whereas Castle in the Sky, Kiki's Delivery Service, and Spirited Away are.

[DreamerQ18]

Here are just a few of mine:

1.Beauty and the Beast PE
2.Aladdin PE
3.Brother Bear
4.Alice in Wonderland
5.Finding Nemo
6.The Lion King
7.Mulan

Yeah I think thats mine for now Lucky 7

[Narfle the Garthok]

The Swiss Family Robinson
The parent Trap
Alice in Wonderland
TRON