I decided to make a subjective list since I've only ever ranked this trying to be "objective." I admit I'm more of a songs person, so great songs/poor score trump meh songs/great score for me.
1.
The Little Mermaid ~ Carroll, Benson, and Wright are all so phenomenal, Benson's voice is just gorgeous and one-of-a-kind. POYW and PUS are just straight up masterpieces; for me, those three are better than anything in B&TB, although I can sort of concede that looking at all the songs combined, B&TB is more even across the board.
2.
Beauty and the Beast ~ Not a weak song in this. The only one that comes to giving me as much
personal attachment as POYW and PUS though is Lansbury's B&tB.
3.
Frozen ~ I remember going into this film expecting to at least like the soundtrack because of Menzel. Menzel was great, but I was shocked how much I loved Bell's voice, too, the combination of them on FtFTiF is my favorite part of the film, although LIG is incredible, too. Fontana's voice is great also, and Groff/Gad are both solid.
4.
Mulan ~ I always had a strong attachment to this film's soundtrack even if it feels fairly short (almost like there should've been one more song near the end or something?). "Honor to Us All" and "Reflection" are two of the best Disney songs, imo, and "Mulan's Decision" is the highlight of the film.
5.
Pocahontas ~ Kuhn's voice is incredible much like Menzel's, both strong belters. "Just Around the Riverbend" is my favorite song, most of the other songs with Kuhn are eargasms as well, mixed bag of songs. I personally always liked Ratcliffe's songs even if I find Ratcliffe unsatisfying as a villain. Or, rather, the actor does a great job as a villain, just maybe should've been in a less serious film than this one was.
6.
Frozen II
7.
Aladdin ~ Love Kane's voice as much as Benson's. I wonder what
those two would've sounded like on a duet.
8.
Encanto
9.
The Princess and the Frog
10.
Cinderella
11.
Enchanted
12.
Wish
13.
Tangled
14.
Raya and the Last Dragon ~ The score at the very end got me and I do like the End Credits song even if it's imperfect.
15.
Moana
16.
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs ~ I do like SW's songs, they are very hummable. "I'm Wishing/One Song" is the only song from this film that I love though.
17.
Disenchanted
18.
Sleeping Beauty ~ The score is incredible, but I never really liked any of the songs, unfortunately.
19.
Ralph Breaks the Internet
Thinking about it now as I'm looking at my list, I'm not really surprised with the ones at the bottom since Moana, SW, Aurora, and Vanellope are the characters whose voices I liked the least of the princesses (Rapunzel being another one, although Moore impressed me in the TV series, so my opinion has turned around a little bit on her), so, being a more songs-focused person like I am, it's probably not really a surprise I listen to their films' soundtracks less than the others. I do like some songs from those films though. SB is harder--the songs I enjoy with that property are actually from the Legacy Collection release (the deleted song, "Riddle, Diddle," and the "Love Theme"). The choral songs at the opening are fairly nice, too. I wasn't crazy about Mirabel's singing voice either; I guess that explains why most of my favorites from the film don't feature her much.
@
Duster: So you've played Hogwarts Legacy, neat!

I hope you got some fun out of it. I thought it was surprisingly good, but I like collecting-type games (the same reason I enjoy making lists, I guess!

).