

https://www.ign.com/videos/2018/11/19/j ... princesses
To me, it sounded like Kermit the Frog doing a Ralph impression.Sotiris wrote:
That John C. Reilly soundalike was so bad!.
The moment where the princesses shout with glee they don't have moms was particularly cringe-worthy, tasteless, and frankly inappropriate. They made a joke out of their moms dying, for crying out loud. What were the filmmakers thinking?D82 wrote:I'm sorry, but I don't like it at all. The things I disliked the most about the scene are still there. I doubt the second half will make me change my mind about the portrayal of the Pricesses.
And I really really hope I'm not unconsciously forcing you guys to like it.D82 wrote:And I'm glad at least you can enjoy it.disneyprincess11 wrote:It’s totally fine you guys don’t like it.
Yeah, I don't get why the cast and crew keep bringing their waists up? They literally do nothing to fix it or even bring it up in the movie. Jasmine's waist looks just aa bad in the movie.DisneyEra wrote:John C. Riley is happy that Ralph Breaks the Internet has redeemed the Disney PrincessesSo, you have a problem with they're looks John?
![]()
https://www.ign.com/videos/2018/11/19/j ... princesses
I personally find that moment funny, but I do get the problem. Especially that we see Anna and Elsa die and mourn for them and we'll explore their mom in the sequel apparently. Even someone on Tumblr or Twitter brought up why would the girls be chirpy about their deceased parents?Sotiris wrote:The moment where the princesses shout with glee they don't have moms was particularly cringe-worthy, tasteless, and frankly inappropriate. They made a joke out of their moms dying, for crying out loud. What were the filmmakers thinking?D82 wrote:I'm sorry, but I don't like it at all. The things I disliked the most about the scene are still there. I doubt the second half will make me change my mind about the portrayal of the Pricesses.
Exactly. Like, I get the joke. They're poking fun at the dead mom trope which has heavily been mocked and criticized in pop culture but they're doing so at the expense of characterization, creating in the process unsettling in-universe implications.disneyprincess11 wrote:I personally find that moment funny, but I do get the problem. Especially that we see Anna and Elsa die and mourn for them and we'll explore their mom in the sequel apparently. Even someone on Tumblr or Twitter brought up why would the girls be chirpy about their deceased parents?
For the sake of getting away from the cynical side of the net, I'm just going to make a list of all the Disney movies I can think of that don't kill of parents. This includes live action (some of the more major ones. If i listed every one of them, I'll be here all night.), animated canon, Pixar and miscellaneous:Sotiris wrote:Exactly. Like, I get the joke. They're poking fun at the dead mom trope which has heavily been mocked and criticized in pop culture but they're doing so at the expense of characterization, creating in the process unsettling implications in-universe.disneyprincess11 wrote:I personally find that moment funny, but I do get the problem. Especially that we see Anna and Elsa die and mourn for them and we'll explore their mom in the sequel apparently. Even someone on Tumblr or Twitter brought up why would the girls be chirpy about their deceased parents?
https://thedisneyodyssey.wordpress.com/ ... maid-1989/It seems as if viewers complain when female protagonists are ‘passive’ and also when they are ‘active’, when they are ‘kind’ and when they are ‘rebellious’. If protagonists are female, from critical point of view, they are always under scrutiny. It is annoying. Why can’t a character just be what it is … a character?! Characters who have virtues and vices, positive and negative qualities, etc.
Manic Pixie Dream Girls? All of them have no trait beyond being cute/wacky and badass? The spunky girl to pair with the jackass male with issues? Cause that's literally what Vanellope, Judy, Anna, Rapunzel, even a little of Moana; are if you want to be really cynical.Sotiris wrote:Something else that bothers me about the princess scene is that their personalities have been condensed into a single trait. They have been so stereotyped here they've turned into caricatures of themselves.
Ugh, I wish they could just lay off the princesses. John C. Riley should be defending the princesses the most since they're likely the only reason his film is even getting a sequel.DisneyEra wrote:John C. Riley is happy that Ralph Breaks the Internet has redeemed the Disney PrincessesSo, you have a problem with they're looks John?
![]()
https://www.ign.com/videos/2018/11/19/j ... princesses
I was actually referring to movies that had both mother and father pairings onscreen and alive. Thank you though for reminding me of a few others. And I didn't include Aristocats since Thomas O' Malley is not the biological father.JeanGreyForever wrote:Ugh, I wish they could just lay off the princesses. John C. Riley should be defending the princesses the most since they're likely the only reason his film is even getting a sequel.DisneyEra wrote:John C. Riley is happy that Ralph Breaks the Internet has redeemed the Disney PrincessesSo, you have a problem with they're looks John?
![]()
https://www.ign.com/videos/2018/11/19/j ... princesses
As for other classic Disney films without dead parents, here are a few more.
Pinocchio
Dumbo
Song of the South
Alice in Wonderland
Old Yeller
Sleeping Beauty
The Aristocats
Tuck Everlasting
The Chronicles of Narnia
You could maybe include Winnie the Pooh there as well.
Don't worry about that. You're not forcing us to like it, just expressing your opinion.disneyprincess11 wrote:And I really really hope I'm not unconsciously forcing you guys to like it.I remembered I got mad at y'all when the girls were revealed. I once again apologize for that.
I was mentally and physically exhausted that day and the day ended me getting sick on my dress that I had just bought
![]()
![]()
Yeah, I seriously don't care if you guys don't like it. It's just lonely at the bottom
I didn't know what I didn't like about that particular joke and it was that. If at least they hadn't shown them happy while delivering that line, it would've been more respectful.disneyprincess11 wrote:I personally find that moment funny, but I do get the problem. Especially that we see Anna and Elsa die and mourn for them and we'll explore their mom in the sequel apparently. Even someone on Tumblr or Twitter brought up why would the girls be chirpy about their deceased parents?Sotiris wrote:The moment where the princesses shout with glee they don't have moms was particularly cringe-worthy, tasteless, and frankly inappropriate. They made a joke out of their moms dying, for crying out loud. What were the filmmakers thinking?
I agree. And, if you notice, the most ridiculed ones are the Walt era Princesses, then the Renaissance ones, and the ones from the current era are almost themselves (from the bits we've seen).Sotiris wrote:Something else that bothers me about the princess scene is that their personalities have been condensed into a single defining trait. They have been so stereotyped here they've turned into caricatures of themselves. Ariel just wants to sing all the time, Pocahontas has her hair blowing in the wind, Belle is bookish, Mulan fights with a sword etc. Not to mention, Walt's princesses have been completely rendered into a (meta) joke because their original personalities weren't convenient or funny or progressive enough for them.
Tristy wrote:Oh and since we're on the subject of Disney Princesses and in light of some of the recent criticisms made about them, here's a quote from The Disney Odyssey in their article about the little Mermaid
https://thedisneyodyssey.wordpress.com/ ... maid-1989/It seems as if viewers complain when female protagonists are ‘passive’ and also when they are ‘active’, when they are ‘kind’ and when they are ‘rebellious’. If protagonists are female, from critical point of view, they are always under scrutiny. It is annoying. Why can’t a character just be what it is … a character?! Characters who have virtues and vices, positive and negative qualities, etc.
I completely agree with both comments. I understand women have always been oppressed and need more representation and more good roles for little girls. But the roles that don't fit with the standards they seek shouldn't be banned. If people don't have problems with male characters doing those actions, they shouldn't have problems with female ones doing the same. That would be real equality. But I know we haven't reached that point yet where the characters are judged equally regardless of their gender, skin color, sexual orientation, etc.; because there's a lot to be changed in the real world first.thedisneyspirit wrote:And yes, there'll always be scrutiny over the princesses no matter what, even if it's something like dead parents. Meanwhile, male characters like Simba and Hiro can be orphans and do selfish, unheroic acts and people will still praise them for being "brave" and whatnot.(Or just even see how people react to Hercules giving up his godhood to stay with Megara with Ariel staying with Eric)
I figured that's what you meant but I included Pinocchio and Dumbo anyway because those films are special cases since two parents weren't necessary (considering that Pinocchio is brought to life by a puppet and Dumbo is given out by a stork).Tristy wrote:
I was actually referring to movies that had both mother and father pairings onscreen and alive. Thank you though for reminding me of a few others. And I didn't include Aristocats since Thomas O' Malley is not the biological father.
Here it is in it's entirety You think your getting a first look at Frozen 2 but your just getting Rick-Rolled.JeanGreyForever wrote:Oh wow that is awful. Like worse than almost anything Dreamworks at its worst has ever done which is saying something. Will definitely not be sticking around for the post-credits scene and that's taking for granted that I don't walk out much earlier.
Wow, that's really annoying.DisneyEra wrote:Here it is in it's entirety You think your getting a first look at Frozen 2 but your just getting Rick-Rolled.JeanGreyForever wrote:Oh wow that is awful. Like worse than almost anything Dreamworks at its worst has ever done which is saying something. Will definitely not be sticking around for the post-credits scene and that's taking for granted that I don't walk out much earlier.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=szivws5 ... outu.be&a=
Astute observation. It's because they aren't ashamed of their current princesses and therefore don't feel obligated to poke fun at them. They could have come up with a ton of jokes about them, but they didn't even bother.D82 wrote:And, if you notice, the most ridiculed ones are the Walt era Princesses, then the Renaissance ones, and the ones from the current era are almost themselves (from the bits we've seen).
It's because female characters and particularly Disney princesses aren't allowed to be human anymore. They have to be feminist "role models" which means they can't have any flaws or weaknesses. Whereas male characters can run through the entire gamut of human experience and their portrayal can be complex, nuanced and not 100% likeable, female ones are never afforded same courtesy. Hercules is a great example of that. Giving up his demi-god strength for a woman and endangering the world in the process is viewed as something heroic and admirable whereas Ariel giving up her voice to pursue Eric is considered pathetic and worthy of ridicule.D82 wrote:I completely agree with both comments. I understand women have always been oppressed and need more representation and more good roles for little girls. But the roles that don't fit with the standards they seek shouldn't be banned. If people don't have problems with male characters doing those actions, they shouldn't have problems with female ones doing the same.
The entire movie is much worse than anything DreamWorks has ever done because Disney is doing it to themselves in this case. It's one thing for a diiferent studio or company to mock them but Disney doing it validates the naysayers by conceding to their criticisms.JeanGreyForever wrote:Oh wow that is awful. Like worse than almost anything Dreamworks at its worst has ever done which is saying something. Will definitely not be sticking around for the post-credits scene and that's taking for granted that I don't walk out much earlier.
Don't you mean Ralph-Rolled?DisneyEra wrote:Here it is in it's entirety. You think your getting a first look at Frozen 2 but your just getting Rick-Rolled. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=szivws5p5mM