The Super Bowl halftime show was inappropriate. It is not just because of the alleged "wardrobe malfunction" either.
Justin and Janet's song and dance would never have been approved for Sunday afternoon network television if the censors had seen it ahead of time.
Here are some of the lyrics that accompanied the heavily sexual dancing and dry humping :
Just wanna rock you girl
I'll have whatever you have
Come on, just give it up girl
See I've been watching you
I like the way you move
So go ahead, girl, just do
That ass shaking thing you do
I don't mean no harm
Just wanna rock you girl
Make a move, but be calm
Let's go, let's give it up girl
See it appears to me
You like the way I move
I'll tell you what I'm gonna do
Pull you close and share my groove
So you grab your girls
And you grab a couple more
And you all come meet me
In the middle of the floor
Said the air is thick, it's smelling right
So you blast to the left and you sail to the right
Don't be so quick to walk away
Dance with me
I wanna rock your body
Please stay
Dance with me
You don't have to admit you wanna play
Dance with me
Just let me rock you
Till the break of day
So what did you come for
I came to dance with you
And you know that you don't want to hit the floor
I came to romance with you
You're searching for love forever more
It's time to take a chance
If love is here on the floor, girl
No disrespect, I don't mean no harm
But I can't wait to have you in my arms
Hurry up cause you're taking too long
Better have you naked by the end of this song
Don't be so quick to walk away
Are you feeling me?
Let's do something
Let's make a bet
Cause I gotta have you naked by the end of this song
As just Justin sang the last line above, he violently ripped off Janet's top. According to Justin and Janet, the top was supposed to come off and expose Janet in a bra.
If you had a Sunday night movie with a scene where a young man says "Don't be so quick to walk away. I came to romance with you. No disrespect, I don't mean no harm, but I can't wait to have you in my arms. Hurry up cause you're taking too long. I gotta have you naked." and immediately violently rips off the young woman's blouse, then that movie would be preceeded by the standardized warning to alert viewers of violent sexual content and that parental discretion was advised. Even HBO, Showtime, and other pay cable channels provide those kinds of warning messages. The MTV half time show violated FCC regulations during one of the most watched events of the year and they gave absolutely no warning. With or without the nipple, they were wrong and should receive the maximum penalty.
The argument that kids can see near naked men and women simulating sex in many music videos on MTV does nothing to justify the half time show. Parents have the choice to decide whether or not they allow their children to watch MTV. Parents who think it is ok can choose to let their children watch whatever they want, but parents who do not think it is ok should also have the choice to restrict viewing. The Super Bowl half time show took away that choice.
If MTV wants to show Janet's nipples all day everyday then that is fine with me as long as they let people know that that is what they are going to do, but they do not have any right to spring questionable content on unsuspecting viewers in the middle of family programming.
It is completely bogus to try to argue that the MTV half time show should not be criticized because the Super Bowl contains inappropriate violence. Personally I disagree with the extreme characterizations made here about the violence in NFL football, but regardless of how violent anyone thinks that it is, the issue is moot. Everyone knows what to expect from an NFL football game and parents who feel it is inappropriate are free to make the decision about whether or not to allow their children to view it.
The issue is choice. If you want to see sex, violence, and nudity then there are plenty of places on television where you can see it. Likewise, if you do not want to see sex, violence, and nudity then you should be able to watch television without having it thrown in your face.