milojthatch wrote:So I hear it wasn't very good this year?  Thoughts?  I wasn't able to go (as posted), so I'm just basing it on what I've heard.  The D23 Expo Facebook page is filled with bad reviews.
I think the biggest thing were that the crowds were completely unexpected.  I only went Saturday & Sunday, so I wasn't prepared at all on Saturday morning when I got to the Expo.  The Studios panel was the thing I was most looking forward at the Expo.  I even convinced one of my friends to actually go to the Expo because of that panel.
I went last year and didn't have a problem at all getting into the panels.  The Studios panel started at 10:30am, so I thought we should be in line by 8:30am "to make sure to get 'good' seats."  We ended up getting in line about 8:15-8:20ish.  Apparently they were letting the members go inside to line up at 8am.  We didn't set foot in the convention center until 9:10-9:15ish.  We hurried right away to get in line at the arena and then at 9:30am we were told it was filled to capacity.  And there were hundreds of people in front of us.
I was extremely upset.  I mean it was my own fault for not lining up earlier - but it was all just so unexpected.  If I had known, I would have gladly gotten up a few hours earlier to wait.  I think the whole unexpectedness of the crowd really turned people sour.
And I really, really felt bad for the general admission people who lined up at 4am to get into the panel but were turned away since they didn't let non-members in until 10am.  I'm sure that didn't give them a good impression of D23.
We learned our lesson quickly.  The other panel we wanted to see was "25 Years of Pixar" which included John Lasseter on the panel.  It started at 2:30pm, so we got in line around 11am to guarantee a spot.  We got in, but we were still about halfway back from the stage.  It was a really good history lesson, but I was really sad they didn't explore anything new.
Lion King 3d was fun.  We got in line only an hour before it started (I didn't want to wait too long for a movie that I could see later) and still made it in (though we were in the top tier).
Sunday was much better in terms of crowds.  We showed up at 9:15 and just walked right into the Marvel panel.  Although the Marvel panel was nothing like I expected.  It was really only about the history of Marvel and they didn't show anything new.  I was a little angry that the Avengers showed up at the Studios panel and not the Marvel panel, but whatever.  The Marvel panel was just one guy talking.  Silly me for hoping that Joss Whedon would make a surprise appearance.  In my opinion this panel didn't need the Arena (it was pretty empty and the presentation wasn't arena worthy).
We left the Marvel panel early to catch "The Art of 'Brave'" panel.  That was probably my favorite of the ones I saw because it was the only one that showed something new.  The art gave lots of hints for the movie and I'm really excited for it.
My final thoughts:
-D23 oversold on Saturday for the the content it had.  There wasn't much to do besides the panels, so you were screwed if you didn't get into them.
-I think the Studios panel should have been divided up more.  In my opinion, Pixar, The Avengers, and the Muppets really deserved their own panels and then more people could have enjoyed them.
-The staff were poorly trained.  If you asked someone a question "I don't know" was the answer they gave 70% of the time.
-Last year they had characters you could have pictures with when you entered the floor, and they didn't do that this year.  I missed that!
-The area was huge, but every other room was much smaller.  I feel like they needed a room that was in between in size.  
I still had fun despite the unexpected unfortunate surprises.  However, if things don't change I may be hesitant to go next time.