Escapay wrote:My problem with Robin Curtis' Saavik is she's too Vulcan. Saavik from TWOK was initially to be half-Vulcan and half-Romulan, and thus always at odds with trying to hold her emotions in whilst retaining the logic and discipline of a Vulcan. (The scene establishing this was cut from the movie, but it's in the novelisation, I think). Since it's more or less assumed in the final film that she's full Vulcan, Curtis carried that on in TSFS, which did the character a great disservice, IMO.
Yeah, that's what I thought. I found out that Khan's Saavik quit because she wanted too much money. It also just occurred to me, that maybe David could've saved himself if Saavik had mind-melded with him before (just in case, or maybe young Spock), taking Saavik with them to Vulcan with Spock. Though that might just make things more complicated, with two Vulcans getting healed... Oh, well.
Escapay wrote:But seriously, I love a lot of what the odd-numbered films bring to the series (except Generations, which is my least favourite of the Trek films), it's just that the even-numbered films generally do it better. The Motion Picture is the slowest-moving, but also arguably the best story of the films (odd-numbered or not), and The Search For Spock, while good in its own right, really just serves as the bridge between The Wrath of Khan and The Voyage Home. For the longest time, it was my favourite of the Trek films, though I've grown less interested in it over time. The Final Frontier really is the mess of the bunch (in all the Trek films and especially in the original crew films) but when you just sit down and watch it in the mind set of "Okay, give me a Trek that's just a lot of fun even if it doesn't make sense!", it's pretty good. Insurrection is highly underrated and I think it suffers mainly from being too small a plot for a movie. It's the biggest "extended television episode" Trek movie ever, but it is still quite good regardless.
Well, I guess Motion Picture could've been a better movie, but I still think it's story is rather weak. I don't remember the plot of Final Frontier (that's why I'm revisiting all the Trek films). I do vaguely remember a Star Trek that only had Shatner in it, but none of the rest of the original crew, and then the new crew (from The Next Generation) came along.