Howard wrote:Actually, not that long while ago, I managed to record the audio commentary off the DVD, and split it up into 8 separate mp3 audio tracks. If you're interested (or if anyone else is interested in hearing the commentary) I'll be more than happy to email them to you if you'd like.
Wow, that'd be great, Howard! I'll e-mail you!
Ames wrote:Based on Albert's post about what might be missing from the new edition, what I'd care about is:
Escapay wrote:History & Behind the Scenes: (2 hours, 47 minutes, 16 seconds, 669 Stills)
-Once Upon a Dream: The Making of Sleeping Beauty (16:22)
-Production (14 minutes, 3 seconds) - the first three can easily be edited into the documentary, while the latter two are old laserdisc pieces that likely won't be carried over (even if the widescreen to pan-and-scan comparison should be)
--The Music (2:46)
--The Design (3:22)
--Creating the Backgrounds (1:07)
I'd rather only have one edition- either just keep the one I have, or sell that one and use that money toward the new edition...
I mean, if the new DVD has a good Making Of documentary, then I guess it wouldn't hurt to sell the old version and buy the new one, right?
I think that since the two editions are vastly different, and both offer very good (and exclusive-to-that-version) content, it's best to keep both. After all, that audio documentary is really really good (as I often say, lol) and the making-of pieces, while brief, do have some value and it's really not known if they'll be on the new edition.
I already plan on keeping my old edition for the audio documentary (there it is again!) and extras, as well as the transfer (it's the 2.35:1 35mm print, and I'd like it for both posterity and comparison purposes).
As for the whole "get rid of the old one for the new", for me it's a case-by-case basis. Using Disney titles as an example, I got the new
Aristocats and
Robin Hood because of the exclusive extras (however brief they were...grr), but kept the old ones for the trailer (
Aristocats) and nostalgia (
Robin Hood was the last DVD I bought in Florida during my 2005 program before I went back home). And the animated ratios as well, simply for comparison purposes. Or to go in a "reverse" direction, after I already had the 40th Anniversary Edition of
Mary Poppins in 2004, I later acquired the old Gold Collection version in 2006 for the features exclusive to that version (the short documentary and the vintage premiere featurette).
Albert