disneyfella wrote:
Let's face it. Everyone's view of "good" Disney Channel is the Disney Channel of their childhood. Did anyone really expect Disney Channel not to change with the times and tastes of the kids?
Actually, my favorite period of Disney Channel history was not from my childhood, but rather was from 1997 until September 2002, which coincided with the Vault Disney programming block!
I don't think Escapay and others are saying Disney should not continue creating new programming for the "tween market", but they completely THREW AWAY everyone who liked Walt-era Disney material, the roots of the company.
And those aren't just "old-timers". I myself was not even alive at any point that Walt was, and yet I love his films. Many young people of today would too, if they were actually given a chance to see them!
If Vault Disney had to be scaled back to less hours a day or even just a few days a week, we could deal with that, but they have COMPLETELY taken ANY and ALL of this programming off the air. Instead of offering something for everyone, during the overnight hours they offer the same old reruns of the tween shows that the fans of said shows already have many other chances to see.
When you can (occasionally) see live-action Disney classics (Walt and post-Walt) like Swiss Family Robinson, Pollyana, Natty Gann, and Love Bug on the Hallmark Channel but NOT the "Disney" channel, this tells me that Disney themselves is SEVERLY neglecting and undervaluing their own classic material, and by extension, the people (of ALL ages) who are it's fans!
While DVD's of this material may not always sell like hotcakes, I think Disney is partly to blame for this due to poor promotion. And I don't just mean advertising the DVDs either.
The Vault Disney block on Disney Channel was perfect "SYNERGY" to drive up demand for both the Treasures line and the live-action catalogue. It is NO surprise to me AT ALL that both sales of the Treasures have slowed and the stream of live-action catalog titles has dried up in direct proportion to the abandonment of support/exposure for this material on the Disney channel.
People see a movie on TV, or a classic short, and then go look for the DVD or even CD soundtracks (when applicable) the next day at the Best Buy. I remember someone from WDR said in an interview (maybe Randy Thornton) that every time a classic gets aired on TV, they get some requests for the soundtrack! So you know this would also be the case for DVDs!
Now, the hardcore fans will remember this material and want it no matter what, but where Disney are really missing the boat by "marginalizing" this material is by losing sales to other more "casual" fans, (at least some of whom will need to buy this material to keep sales at a healthy level), because:
a) they might have been inclined to buy the "older" films if they still aired but they have now forgotten about them since they haven't aired for awhile,
b) they don't know they are out on DVD due to lack of promotion, OR,
c) they haven't seen the movies before and don't want to blind buy, but if they COULD see them on tv, they WOULD want them on DVD after seeing how good they are!
I remember how much fun I had in the late 90's and early 2000's when Vault Disney was at it's prime, taping so much off the air and using Leonard Maltin's THE DISNEY FILMS, Dave Smith's DISNEY A TO Z, and Bill Cotter's THE WONDERFUL WORLD OF DISNEY TELEVISION as reference guides to check off each short, film, and anthology episode as I had taped it.
Now, much of this material I had never even seen before AT ALL, much less in my childhood, so I was clearly enjoying the material on it's own merit and NOT just as the stereotypical fodder for "nostalgia trips"!
I also remember, as DVDs became mainstream, thinking my ultimate goal would be to upgrade all of this material to "official" DVD releases. But I can't give the Mouse my money if he doesn't want to take it!
The net result of this total lack of exposure on the Disney channel and the resulting decline of sales on DVD has created a catch 22 quagmire of marginalization for the Walt-era live action film and tv library (and post-Walt 70's, 80's and 90's) for which it sadly may never recover. It is now relegated to even more obscurity when it DOES get released, thanks to under-the-radar releases through such obscurities as the Disney movie club, which is "Continuing to deprive the general public of the studio's vintage family entertainment", as the UD homepage so eloquently stated!
Even before Vault Disney, selections from the "vintage" material were always available on some level on the Disney Channel, and thanks to the desire to COMPLETELY remove it due to lack of percieved "hipness" *, we now have, for the first time in history, generations growing up with absolutely zero exposure on Disney's own channel to Walt's classic live action films and tv.
*source quote from Wikipedia:
As part of the network's 2002 re-brand campaign, the "Zoog" brand name was dropped, and Vault Disney was dropped (primarily to contribute to the network's new "hip" image).
Full article:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vault_Disney