It seems to me that the greedy bastard (Lucas) saturated the market with unneccessary releases and rereleases of the Star Wars movies for the past few years and now that he's soaked most of the fans for all their worth, he's not delivering on what many of them have truely been waiting for. He really makes me sick.
STAR WARS 30th Anniversary - The Complete Saga on DVD?
- Prince Phillip
- Anniversary Edition
- Posts: 1419
- Joined: Mon May 12, 2003 11:48 am
- Location: Baltimore, MD
STAR WARS 30th Anniversary - The Complete Saga on DVD?
For years now, I have been waiting for them to release a boxset with all 6 Star Wars movies. I remember George Lucas announcing that such a boxset would be released. I thought that 2007, the 30th Anniversary of the release of the first movie would be the ideal time for such a boxset, and yet 2007 and drawing to a close and I have heard no news of a release. Has anyone else?
It seems to me that the greedy bastard (Lucas) saturated the market with unneccessary releases and rereleases of the Star Wars movies for the past few years and now that he's soaked most of the fans for all their worth, he's not delivering on what many of them have truely been waiting for. He really makes me sick.
It seems to me that the greedy bastard (Lucas) saturated the market with unneccessary releases and rereleases of the Star Wars movies for the past few years and now that he's soaked most of the fans for all their worth, he's not delivering on what many of them have truely been waiting for. He really makes me sick.
Defy Gravity
- KubrickFan
- Anniversary Edition
- Posts: 1209
- Joined: Sun Sep 17, 2006 11:22 am
Re: STAR WARS 30th Anniversary - The Complete Saga on DVD?
He wants to wait with the releases until one of the HD-formats (Blu-Ray or HD-DVD) has survived. So it can take a while, but don't count on the complete saga coming to normal dvd. It will also be the 'ultimate' Star Wars dvd box, with more enhancements to his films (Yoda has been replaced by CG in The Phantom Menace, and there were some rumors about a scene with Padme in the old trilogy) and hopefully some tweaking for continuity's sake (lightsabers clearly lacked consistency in the original trilogy dvds). Along with more bonus features (the 2 1/2 hour documentary was great, but the Star Wars archives are so enormous, that there must be tons of material) they will be the final dvds. Hopefully.Prince Phillip wrote:For years now, I have been waiting for them to release a boxset with all 6 Star Wars movies. I remember George Lucas announcing that such a boxset would be released. I thought that 2007, the 30th Anniversary of the release of the first movie would be the ideal time for such a boxset, and yet 2007 and drawing to a close and I have heard no news of a release. Has anyone else?
It seems to me that the greedy bastard (Lucas) saturated the market with unneccessary releases and rereleases of the Star Wars movies for the past few years and now that he's soaked most of the fans for all their worth, he's not delivering on what many of them have truely been waiting for. He really makes me sick.

Another factor to consider is that Lucasfilm does not have a history of releasing more than one big fourth quarter product per year.
2001: TPM
2002: AOTC
2003: Indy trilogy
2004: SW original trilogy
2005: ROTS
2006: SW original trilogy re-release with original letterboxed versions
2007: Young Indy
2008: Indy IV
2009: ?
Hopefully, by 2009, the format war will be over, and Lucas can release a SW saga boxset for an HD format and DVD.
2001: TPM
2002: AOTC
2003: Indy trilogy
2004: SW original trilogy
2005: ROTS
2006: SW original trilogy re-release with original letterboxed versions
2007: Young Indy
2008: Indy IV
2009: ?
Hopefully, by 2009, the format war will be over, and Lucas can release a SW saga boxset for an HD format and DVD.
-
Maerj
- Collector's Edition
- Posts: 2748
- Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2003 11:31 pm
- Location: Ephrata, PA
- Contact:
Re: STAR WARS 30th Anniversary - The Complete Saga on DVD?
He originally said he was going to wait for all the movies to be done before he was to release them to DVD at all. People kept asking for them on DVD, so that's what they got. As the other folks said here, maybe when the format war is over we'll get a mega set, who knows?Prince Phillip wrote:For years now, I have been waiting for them to release a boxset with all 6 Star Wars movies. I remember George Lucas announcing that such a boxset would be released. I thought that 2007, the 30th Anniversary of the release of the first movie would be the ideal time for such a boxset, and yet 2007 and drawing to a close and I have heard no news of a release. Has anyone else?
It seems to me that the greedy bastard (Lucas) saturated the market with unneccessary releases and rereleases of the Star Wars movies for the past few years and now that he's soaked most of the fans for all their worth, he's not delivering on what many of them have truely been waiting for. He really makes me sick.
- slave2moonlight
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4427
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: TX
- Contact:
-
dvdjunkie
- Signature Collection
- Posts: 5613
- Joined: Wed Nov 10, 2004 10:05 am
- Location: Wichita, Kansas
I had also heard a rumor that he was 'tweaking' the whole series for IMAX 3-D release starting in 2008, each film with some added scenes and features especially for the IMAX system. If this is true then our Mega-Box Set is probably down the road four to five years.

The only way to watch movies - Original Aspect Ratio!!!!
I LOVE my Blu-Ray Disc Player!
I LOVE my Blu-Ray Disc Player!
- slave2moonlight
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4427
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: TX
- Contact:
- DarthPrime
- Collector's Edition
- Posts: 2520
- Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2005 10:55 pm
I honestly think the current DVDs are pretty good and I would skip a Saga set if the films were not changed. However if this is ever released more changes will happen to the Original Trilogy and I'm sure Prequel Trilogy changes too. Yoda is already supposed to be done in CGI for The Phantom Menace. I'm wondering if edits to Menace and Clones would help them. In my opinion they are the weakest parts of the Saga. Also there are still some things that need fixing in the Originals. The 2004 restoration of the Trilogy was amazing, but the Lightsaber colors really got screwed up.
As a Star Wars fan I don't mind some of the changes, but some annoy me. I'm glad we got the Originals on DVD last year, however I'm sad that they were nothing more than letterboxed Laserdisc transfers. I wished Lucas would realize that these are the films many grew up to love and there is nothing wrong with them. Sadly I don't think he ever will. I would really love to have a restored anamorphic edition of the Originals on DVD.
To me the Prequels don't have that Star Wars "Magic" that the Originals do. However I do enjoy them for what they are. I think the Prequels should have been made so that changes to the Originals were not necessary.
If Star Wars gets released on HD DVD or Blu-ray I don't think we will see it for many years. It took ages to get the movies on DVD.
As a Star Wars fan I don't mind some of the changes, but some annoy me. I'm glad we got the Originals on DVD last year, however I'm sad that they were nothing more than letterboxed Laserdisc transfers. I wished Lucas would realize that these are the films many grew up to love and there is nothing wrong with them. Sadly I don't think he ever will. I would really love to have a restored anamorphic edition of the Originals on DVD.
To me the Prequels don't have that Star Wars "Magic" that the Originals do. However I do enjoy them for what they are. I think the Prequels should have been made so that changes to the Originals were not necessary.
If Star Wars gets released on HD DVD or Blu-ray I don't think we will see it for many years. It took ages to get the movies on DVD.
- slave2moonlight
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4427
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: TX
- Contact:
I don't think George Lucas will be as slow to release stuff onto new formats as he used to be. I just hope that every new release doesn't involve a new set of changes, because that would just be ridiculous. However, I can live with one more set of changes, and I don't think it's a bad idea to change Yoda in Episode 1. That Yoda never did look quite right.
I didn't like all the changes to the original trilogy, but some were okay. For example, the way they opened up Cloud City. I don't mind George making adjustments to make the saga fit better as long as we have access to the originals, and as long as we do, I don't know why the changes are so upsetting. Granted, we should get a better release of the originals. Frankly, I still need to get it myself. I have all the initial DVD releases of the entire saga though. I agree that it would have been better if they had been written so that the originals didn't have to be changed, by the way, and I also probably wouldn't double-dip unless there were new changes and/or an upgrade was in order.
As for Episodes 1 and 2 being weak, I agree on 1, but for the most part I rather liked Episode 2. The romance stuff wasn't that well written, but I loved most everything else. I don't think it'd be possible for the films to have the same feel as the originals unless CGI was completely unused though, or just barely used. Also, they were all missing that "dashing rogue" character in the style of Han Solo. Anakin's darkness helped 2 and 3, but in Episode 1 it was really hurting for a human character that was more free-spirited.
I didn't like all the changes to the original trilogy, but some were okay. For example, the way they opened up Cloud City. I don't mind George making adjustments to make the saga fit better as long as we have access to the originals, and as long as we do, I don't know why the changes are so upsetting. Granted, we should get a better release of the originals. Frankly, I still need to get it myself. I have all the initial DVD releases of the entire saga though. I agree that it would have been better if they had been written so that the originals didn't have to be changed, by the way, and I also probably wouldn't double-dip unless there were new changes and/or an upgrade was in order.
As for Episodes 1 and 2 being weak, I agree on 1, but for the most part I rather liked Episode 2. The romance stuff wasn't that well written, but I loved most everything else. I don't think it'd be possible for the films to have the same feel as the originals unless CGI was completely unused though, or just barely used. Also, they were all missing that "dashing rogue" character in the style of Han Solo. Anakin's darkness helped 2 and 3, but in Episode 1 it was really hurting for a human character that was more free-spirited.
- DarthPrime
- Collector's Edition
- Posts: 2520
- Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2005 10:55 pm
Episode 2 wasn't as bad as 1. The problems I have with it are the Anakin/Padme scenes. Whether it was the writing or acting, something just wasn't right about them. The ending was good. Yoda using the Lightsaber for the first time was priceless.
I'm not really mad with the changes, and I actually do like some of them. Cloud City is a good change, along with the Death Star stuff that was reworked some in A New Hope. The CGI Jabba never looked right, and while I like the new Emperor scene in Empire, it just looks odd. Same with Hayden at the end of Jedi. It makes since, but it didn't look right.
Reworking the Originals and the Prequels to make them all fit together wouldn't be that bad. I just wished the Original Originals (that sounded odd) got a proper release.
I'm not really mad with the changes, and I actually do like some of them. Cloud City is a good change, along with the Death Star stuff that was reworked some in A New Hope. The CGI Jabba never looked right, and while I like the new Emperor scene in Empire, it just looks odd. Same with Hayden at the end of Jedi. It makes since, but it didn't look right.
Reworking the Originals and the Prequels to make them all fit together wouldn't be that bad. I just wished the Original Originals (that sounded odd) got a proper release.
- slave2moonlight
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4427
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: TX
- Contact:
That's what I was talking about with Episode 2. Some of the Anakin/Padme stuff wasn't well written, in my opinion.
As for the scene with the CGI Jabba in New Hope, yeah, he looked weird, but I was always happy to have that scene put back into the film and I'm fine with it since they redid Jabba for the DVDs. They could touch it up a bit more, but it was a big improvement from the theatrical one.
One thing I never have gotten over is the removal of Lak Sivrak from the Cantina (the Wolf man).
I'm not really sure it made sense to have Anakin's ghost be Hayden at the end of Jedi. I mean, the whole point was that he was still in that black suit, under all that metal and evil. He did age, and if Obi Wan's ghost and Yoda's weren't young again, he shouldn't have been either. Sure, it makes the films seem to tie together more, but it doesn't truly make sense to me. I can't say it bothers me greatly, but I'd prefer that scene the old way. Perhaps they should have added Qui Gon's ghost alongside the originals instead, ha. Though Luke wouldn't know who the heck he was, so they'd have to redub Ben mentioning Qui Gon or something. Perhaps add a whole new scene with a CGI Ben, like that Orville Reddenbacher (sp?) commercial.
And, they say they are going to add Padme into the original trilogy now? I'm wondering what that will mean. My best guess would be yet another ghost at the end. I'd prefer that to flashbacks when Leia talks about her though. How exactly does she remember her being sad and beautiful again? Ha. They might just take that sentence out completely.
As for the scene with the CGI Jabba in New Hope, yeah, he looked weird, but I was always happy to have that scene put back into the film and I'm fine with it since they redid Jabba for the DVDs. They could touch it up a bit more, but it was a big improvement from the theatrical one.
One thing I never have gotten over is the removal of Lak Sivrak from the Cantina (the Wolf man).
I'm not really sure it made sense to have Anakin's ghost be Hayden at the end of Jedi. I mean, the whole point was that he was still in that black suit, under all that metal and evil. He did age, and if Obi Wan's ghost and Yoda's weren't young again, he shouldn't have been either. Sure, it makes the films seem to tie together more, but it doesn't truly make sense to me. I can't say it bothers me greatly, but I'd prefer that scene the old way. Perhaps they should have added Qui Gon's ghost alongside the originals instead, ha. Though Luke wouldn't know who the heck he was, so they'd have to redub Ben mentioning Qui Gon or something. Perhaps add a whole new scene with a CGI Ben, like that Orville Reddenbacher (sp?) commercial.
And, they say they are going to add Padme into the original trilogy now? I'm wondering what that will mean. My best guess would be yet another ghost at the end. I'd prefer that to flashbacks when Leia talks about her though. How exactly does she remember her being sad and beautiful again? Ha. They might just take that sentence out completely.
-
Maerj
- Collector's Edition
- Posts: 2748
- Joined: Sun Apr 20, 2003 11:31 pm
- Location: Ephrata, PA
- Contact:
They already changed Yoda in Episode 1. You can see the footage in the Revenge of the Sith DVD, I believe. They have a docu about Anakin and they go to the scene where Yoda is saying "Fear leads to the Dark Side..." and he is indeed CG.
Lak Sivrak was removed because it was just an off the shelf wolfman mask and George wanted something more alien looking.
I think that they put young Anakin in the end of Return of the Jedi to show the good man he once was not the mechanical monster he had become. The images afterall are just visual representations of the individuals, so that would probably how he would see himself, rather than the kindly old man they had originally since that version of Anakin never existed.
Lak Sivrak was removed because it was just an off the shelf wolfman mask and George wanted something more alien looking.
I think that they put young Anakin in the end of Return of the Jedi to show the good man he once was not the mechanical monster he had become. The images afterall are just visual representations of the individuals, so that would probably how he would see himself, rather than the kindly old man they had originally since that version of Anakin never existed.
- SpringHeelJack
- Platinum Edition
- Posts: 3673
- Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2006 3:20 pm
- Location: Boston, MA
- Contact:
I still loathe the Jabba scene in "A New Hope". He looks better than that CGI beanbag that was in the '97 Special Edition, but he still doesn't look like Jabba from ROTJ. Plus the scene just reiterates everything Greedo said previously, AND Han Solo steps on Jabba's tail. COME ON. Jabba put a bounty on Han's head for dumping spice. Do you really think he'd just sit and take Han literally walking all over him?
I also think Lucas said that they will not be digitally adding footage of Padme into the OT. That was a rumor when the DVDs were first being released, and he said then it was not going to happen (thankfully).
All I really want on a re-release is finally fixing the lightsabers (they've had two chances previously to do this, and still messed it up. Why?) and the deleted scenes. I know they exist, so why can't we have them?
I also think Lucas said that they will not be digitally adding footage of Padme into the OT. That was a rumor when the DVDs were first being released, and he said then it was not going to happen (thankfully).
All I really want on a re-release is finally fixing the lightsabers (they've had two chances previously to do this, and still messed it up. Why?) and the deleted scenes. I know they exist, so why can't we have them?
"Ta ta ta taaaa! Look at me... I'm a snowman! I'm gonna go stand on someone's lawn if I don't get something to do around here pretty soon!"
-
Barbossa
- Collector's Edition
- Posts: 2944
- Joined: Sun Jul 22, 2007 3:23 am
- Location: Calgary, AB, Canada
They should release The Star Wars Holiday Special as a bonus disc.
I can't get enough of Lumpy, Crusty, Itchy, Snotty, Smelly, Scratchy, or whatever the wookies were called.
Actually, each movie in the original trilogy should get their own bonus disc, not just one disc for the whole orignal trilogy - do it like the DVD releases for the prequels, where each was a two-disc release.
Actually, each movie in the original trilogy should get their own bonus disc, not just one disc for the whole orignal trilogy - do it like the DVD releases for the prequels, where each was a two-disc release.
- TM2-Megatron
- Anniversary Edition
- Posts: 1065
- Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2005 5:51 pm
- Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
I doubt this will ever see the light of day on a legal DVD release, as Lucas is too embarrassed by it. It's just a pity he doesn't have the good sense to be equally shamed by the prequels.Barbossa wrote:They should release The Star Wars Holiday Special as a bonus disc.I can't get enough of Lumpy, Crusty, Itchy, Snotty, Smelly, Scratchy, or whatever the wookies were called.
![]()
![]()
- DarthPrime
- Collector's Edition
- Posts: 2520
- Joined: Sun Aug 28, 2005 10:55 pm
Thats one of my problems with the scene too. Its really pointless after the run in with Greedo.SpringHeelJack wrote:I still loathe the Jabba scene in "A New Hope". He looks better than that CGI beanbag that was in the '97 Special Edition, but he still doesn't look like Jabba from ROTJ. Plus the scene just reiterates everything Greedo said previously, AND Han Solo steps on Jabba's tail. COME ON. Jabba put a bounty on Han's head for dumping spice. Do you really think he'd just sit and take Han literally walking all over him?
Also the Han Shoots First thing... Why in the world did they change this, and why after all the changes does it still look completely horrible? I mean in 1997 they added the Emperor's scream from Jedi to Luke falling after his confrontation with Vader in Empire. At least they removed it in the 2004 editions. The Han/Greedo thing should be changed back and just let Han blast him.
The Holiday Special is PAINFUL to watch, and I seriously doubt it will ever see a release on any format.
- slave2moonlight
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4427
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: TX
- Contact:
Yeah, I knew that about Lak, but I thought he looked great anyway and it was too late to remove his people from Star Wars lore. In fact, they now have a Jedi character of that species that was created for the Clone Wars cartoon after fans voted on the internet, so people clearly liked the idea and look of the character. Of course, there were originally two werewolf masked characters in the cantina, and the other one didn't look as good. Oddly enough, the other one is the one they called a wolf-man while working on the film, and Lak Sivrak was being called Hyena-man, if memory serves.Maerj wrote:They already changed Yoda in Episode 1. You can see the footage in the Revenge of the Sith DVD, I believe. They have a docu about Anakin and they go to the scene where Yoda is saying "Fear leads to the Dark Side..." and he is indeed CG.
Lak Sivrak was removed because it was just an off the shelf wolfman mask and George wanted something more alien looking.
I think that they put young Anakin in the end of Return of the Jedi to show the good man he once was not the mechanical monster he had become. The images afterall are just visual representations of the individuals, so that would probably how he would see himself, rather than the kindly old man they had originally since that version of Anakin never existed.
But, did they really change Yoda in Episode One already? I don't recall that. Is that in the first DVD release? I'll have to check it out again, but I doubt I'd have missed it, unless it's from the release that includes the original versions. I still need to get that.
I know what you're saying about Anakin's ghost, but I think the kind old man version makes more sense to appear to Luke.
- SpringHeelJack
- Platinum Edition
- Posts: 3673
- Joined: Fri Nov 10, 2006 3:20 pm
- Location: Boston, MA
- Contact:
The CGI Yoda from Episode I can be seen in footage in one of the documentaries on disc two of "Revenge of the Sith". I don't know what one, but it's the scene where he does his "Fear leads to anger..." bit. It looks okay, but I'm still a fan of puppet Yoda.
"Ta ta ta taaaa! Look at me... I'm a snowman! I'm gonna go stand on someone's lawn if I don't get something to do around here pretty soon!"
- slave2moonlight
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4427
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: TX
- Contact:
SpringHeelJack wrote:I still loathe the Jabba scene in "A New Hope". He looks better than that CGI beanbag that was in the '97 Special Edition, but he still doesn't look like Jabba from ROTJ. Plus the scene just reiterates everything Greedo said previously, AND Han Solo steps on Jabba's tail. COME ON. Jabba put a bounty on Han's head for dumping spice. Do you really think he'd just sit and take Han literally walking all over him?
I agree about the deleted scenes and other stuff, but I still like that scene in A New Hope. It's nice to see Han interacting with Jabba, and I think the tail thing shows Han as appropriately cocky. Yeah, maybe the Han/Jabba meeting was a bit too friendly, but if you want to talk about flaws in the films, why did Vader have to become more machine then man when they had cloning technology? At any point he could have easily replaced organs, body parts, skin, whatever. Heck, they even should have had the technology to put his brain into a clone, since the bo'marr monks were just brains in jars. I know that the comic sequels aren't canon, but even in those, the Emperor returned by putting his soul into a clone in Dark Empire, and he had plenty more ready to go. Maybe the Emperor wanted to have more control over Vader, but one would think Vader could have figured this plan out on his own at some point. Sorry, I just realized this recently and it bothers me, ha. Still love the saga though.
- slave2moonlight
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4427
- Joined: Wed Aug 23, 2006 11:33 pm
- Location: TX
- Contact:
Thanks, I'll check it out. I would prefer a puppet Yoda, but I just don't think the one they made looked good.SpringHeelJack wrote:The CGI Yoda from Episode I can be seen in footage in one of the documentaries on disc two of "Revenge of the Sith". I don't know what one, but it's the scene where he does his "Fear leads to anger..." bit. It looks okay, but I'm still a fan of puppet Yoda.