Rate the Disney Animated Classics

[Escapay]

Yay, another Rank the Movies thread!

(And I'm too lazy to use the search feature to find some to link to, so if someone would do it for me, I'd be much obliged).

Anyways, here's my rankings (X is I can't rank as I didn't see it)

Snow White - 7
Pinocchio - 7
Fantasia - 8
Dumbo - 8
Bambi - 5
Saludos Amigos - X
The Three Caballeros - X
Make Mine Music - 5
Fun and Fancy Free - 5
Melody Time - 5
Ichabod & Toad - 7
Cinderella - 7
Alice in Wonderland - 8
Peter Pan - 8
Lady and the Tramp - 9
Sleeping Beauty - 8
101 Dalmatians - 7
Sword in the Stone - 6
Jungle Book - 5
Aristocats - 5
Robin Hood - 5
Winnie the Pooh - 8
Rescuers - 6
Fox and Hound - 5
Black Cauldron - 9
Great Mouse Detective - 7
Oliver and Company - 6
Little Mermaid - 8
Rescuers Down Under - 6
Beauty and the Beast - 10
Aladdin - 10
Lion King - 6
Pocahontas - 5
Hunchback - 6
Hercules - 5
Mulan - 8
Tarzan - 10
Fantasia 2000 - 7
Emperor's New Groove - 9
Atlantis - 5
Lilo & Stitch - 9
Treasure Planet - X
Brother Bear - 8
Home on the Range - X

I didn't have the heart to go below a 5...

[Jack]

Since it was identical to a thread that has already been started, I merged the two threads.

[deathie mouse]

Escapay

we just had
<a href="http://www.ultimatedisney.com/forum/vie ... 5958">Rank Disney's 2-Disc Sets!</a>
<a href="http://www.ultimatedisney.com/forum/vie ... 5962">Rank and rate Disney's live action animation combo films</a>
<a href="http://www.ultimatedisney.com/forum/vie ... 5871">Rank and Rate Disney Classics by Decade</a>
<a href="http://www.ultimatedisney.com/forum/vie ... 5794">Rank and rate the Disney animated films of the 1950s</a>

All ending within the last 10 or so days....



Also a <a href="http://www.ultimatedisney.com/forum/vie ... =234">Rank & Rate the Pixar Films</a> too, ending not much earlier which after this week might be revived again




maybe someone should make a massive all emcompassing meltdown err... i mean merge, just called RANK



oh I see Intrepid Jabberin'Jack did one while i was gettin a hold of the other threads. For a moment my reply got lost into twilight zone status hehehee

[azul017]

Edited my list to reflect my adjusted feelings towards some of the films. "Pinnochio" was just frightening and mean-spirited, while "Tarzan", while sporting great animation, was just plodding and dull.

[Wonderlicious]

Bump, bump, bump it up!

Since I have some different feelings towards the animated classics since I posted in this thread, and I'm interested in seeing what people thought about the movies listed, I've decided to revive.

[ichabod]

Oh my word! i can't believed I never posted in this thread during it's last incarnations!

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 7
2. Pinocchio - 8
3. Fantasia - 10
4. Dumbo - 7
5. Bambi - 9
6. Saludos Amigos - 6
7. The Three Caballeros - 7
8. Make Mine Music - 6
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 7
10. Melody Time - 5
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 7
12. Cinderella - N/A
13. Alice in Wonderland - 10
14. Peter Pan - 8
15. Lady and the Tamp - 10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 7
17. 101 Dalmatians - 9
18. The Sword in the Stone - 8
19. The Jungle Book - 8
20. The Aristocats - 8
21. Robin Hood - 8
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8
23. The Rescuers - 7
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6
25. The Black Cauldron - 6
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 7
27. Oliver & Company - 6
28. The Little Mermaid - N/A
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 7
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10
31. Aladdin - 7
32. The Lion King - 7
33. Pocahontas - 8
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 10
35. Hercules - 7
36. Mulan - 9
37. Tarzan - 8
38. Fantasia 2000 - 8
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 8
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 8
42. Treasure Planet - 8
43. Brother Bear - 8
44. Home on the Range - 9

[Raydawggie]

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9
2. Pinocchio - 9
3. Fantasia - 10
4. Dumbo - 7
5. Bambi - 10
6. Saludos Amigos - 6
7. The Three Caballeros - 7
8. Make Mine Music - 6
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 7
10. Melody Time - 5
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 8
12. Cinderella - 9
13. Alice in Wonderland - 8
14. Peter Pan - 8
15. Lady and the Tamp - 10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 9
17. 101 Dalmatians - 7
18. The Sword in the Stone - 8
19. The Jungle Book - 8
20. The Aristocats - 8
21. Robin Hood - 8
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 6
23. The Rescuers - 5
24. The Fox and the Hound - 7
25. The Black Cauldron - 6
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 4
27. Oliver & Company - 8
28. The Little Mermaid - 9
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 3
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10
31. Aladdin - 10
32. The Lion King - 9
33. Pocahontas - 7
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 1
35. Hercules - 10
36. Mulan - 10
37. Tarzan - 8
38. Fantasia 2000 - 8
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 7
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 4
41. Lilo & Stitch - 8
42. Treasure Planet - 7
43. Brother Bear - 5
44. Home on the Range - 4

[Timon/Pumbaa fan]

Well this was though. But here are mine:

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs- 9
2. Pinocchio - 10
3. Fantasia - 9
4. Dumbo - 6
5. Bambi - 10
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't seen it
7. The Three Caballeros - 4
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't seen it
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 5
10. Melody Time - 4
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 8(Woud've been a 10 if it weren't for Ichabod)
12. Cinderella - 5
13. Alice in Wonderland - 6
14. Peter Pan - 8
15. Lady and the Tamp - 7
16. Sleeping Beauty - 10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 7
18. The Sword in the Stone - Haven't seen it in a long time
19. The Jungle Book - 9
20. The Aristocats - 5
21. Robin Hood - 8
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8
23. The Rescuers - 7
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6
25. The Black Cauldron - 1
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 8
27. Oliver & Company - 4
28. The Little Mermaid - 10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 5
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10
31. Aladdin - 10
32. The Lion King - 11
33. Pocahontas - 5
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 1
35. Hercules - 8
36. Mulan - 9
37. Tarzan - 9
38. Fantasia 2000 - 9
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 9
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 6
41. Lilo & Stitch - 8
42. Treasure Planet - 9
43. Brother Bear - 8
44. Home on the Range - Haven't seen it

[Dan05]

My movie ratings usually change over time but here are what they currently are.

Snow White - 6
Pinocchio - X
Fantasia - X
Dumbo - 4
Bambi - 9
Saludos Amigos - X
The Three Caballeros - X
Make Mine Music - X
Fun and Fancy Free - X
Melody Time - X
Ichabod & Toad - X
Cinderella - 7
Alice in Wonderland - 4
Peter Pan - 6
Lady and the Tramp - 7
Sleeping Beauty - 10
101 Dalmatians - 7
Sword in the Stone - 5
Jungle Book - X
Aristocats - 3
Robin Hood - 6
The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - X
Rescuers - 5
Fox and Hound - 5
Black Cauldron - X
Great Mouse Detective - X
Oliver and Company - 9
Little Mermaid - 10
Rescuers Down Under - X
Beauty and the Beast - 10
Aladdin - 10
Lion King - 10
Pocahontas - 2
Hunchback - 8
Hercules - 8
Mulan - 8
Tarzan - 8
Fantasia 2000 - X
Emperor's New Groove - 10
Atlantis - X
Lilo & Stitch - 9
Treasure Planet - X
Brother Bear - 9
Home on the Range - X

The ones I haven't seen are marked with an X

[thompsoncory]

SNOW WHITE & THE SEVEN DWARFS - 8/10 (B+)
PINOCCHIO - 7/10 ( B )
FANTASIA - 8/10 (A-)
BAMBI - 9/10 (A-)
FUN AND FANCY FREE - 7/10 ( B )
CINDERELLA - 9/10 (A-)
ALICE IN WONDERLAND - 8/10 (B+)
PETER PAN - 9/10 (A)
LADY & THE TRAMP - 8/10 (B+)
SLEEPING BEAUTY - 10/10 (A+)
101 DALMATIANS - 7/10 (B-)
THE SWORD IN THE STONE - 6/10 (B-)
THE JUNGLE BOOK - 8/10 (B+)
THE ARISTOCATS - 9/10 (A)
ROBIN HOOD - 8/10 (B+)
THE MANY ADVENTURES OF WINNIE THE POOH - 9/10 (A-)
THE RESCUERS - 8/10 (B+)
THE FOX AND THE HOUND - 7/10 ( B )
THE BLACK CAULDRON - 6/10 (C+)
THE GREAT MOUSE DETECTIVE - 8/10 (A-)
OLIVER & COMPANY - 9/10 (A-)
THE LITTLE MERMAID - 10/10 (A+)
RESCUERS DOWN UNDER - 7/10 (B-)
BEAUTY AND THE BEAST - 10/10 (A+)
ALADDIN - 9/10 (A)
THE LION KING - 10/10 (A+)
POCAHONTAS - 9/10 (A)
THE HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME - 8/10 (B+)
HERCULES - 6/10 (C+)
MULAN - 10/10 (A+)
TARZAN - 9/10 (A)
FANTASIA 2000 - 8/10 (A-)
ATLANTIS: THE LOST EMPIRE - 7/10 (B-)
LILO & STITCH - 10/10 (A+)
TREASURE PLANET - 8/10 (B+)
BROTHER BEAR - 9/10 (A-)
HOME ON THE RANGE - 5/10 ( C )

[my chicken is infected]

1. <i>Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs</i> - 10/10
2. <i>Pinocchio</i> - 9/10
3. <i>Fantasia</i> - 7.5/10
4. <i>Dumbo</i> - 8/10
5. <i>Bambi</i> - 10/10
6. <i>Saludos Amigos</i> - 5/10
7. <i>The Three Caballeros</i> - 4/10
8. <i>Make Mine Music</i> - 7.5/10
9. <i>Fun and Fancy Free</i> - 7.5/10
10. <i>Melody Time</i> - 7.5/10
11. <i>The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad</i> - 7.5/10
12. <i>Cinderella</i> - 10/10
13. <i>Alice in Wonderland</i> - 9/10
14. <i>Peter Pan</i> - 8/10
15. <i>Lady and the Tamp</i> - 8/10
16. <i>Sleeping Beauty</i> - 10/10
17. <i>101 Dalmatians</i> - 8/10
18. <i>The Sword in the Stone</i> - 8/10
19. <i>The Jungle Book</i> - 8/10
20. <i>The Aristocats</i> - 8.5/10
21. <i>Robin Hood</i> - 6/10
22. <i>The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh</i> - 9/10
23. <i>The Rescuers</i> - 8/10
24. <i>The Fox and the Hound</i> - 8/10
25. <i>The Black Cauldron</i> - 9.5/10
26. <i>The Great Mouse Detective</i> - 8/10
27. <i>Oliver & Company</i> - 9/10
28. <i>The Little Mermaid</i> - 10/10
29. <i>The Rescuers Down Under</i> - 7.5/10
30. <i>Beauty and the Beast</i> - 10+/10
31. <i>Aladdin</i> - 10/10
32. <i>The Lion King</i> - 8/10
33. <i>Pocahontas</i> - 9/10
34. <i>The Hunchback of Notre Dame</i> - 9/10
35. <i>Hercules</i> - 8/10
36. <i>Mulan</i> - 8/10
37. <i>Tarzan</i> - 7/10
38. <i>Fantasia 2000</i> - Haven't seen it.
39. <i>The Emperor's New Groove</i> - 7/10
40. <i>Atlantis: The Lost Empire</i> - 8/10
41. <i>Lilo & Stitch</i> - 9/10
42. <i>Treasure Planet</i> - Haven't seen it.
43. <i>Brother Bear</i> - 8/10
44. <i>Home on the Range</i> - Haven't seen it

[Lazario]

I really can't do this list like everyone else, so I'll rank in order of favorites

My rating system is bound to be different from yours, but here they are,
in order of best to least:

1. Sleeping Beauty - 5
2. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 5
3. Alice in Wonderland - 5
4. Dumbo - 5
5. The Little Mermaid - 4.5
6. The Jungle Book - 4.5
7. The Black Cauldron - 4.5
8. Aladdin - 4
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 4
10. The Rescuers - 4
11. Cinderella - 3.5
12. 101 Dalmatians - 3.5
13. Pinocchio - 3.5
14. The Great Mouse Detective - 3.5
15. Fantasia - 3.5
16. The Three Caballeros - 3.5
17. The Sword in the Stone - 3
18. Pocahontas - 3
19. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 3
20. Robin Hood - 3
21. Bambi - 3
22. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 3
23. Beauty and the Beast - 2.5
24. Lady and the Tramp - 2.5
25. Oliver & Company - 2.5
26. The Aristocats - 2.5
27. Peter Pan - 2
28. The Lion King - 1.5
29. The Fox and the Hound - 1.5


Haven't seen:
Saludos Amigos, Make Mine Music, Melody Time,
The Rescuers Down Under, Hercules, Mulan, Tarzan, Fantasia 2000,
The Emperor's New Groove, Atlantis: The Lost Empire, Lilo & Stitch,
Treasure Planet, Brother Bear, Home On the Range


Have seen, but don't remember well enough to rate:
The Hunchback of Notre Dame

(by the way, I've given this list a lot of thought, so these numbers are very much correct)