UltimateDisney.com | DVD Review Index | Upcoming Disney Movies | Recent Live Action (1980-Present) Films Page | Search This Site
The Pirates of the Caribbean Trilogy: The Curse of the Black Pearl - 2-Disc CE • 3-Disc Gift Set / Dead Man's Chest / At World's End
Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End Movie Review
|
"This is a mess." David Hasselhoff's Internet-circulating review of an uncooperative Wendy's hamburger is also perhaps the best way to succinctly assess Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End.
Arriving less than a year after the record-breaking Dead Man's Chest, this third installment of Disney's blockbuster adventure series offers more of the same -- Things open in Singapore, where resurrected Captain Barbossa (Geoffrey Rush), Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightley), and their nigh-untrackable lot of oddball pirates turn to Sao Feng (Chow Yun-Fat) for help in locating Captain Jack Sparrow (Johnny Depp), last seen being devoured by legendary sea monster the Kraken. The efforts of Barbossa and company, soon joined by Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) and Tia Dalma (Naomie Harris), to rescue Captain Jack are instantly complicated by murky motives and the arrival of the East India Trading Company, headed by boring antagonist Lord Cutler Beckett (Tom Hollander).
The journey to Davy Jones' Locker proves moderately compelling, though what awaits there raises the franchise to new heights of silliness. Johnny Depp turns in a mere caricature of his earlier performances, this time sharing the screen with countless clones of himself à la Michael Keaton in Multiplicity. Between this over-employed device and the central practice of bringing dead characters back to life, the word "uninspired" inevitably comes to mind.
What ensues next incorporates all parties, including: the squid-like Davy Jones (Bill Nighy), who is given a romantic back-story as his heart literally continues to pass hands in a locked chest; Will's father Bootstrap Bill (Stellan Skarsgård), who with the passage of time is losing his memory and physically becoming part of Jones' hellish Flying Dutchman ship; and Elizabeth's near-fiancé James Norrington (Jack Davenport), a morally ambiguous figure made extraneous by the years' various cast expansions.
Slow-paced and not very lively, it's rather disappointing to see the once-fresh Pirates franchise hobble to its (likely momentary) conclusion. For a movie so long in development that's spending so many millions of dollars on production and promotion, it's amazing that all of the people involved couldn't see where they went wrong here and corrected themselves. There is no change of personnel to cite; blame therefore must go to producer Jerry Bruckheimer, director Gore Verbinski, and writers Ted Elliott and Terry Rossio, who all, perhaps understandably, have developed this universe, to massively positive public approval, into something so big and lucrative that they can't possibly see it out in a coherent, satisfactory fashion.
At World's End feels closer to its immediate predecessor than The Curse of the Black Pearl, the original, subtitled-at-the-last-moment film that was embraced beyond all expectations in the summer of 2003. The worst way in which World's End is similar to Dead Man's, however, is in its manufactured nature. The movie seems consciously designed to ensure repeat theater trips to pick up on everything in play. At any given point during the film, one is apt to ask "What the heck is going on exactly?" and get nowhere. "Who's betraying who?" The real question is "Why should we care?" The Bruckheimer style of moviemaking -- where only the rare shot can last more than four seconds -- collides with Elliott and Rossio's script, yielding something replete with both plot particulars and vagaries.
Like Dead Man's Chest, the movie picks up the slack a bit near the end, but this time it's not enough to overlook the dull, deliberately confusing happenings before. As long as there's billions of dollars to be made, I'm sure Disney and Jerry Bruckheimer will keep on churning out more Pirates movies, regardless of what they now say. After being disappointed by but tolerant of Dead Man's Chest and feeling even more let down by At World's End, I only hope that any further follow-ups will be dictated by worthy ideas and not merely a financial demand. While no film really needs a sequel (and crafting the last one for such still feels cheap), I really think more organic, restrained Pirates sequels would have been a good thing. Choreographing such elaborate money-makers has left me not caring about the fates of any/all the characters, even those I enjoyed getting to know less than four years ago.
By the time you're allowed to read this, screenings of At World's End will have already started, beginning 8 PM Thursday night at select theaters. As much as I wish it weren't the case, I'm sure that box office records will be set and that many flocking moviegoers will be able to overlook the movie's numerous flaws. They'll roast critics, fall for the hype, and be back in line before long to see it again. That's fine. Getting excited about a big movie is great fun and I can think of many worse things to spend one's money on. It's just a little sad that the Disney studio's all-time biggest hits and my favorite of all theme park rides will both be tainted by the flaws of two overblown sequels for a very long time to come.
NOTE: Like the previous two Pirates films, this one contains a scene at the end of the end credits. Unlike the last two, however, this is more of a conclusion than a throwaway joke (though it's still slightly funny in an unintentional way), so you may wish to endure the long scroll of names to see it. |
|
Related Reviews:
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl (3-Disc DVD)
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man's Chest (2-Disc DVD)
Meet the Robinsons (Movie) • Bridge to Terabithia (Movie)
Related Interview:
UD talks with the writers of all 3 Pirates of the Caribbean movies
Related Countdowns:
Top 30 Live Action Disney Films of All-Time
Top 30 Disney Villains
Related Products - At World's End Tie-In Books:
The Art of At World's End • Bring Me The Horizon: POTC - The Making of the Trilogy
POTC: AWE: Movie Storybook • Storybook with Compass and Picture Viewer
• Pirates Trilogy: The Complete Visual Guide • A Pirate's Tale: Play Pack
Glow-in-the-Dark Sticker Book • At World's End Novelization
The Black Pearl: A Pop-Up Pirate Ship • Saving Jack Sparrow
The Mystic's Journey • POTC: AWE - Singapore!
Escape from Davy Jones • The Missing Pirate
Related Products - At World's End Toys:
Jack Sparrow with Transforming Crab & Navigational Chart
Pirate King Elizabeth Swann with Glowing Brethren Court Globe & Sword
Singapore Disguised Elizabeth Swann with Double Holster, Pistols & Asian Cloak
Prisoner Will Turner with Sword & Navigational Charts
Sao Feng with Sword • Gibbs with Pistol • Norrington with Pistol • Marty with Jack the Monkey
12-inch Jack Sparrow • 12-inch Will Turner
Reviewed May 25, 2007.