pap64 wrote:Marce82 wrote:See now, I'm not a gamer either. And to be honest, after watching the two trailers, I have to admit I have no interest whatsoever in this film. Seems like a story I have seen done a thousand times, and the "clever" game references do nothing for me. Nor will they do for people that aren't or weren't gamers.
To semi-quote Howard Ashaman: " Does this film fit comfortable on the shelf with Pinocchio, Peter Pan and Cinderella?". I don't think so. I also don't think this film has universal appeal...
Hmmm... I don't think this will be a hit
I hope I'm wrong
I disagree with this post entirely. And here's why...
I am a gamer, so many of these references apply to me. But even then, I think Wreck it Ralph will still have a presence with audiences that aren't gamers. Why? Because I feel the story and characters will be strong enough that it will be universal to everyone, regardless if they are gamers or not.
Take for example Who Framed Roger Rabbit. One of the biggest appealing elements of the film are the cameo appearances by various cartoon characters from the golden age of animation. The film had a ton of them, and it too relied on jokes and tropes related to the world of animation. And yet, what really stood out for people was the story and the characters. The very adult themes of infidelity, murder and corruption, the subtle yet raunchy humor, the brisk pacing, action and mystery made it a huge it with people. Yeah, animated characters have more history than video game characters, but even then while people talk about how Mickey Mouse and Bugs Bunny met in that one scene, what stayed with them was the powerful story.
So don't be too surprised if Wreck it Ralph suddenly finds an audience with non-gamers because the story that has been given to the story has been solid based on what we have seen, read and heard. It is a very universal story about accepting yourself for who you are and having a huge impact in your world, as well as learning to appreciate everyone in your life, which in a way is a very classic Disney moral.
Now, regarding what you said about the movie being able to fit in with Peter Pan and Cinderella... well that's the beauty of this movie: it DOESN'T fit in. Wreck it Ralph seems to be something special and unique for Disney, a movie that seems honest with its humor and characters rather than aiming for the cool, hip audience (yeah some ads have the infamous DreamWorks face going on, but so far Ralph and friends have been sold as their own characters, not as super hip characters for the younger generation). Yeah, the movies you mentioned are class acts on their own, but comparing Ralph to them is diminishing its value and placing unfair judgment on it, which is exactly what Wreck it Ralph is talking about with the Vanellope story: being rejected because you somehow don't "fit" with the best when the chance hasn't even been given.
Let us also forget that on that shelf lies other Disney classics like Three Caballeros, the package films, Alice in Wonderland and such, movies that fans have deemed as "unworthy" of the Disney name, but are still part of that shelf along with Peter Pan and Cinderella.
If you feel that the movie isn't for you, well that's fine. But I think video game references and all, it will have an audience that isn't primarily composed of gamers. Heck, I know a lot of my friends who are not gamers yet still really want to see this movie because it looks fun, creative and different.