purin wrote:There was a teensy bit of music I heard that I knew I recognized but couldn't put my finger on... and now I can't remember what it sounded like. Something with trumpets, I think. Does anybody remember? Something from The Three Caballeros, maybe?
It was definitely The Three Caballeros. I noticed it immediately and kept wanting them to cut back to the TV to confirm my thoughts.
Anyway, as is already obvious by the sentence above, I saw the film today and loved it. I can't say it exceeded my expectations (which were pretty lofty), but it definitely met them. Note that spoilers follow.
Pros
* Amy Adams. This movie was completely hers, in my opinion. She played Giselle with such sinceirty that I wanted to hug her everytime she appeared. She definitely makes you feel for the character and plays her beyond stereotype. Giselle was just adorably sweet and much more endearing than Snow White (stone me if you must), especially when she gave the old lady money. Plus, she's an excellent crier, to boot.
* The rest of the cast. I had to single out Amy because she impressed me the most, but the cast was uniformly excellent. Each actor obviously had a lot of fun with his or her part. Patrick Dempsey took me off guard because he comes across so harshly in the beginning (this is a good thing) and convincingly warms up to Giselle. Rachel Covey was surprisingly natural as Morgan. Susan Sarandon, James Marsden, and Timothy Spall all maintained the right balance between caricature and realism, not venturing too far in either direction in a way that would turn the audience off.
* The animated scenes. I got chills watching the opening because it felt like classic Disney again. The animation was so fluid and graceful, filled with warm and vibrant colors. The backgrounds especially were gorgeous. I really liked the idea of giving the animals children voices rather than giving them distorted adult voices (though that worked great for Cinderella's mice, but it was nice to see something different here).
* The Disney princess cameos. Jodi Benson was given more lines than I expected, and it was nice to see her play cynical instead of bright and bubbly Ariel. Paige O' Hara and Judy Kuhn's cameos were hilarious, as well, both of them making the most of their few seconds of screentime.
* The songs. "Happy Working Song" may just be the most hilarious song written for a Disney film ever. The audience with me reacted really well to it (though I had already watched it online countless times). "That's How You Know" is delightfully tongue-in-cheek in terms of presentation and is the most elaborate musical number I've seen in a film in a long time (since Moulin Rouge, probably). "True Love's Kiss", like the other animated segments, just felt so very much like nostalgic Disney.
* The shopping montage. It may be cliche, but I like shopping montages in films, especially when it's between an adult and child. This scene really made me root for Giselle to be Morgan's mother (even though I already knew the ending). The bit where Morgan explains to Giselle how men perceive women is priceless.
* The ball. When I first heard the soundtrack online, I thought the song "So Close" would make a gorgeous accompaniment to Giselle and Robert's dance, and I was glad to see that's what the song was for. The whole ball sequence may actually be my favorite live-action scene in the film (yes, dare I say more than "Happy Working Song" and "That's How You Know"). I just love the way it was shot, and it's most definitely the most romantic portion of the film for me.
* The Disney references. Outside of what we already saw in trailers, TV spots, clips, and featurettes, here are the references I spotted for the first time during the film:
- Animated Giselle looks through two sapphires the way Dopey does with diamonds.
- The lobby of Robert's firm plays "Part of Your World" while Giselle admires the aquarium.
- The soap opera Paige O'Hara appears in has "Beauty and the Beast" for its underscoring.
- The Three Caballeros and Fun and Fancy Free play on Edward's hotel TV.
- Morgan has a Cinderella storybook in her room.
- The end credits feature visual references to Snow White, Cinderella, Sleeping Beauty, The Sword in the Stone, and The Little Mermaid (I think there were a couple more).
- A slew of character names are references, but these I saw already from IMDb. They include Nancy TREMAINE, Robert and Morgan PHILLIP, Mary Ilene Caselotti (the TV news reporter, named after the three Walt princess actresses), Phoebe and Ethan BANKS, and Angela (the character Paige played, probably a reference to her Beauty and the Beast co-star).
- Two bits which may or may not be references that we've seen before in ads: first is Giselle's tumble down the vortex, which may be an Alice in Wonderland reference (if her gown inflated and she had floated instead of fallen, it definitely would've been). The other is Giselle and Robert sliding down the building shingles which could be a Hunchback of Notre Dame reference.
Cons
* The climax was weak. It needed to be more action-packed and frightening. I never felt any danger at all during this, and while I'm sure Narissa's demise is a tribute to the way dozens of Disney villains have died, I would've liked to have seen a different spin on it. The way it was handled felt kind of cheap. EDIT: After making this post, I checked DarkHorizons.com to see what movie news was up for today. They had an interview with Amy Adams, and she had this to say about the climax: "But also doing the last sequences with the dragon [was challenging], it initially was a much longer sequence, so I spent a lot of time wet in the rain in a harness hanging off the sword trying to climb, which I guess terrified the kids too much." Well, that explains why it's all over as soon as it's begun. Disney edited it down for the kids.
* Idina Menzel did a good job as Nancy, but it was disappointing how little screentime she had. For her to be Edward's match, she should've had as much screentime as him. A scene or two between her and Giselle would've been good. The two of them barely interacted.
* What happened to the other Disney princess actresses (Ilene Woods, Mary Costa, Linda Larkin, Lea Salonga, Irene Bedard, and Ming Na)? There were so many extras in this film that it should've been easy to find roles for them (for example, either Ilene or Mary could've played the old lady on the bus that later tells Giselle she saw Edward; any of the other women could've played the woman filing for divorce, etc.). Were none of these people available?
* Too few songs. I always consider a musical to have five or more songs. While this film has five, only three of them are sung by characters (I realize Nancy and Edward had a duet cut from the animated ending). Susan Sarandon can sing, so Narissa should've gotten a number. Don't get me wrong; the songs in the film are great, but for this film to be claiming to be a return to form, it barely qualifies as a musical.
* Speaking of songs, I don't like that they ended the film with Carrie Underwood's "Ever After." It's not a bad song, but I felt that since the film opened classically, it should've ended classically. I would've liked to have the Disney Chorus return for perhaps a reprise of True Love's Kiss during the ending montage.
All in all, it was a wonderful film and has already become one of my favorite Disney movies. I'd give it four stars out of four or (if you want to deal with specifics) a 9 out of 10.