2099net wrote:David S. wrote:Well, if one is sticking with STANDARD DVD and hoping they can at least be bothered to make the Platinum AS GOOD AS the previous 2-disc Sleeping Beauty release on standard DVD, this could be a cause for concern.
Be concerned already. You only have to look at the last three years of Disney DVD releases to realise that.
Yes, I know the quality of Disney DVD has been declining in general ever since the Tarzan 1 disc fiasco, and obviously the Platinums have declined compared to say, Snow White and Aladdin (cough, Peter Pan "read along" feature????) . But still, I think we would all agree that whether each Platinum was as good as it could/should be, they each at least represented the best release of that title so far on DVD. Speculation that the meaty bonus features on SB would be found in the Cine Explore feature on Blue Ray (and presumably NOT on the standard) is what I meant by concern - that this could theoretically be the first Platinum DVD to not be more definitive than it's previous edition.
2099net wrote:
The stuff on the Sleeping Beauty SE isn't stuff that fits in with the Cine Explore feature. The SB SE features were largely long running archive footage. Cine Explore shows images on screen over a commentary and also branches out to short featurettes (imagine the Atlantis DVD or the Dinosaur DVD). Now Bonus View is implemented, its possible branching may be removed, and the short featurettes simply displayed as smaller picture in picture content though.
Well, I was responding to the speculation posted above by Disneykid that possibly the extras on the SE would be part of Cine Explore
2099net wrote:
The Platinum line still has credibility? That's news for me. Personally, when Disney were making their Vault Disney titles, and stuff like the awesome Atlantis: The Lost Empire 2 discer (or even as recently as the international Lilo and Stitch 2 discer) the Platinum line had already lost its credibility.
Really people, they're just pointless labels! I mean, how can anyone think that they're more after recent Platinum editions like Peter Pan (UGH!) or 101 Dalmations (first disc uses little more than half the capacity of a DVD9, and the second disc is just okay, but also filled with those stupid virtual puppies).
Yes, I know it's just a name. I don't care if they call it Platinum, Ambrosia, Copper, or Puce, I just want solid 2-disc editions with lots of substantial bonus features.
I meant the Platinum "brand" would be losing "credibility" is the sense that, flaws and all, each Platinum was still the best DVD release each has had so far. I know Mermaid, Lady and the Tramp, Peter Pan, 101 Dalmatians etc. could and should be "meatier" - however, I still enjoy what is there and don't feel like these are bad releases per se. (that Peter Pan 70 something minute read along, though, just makes NO SENSE and wastes space)
So it would follow that if the Platinum SB has less "meat" in the bonus catagory than the SE - then the line would lose "credibility" in the sense that it would no longer represent the most comprehensive release to date of this title, which could be a historic low first for anything bearing the "platinum" name.
By dropping the pan and scan transfer (as they should) there is NO reason not to port over everything from the SE and still have room for new bonus features.