Hurt or Heal: Disney Heroines

[SmartAleck25]

Snow White - 26
Cinderella - 28
Ariel- 36
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 32 (-2)
Mulan- 36 (+2)
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Scarred4life]

Snow White - 24 (-2)
Cinderella - 28
Ariel- 36
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34 (+2)
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Disney Duster]

Snow White - 24
Cinderella - 30 (+2)
Ariel- 34 (-2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Big Disney Fan]

Snow White - 26 (+2)
Cinderella - 28 (-2)
Ariel- 34
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[WDWLocal]

Snow White - 26
Cinderella - 28
Ariel- 32 (-2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 38 (+2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Jay]

Snow White - 28(+2)
Cinderella - 28
Ariel- 32
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36 (-2)
Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Disney's Divinity]

Snow White - 28
Cinderella - 28
Ariel- 34 (+2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 32 (-2)
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Scarred4life]

Snow White - 26 (-2)
Cinderella - 28
Ariel- 34
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34 (+2)
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Disney Duster]

Snow White - 26
Cinderella - 30 (+2)
Ariel- 32 (-2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Big Disney Fan]

Snow White - 26 (+2)
Cinderella - 28 (-2)
Ariel- 32
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Escapay]

BDF, you've voted twice on the following days:

September 18, 2010:
1:08 pm (Pacific)
9:31 pm (Pacific) - shows up as 12:31 am on September 19 (Eastern)

September 20, 2010:
9:09 am (Pacific)
10:20 pm (Pacific) - shows up as 1:20 am on September 21 (Eastern)

As such, those votes don't count, so I'm re-instating 4 points to Cinderella and removing 4 points from Snow White, which should cover your second votes (9:31, 10:20) from those days. Your other votes, including your latest one, still count.

In the future, everyone please remember that "day" is defined by your own time zone, it's not based on Eastern Standard Time. You can't vote at noon Pacific / 3 pm Eastern, then again at 10 pm Pacific / 1 am Eastern and call it two different days.

Points are now the following:

Snow White - 22 (fixed)
Cinderella - 32 (fixed)
Ariel- 32
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

In addition, to get this game moving faster, revert back to the original HoH rules:

Heal a Heroine with 2 points
Hurt a Heroine with 2 points
Heal a Heroine with 1 point, Hurt another Heroine with 1 point.

Too many are close to the 40-point cap that there would be no way to keep voting a simultaneous +2/-2 without going over the point cap. So the original option of just hurting or healing has to be in play.

Jay, I hope you don't mind that I'm more or less "taking over" by always ruling in. But someone has to.

albert

[WDWLocal]

Snow White - 22
Cinderella - 32
Ariel- 30 (-2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Disney's Divinity]

Snow White - 22
Cinderella - 32
Ariel- 32 (+2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 32 (-2)
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Scarred4life]

Snow White - 20 (-2)
Cinderella - 32
Ariel- 32
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 32
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Disney Duster]

Thank you wise, fair Escapay.

Disney's Divinity, what did he just say?! I'm just kidding, you probably missed what he said. I shall fix it for you, and I shall, extremely reluctantly, fix it to what you would probably want. If you don't like it, you can change it, but you gotta step in.

Snow White - 20
Cinderella - 34 (+2)
Ariel- 32
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34 (fixed)
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 36

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Jay]

Snow White - 22(+2)
Cinderella - 34
Ariel- 32
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 34(-2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Disney Duster]

So Escapay's rule don't count? I thought they did because he made these games, I thought he had control over them. If his new rules don't count, I want to hurt someone today...

[Escapay]

So Escapay's rule don't count? I thought they did because he made these games, I thought he had control over them. If his new rules don't count, I want to hurt someone today...

Like I said in my PM, this HoH is Jay's game so technically he should have the final say in any rule changes.

So he either decided to retain the simultaneous +2/-2 or he never bothered reading my post.

Still, the simultaneous will screw up voting eventually onces there is more than one Heroine at the 40 point cap, so I'm reposting this again. If people want to follow it, they can: (and I'd rather they did)

To get this game moving faster, revert back to the original HoH rules:

Heal a Heroine with 2 points
Hurt a Heroine with 2 points
Heal a Heroine with 1 point, Hurt another Heroine with 1 point.

Too many are close to the 40-point cap that there would be no way to keep voting a simultaneous +2/-2 without going over the point cap. So the original option of just hurting or healing has to be in play.

Jay, I hope you don't mind that I'm more or less "taking over" by always ruling in. But someone has to.

And just to show I'm not just someone stepping in and taking over...I'll do a vote. (*gasp!*)

Snow White - 22
Cinderella - 34
Ariel- 30 (-2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 34
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 34

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

albert

[Disney Duster]

This means Divinity's hurt still counts, and that I can hurt, too.

Snow White - 22
Cinderella - 34
Ariel- 28 (-2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 32 (fixed)
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 34

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora

[Disney's Divinity]

I don't think there's anything wrong with the +2/-2. I just wish there was a +4 or -4 option. If you went +1/-1 you might as well half all the scores, otherwise it'll take forever. But I'll change if Jay wants to.

Also, I added 2 to Esmeralda, because I didn't want Scarredforlife to be the only who didn't +2/-2.

Snow White - 22
Cinderella - 34
Ariel- 30 (+2)
Pocahontas- 40
Esmeralda- 32 (-2)
Mulan- 36
Tiana- 34

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marion
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora[/quote]