OMG!lord-of-sith wrote:It's been my theory from the moment I finished book 4 that Dumbledore is evil. When I say he's evil, I don't mean he's voldemort, but.... oh here:
My theory is that a death eater, very close to Voldemort, killed Faux and put Dumbledore's soul inside of the body. Then, the death eater put himself in Dumbledore's body. If you think about it, Faux has always kinda been there for Harry (as shown in CoS) and Dumbledore has always sort of dissapeared whenever Harry faught Voldemort (all of the books except 5). And there is a part in GoF (after Harry has escaped from Voldemort) that Dumbledore has a (happy) twinkle in his eyes while talking to harry about his dreadful experience (or something like that). But, that's probably not even close to what really happens.
I have had that suspiscion for ages, and everyone thinks I'm mad!
My reasoning is the same as yours, about the twinkle, but also in Order of the Phoenix, when Harry is doing occulemency, he flinches at Dumbledore!
It's been 2 years since I read it, so I'll go and see if I can find the quote.
Also who does every trust without pretty much unboubtedly?
Who tells Harry pretty much everything?
I'm still undecided about whether he is evil or not, but it could be a possible avenue.
Of course JK Rowling could be trying to throw us off the scent!
