Rate the Disney Animated Classics

[Satoshi]

Wow! You sure have some great movies that you still have to see, like Treasure Planet.

Fixed.

[Tangela]

Wow! You sure have some great movies that you still have to see, like Treasure Planet.

Fixed.

That's not me!!! Treasure Planet is thrash!
There, now that is better!

[Udvarnoky]

Apparently I enjoy Robin Hood more than many people.

[AwallaceUNC]

I like Robin Hood a lot too.

MisterMaleficent, welcome aboard. Maleficent has the distinction of my favorite Disney villain, I think she's awesome, so I love the sn. I agree, I love Sleeping Beauty, but wouldn't say it's "best." It comes closer than most too. You should see some of the earlier ones, especially Cinderella!
How old are you, btw? (Just wondering). Anyhoo, welcome.

-Aaron

[2099net]

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9
2. Pinocchio - 8
3. Fantasia - 8
4. Dumbo - 8
5. Bambi - Not Seen
6. Saludos Amigos - 6
7. The Three Caballeros - 8
8. Make Mine Music - 6
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 7
10. Melody Time - 6
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 7
12. Cinderella - seen so long ago not fair to comment
13. Alice in Wonderland - 4
14. Peter Pan - 5
15. Lady and the Tamp - 7
16. Sleeping Beauty - 9
17. 101 Dalmatians - 9
18. The Sword in the Stone - 4
19. The Jungle Book - 6
20. The Aristocats - 4
21. Robin Hood - 4
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 6
23. The Rescuers - 6
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6
25. The Black Cauldron - 6
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 8
27. Oliver & Company - 6
28. The Little Mermaid - 7
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 6
30. Beauty and the Beast - 8
31. Aladdin - 8
32. The Lion King - 7
33. Pocahontas - 8
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 10
35. Hercules - 9 (in retrospect after repeated viewings)
36. Mulan - 8
37. Tarzan - 8
38. Fantasia 2000 - 8
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 7
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 7
41. Lilo & Stitch - 8
42. Treasure Planet - 8
43. Brother Bear - N/A

[Jack]

I raised my rating on Dumbo considerably after having seen it again for the first time years. I forgot how great it was.

[Tangela]

I raised my rating on Dumbo considerably after having seen it again for the first time years. I forgot how great it was.

Yeah, you probably watched The Rescuers when you were 8, so watch it again.

[Joe Carioca]

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 5/5
2. Pinocchio - 5/5
3. Fantasia - 5/5
4. Dumbo - 4.½/5
5. Bambi - 4/5
6. Saludos Amigos - 3/5
7. The Three Caballeros - 4/5
8. Make Mine Music - only saw it when I was little, can't really remember it
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 2.½/5
10. Melody Time - 3.½/5
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 4/5
12. Cinderella - 3/5
13. Alice in Wonderland - 5/5
14. Peter Pan - 5/5
15. Lady and the Tamp - 3.½/5
16. Sleeping Beauty - 4.½/5
17. 101 Dalmatians - 3/5
18. The Sword in the Stone - 3.½/5
19. The Jungle Book - 3.½/5
20. The Aristocats - 2/5
21. Robin Hood - 2/5
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 4/5
23. The Rescuers - 4/5
24. The Fox and the Hound - 2/5
25. The Black Cauldron - 3/5
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 4.½/5
27. Oliver & Company - 2.½/5
28. The Little Mermaid - 5/5
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 3.½/5
30. Beauty and the Beast - 5/5
31. Aladdin - 5/5
32. The Lion King - 5/5
33. Pocahontas - 5/5
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4/5 -
*if only there were no stupid gargoyles...
35. Hercules - 4/5
36. Mulan - 3.½/5
37. Tarzan - 4/5
38. Fantasia 2000 - 4.½/5
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 4/5
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 3.½/5
41. Lilo & Stitch - 5/5
42. Treasure Planet - 3/5
43. Brother Bear - 4/5

[AwallaceUNC]

34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 4/5 -
*if only there were no stupid gargoyles...

I love the gargoyles! Especially the one voiced by that woman in White Christmas and the Sister Acts!

-Aaron

[MickeyMousePal]

Jack Wrote:

23. The Rescuers - 5.5/10

Why so low Jack.
I really enjoyed that film.
Penny got kidnapped and she was so brave.
Throwing that bottle to the ocean to get help was a great idea.
I recommend you to watch it again.
Go buy it or rent it .

[Tangela]

Jack Wrote:

23. The Rescuers - 5.5/10

Why so low Jack.
I really enjoyed that film.
Penny got kidnapped and she was so brave.
Throwing that bottle to the ocean to get help was a great idea.
I recommend you to watch it again.
Go buy it or rent it .

Yeah, I think Jack's judging the animation, not the film itself, besides that he hasn't even seen the huge change from the VHS to the DVD, the movie has really changed, as I so kindly told him already.

[Jack]

The Rescuers is a movie I remember very well, and I think it's just a bland movie overall. There are some good points, but I feel it's mediocre.

[Wonderlicious]

I'm reviving another thread again!

Snow White- 9/10
Pinocchio- 10/10
Fantasia- 9/10
Dumbo- 9/10
Bambi- 7.5/10
Saludos Amigos- I think I saw this long ago, so unfair to rate
Three Cabelleros- 7/10
Make Mine Music- n/a
Fun and Fancy Free- 7/10
Melody Time- 5/10
Ichabod and Mr Toad- 8/10
Cinderella- 8.5/10
Alice in Wonderland- 10/10
Peter Pan- 9.5/10
Lady and the Tramp- 9/10
Sleeping Beauty- 8/10
101 Dalmatians- 7/10
The Sword in the Stone- 6/10
The Jungle Book- 7/10
The Aristocats- 5/10
Robin Hood- 8.5/10
Winnie the Pooh- 7/10
The Rescuers- 8/10
The Fox and the Hound- 5/10
The Black Cauldron- 7/10
The Great Mouse Detective- saw too long ago to achieve a fair rating
Oliver and Company- 7/10
The Little Mermaid- 10/10
The Rescuers Down Under- 8/10
Beauty and the Beast- 10/10
Aladdin- 9.5/10
The Lion King- 9/10
Pocahontas- 7.5/10
Hunchback of Notre Dame- 6.5/10
Hercules- 6/10
Mulan- 9.5/10
Tarzan- 7/10
Fantasia 2000- 6.5/10
Emperor's New Groove- 7/10
Atlantis- 5/10
Lilo and Stitch- 8/10
Treasure Planet- 3/10
Brother Bear- 9/10
Home on the Range- n/a

[manny]

I think I'm going to like it here....

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 8/10
2. Pinocchio - 8/10
3. Fantasia - 7/10
4. Dumbo -7/10
5. Bambi - 8/10
6. Saludos Amigos - Have not seen
7. The Three Caballeros - 6/10
8. Make Mine Music - Have not seen
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 6/10
10. Melody Time - Have not seen
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Have not seen
12. Cinderella - 8/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 7/10
14. Peter Pan - 8/10
15. Lady and the Tamp - 8/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 8/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 8/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 7/10
19. The Jungle Book - 7/10
20. The Aristocats - 7/10
21. Robin Hood - 6/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 7/10
23. The Rescuers - 8/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 9/10
25. The Black Cauldron - Have not seen
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 6/10
27. Oliver & Company - 7/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 10/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 9/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 9/10
32. The Lion King - 10/10
33. Pocahontas - 9/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 8/10
35. Hercules - 6/10
36. Mulan - 9/10
37. Tarzan - 8/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - Have not seen
39. The Emperor's New Groove - Have not seen (and don't want to)
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 7/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 7/10
42. Treasure Planet - Have not seen
43. Brother Bear - 10/10

I guess I rated the movies that I grew up a little bit higher because of the fact that it means much more to me than the others.

Also, someone mentioned that if Brother Bear was released about 10 years earlier when animated movies flourished and Disney was at it's best, it would have done so much more better. Brother Bear was an underrated movie that not many people gave a chance.

[Jack]

Hey, I remember this topic!

Updated my original post with my revised ratings for all the Animated Classics.

[Jack]

Opps, I didn't realize manny was a new member! Welcome to the forums, glad to have ya!

I agree with you about BB - a much stronger film than many people say it is, and certainly one of the best movies Disney has put out recently.

[azul017]

HS means those that I haven't seen yet.

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9/10
2. Pinocchio - 3/10
3. Fantasia - 10/10
4. Dumbo - 5/10
5. Bambi - 10/10
6. Saludos Amigos - HS
7. The Three Caballeros - HS
8. Make Mine Music - HS
9. Fun and Fancy Free - HS
10. Melody Time - HS
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - HS
12. Cinderella - 5/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 5/10
14. Peter Pan - 7/10
15. Lady and the Tramp - 7.5/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 9/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 6/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 5/10
19. The Jungle Book - 5/10
20. The Aristocats - 4/10
21. Robin Hood - 4/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 7/10
23. The Rescuers - 7/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6/10
25. The Black Cauldron - HS
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 7/10
27. Oliver & Company - 5/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 10/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 6/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 8/10
33. Pocahontas - 7/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 8/10
35. Hercules - 7/10
36. Mulan - 10/10
37. Tarzan - 1/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - HS
39. The Emperor's New Groove - HS
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 5/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 9/10
42. Treasure Planet - HS
43. Brother Bear - HS
44. Home on the Range - HS

[Disneykid]

I went back and edited my list to include Brother Bear and Home on the Range. I agree with those that say Brother Bear's very underrated. Although I noticed some rehashed elements, I feel that overall it's a solid film. As a matter of fact, I find myself liking it more and more with each successive viewing.

Joe: I'm curious. You rated Cinderella 3 out of 5. Considering how anxious you've been over the film's DVD release, I figured you liked it more than that, or is that rating just outdated?

[panhead4life]

1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 10/10
2. Pinocchio - 6/10
3. Fantasia - 9/10
4. Dumbo - 9/10
5. Bambi - 10/10
6. Saludos Amigos - Yet To See
7. The Three Caballeros - Yet To See
8. Make Mine Music - Yet To See
9. Fun and Fancy Free - Yet To See
10. Melody Time - Yet To See
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Yet To See
12. Cinderella - 10/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 6/10
14. Peter Pan - 10/10
15. Lady and the Tamp - 10/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 9/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 10/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 9/10
19. The Jungle Book - 9/10
20. The Aristocats - Yet To See
21. Robin Hood - 9/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - Yet To See
23. The Rescuers - 6/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 7/10
25. The Black Cauldron - Yet To See
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 9/10
27. Oliver & Company - Yet To See
28. The Little Mermaid - 9.5/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 7/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 10/10
33. Pocahontas - 8/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 5/10
35. Hercules - Yet To See
36. Mulan - 10/10
37. Tarzan - Yet To See
38. Fantasia 2000 - 8/10
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 8/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 1/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - Yet To See
42. Treasure Planet - 10/10
43. Brother Bear - Yet To See
44. Home on the Range - Yet To See

[lolopimp]

On a scale of 1 through 10, rate the full-length animated features..
Here's my list:
Snow White:8
Pinocchio: 6
Fantasia: 7
Bambi: 7
Cinderella: 5
Sleeping Beauty:8
101 Dalmatians: 7
Lady and the Tramp: 7
Jungle Book: 6
Fox and the Hound: 4
Little Mermaid: 9
Beauty and the Beast: 10
Aladdin: 10
The Lion King: 11 out of 10!!!(if it existed)
Pocahontas: 6
The Hunchback of Notre Dame: 5
Hercules: 3
Mulan: 7
Lilo and Stitch: 8
Home on the Range: 1


I ranked the movies that first popped into my head so there it is. You may just rank the movies above; all of them, or maybe only the ones that you want (if you're lazy)