the monkeys were gorgeous though 
and yay im happy to see someone else thinks the rescuers is a masterpiece 
Rate the Disney Animated Classics
-
Prince Adam
- Anniversary Edition
- Posts: 1318
- Joined: Wed Jun 25, 2003 4:44 pm
- Location: The Great, Wide Somewhere (Ont, Canada)
I'm going to try these as much in order as possible:
Snow White 10/10-seeing as how this is the first, it can't be any lower. Although the characters seem a little transparent, and the first half is a little dull, without it, we wouldn't have all the other greats.
Pinocchio 8/10-it was my first VHS, and will always have a special place in my heart. Sometimes it borderlines on being too "kiddie" though.
Bambi 9/10-almost perfect. It bored me as a small child, though.
Dumbo 7/10-the first movie to make me cry, but it definitely borderlines on being "kiddie"
Cinderella 10/10-after a long dryspell, this was a long-awaited saviour for the Disney company. Can't help but fall in love with it.
Sleeping Beauty 9/10-almost perfect, but frightening and intense for younger ones.
Alice in Wonderland 7/10-borderlines on being "kiddie" and episodic
Peter Pan 10/10-perfect. Captures what childhood is supposed to be.
The Rescuers 9/10-made at the wrong time, and highly underrated. If only Snoops was less comical, and more evil.
The Little Mermaid 10/10-perfect
Beauty and the Beast 10/10-perfect
Aladdin 8/10-loved it as a kid, but now I find the Genie so annoying.
Lion King 8/10-highly overrated.
Pocahontas 9/10-very underrated.
Hunchback 10/10 although very intense, this is one of the first Disney movies for grownups
Tired of typing, so I'll do the others later.
Snow White 10/10-seeing as how this is the first, it can't be any lower. Although the characters seem a little transparent, and the first half is a little dull, without it, we wouldn't have all the other greats.
Pinocchio 8/10-it was my first VHS, and will always have a special place in my heart. Sometimes it borderlines on being too "kiddie" though.
Bambi 9/10-almost perfect. It bored me as a small child, though.
Dumbo 7/10-the first movie to make me cry, but it definitely borderlines on being "kiddie"
Cinderella 10/10-after a long dryspell, this was a long-awaited saviour for the Disney company. Can't help but fall in love with it.
Sleeping Beauty 9/10-almost perfect, but frightening and intense for younger ones.
Alice in Wonderland 7/10-borderlines on being "kiddie" and episodic
Peter Pan 10/10-perfect. Captures what childhood is supposed to be.
The Rescuers 9/10-made at the wrong time, and highly underrated. If only Snoops was less comical, and more evil.
The Little Mermaid 10/10-perfect
Beauty and the Beast 10/10-perfect
Aladdin 8/10-loved it as a kid, but now I find the Genie so annoying.
Lion King 8/10-highly overrated.
Pocahontas 9/10-very underrated.
Hunchback 10/10 although very intense, this is one of the first Disney movies for grownups
Tired of typing, so I'll do the others later.
Defy Gravity...
-
Tangela
Here are my ratings
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9/10
2. Pinocchio -10/10
3. Fantasia - 10/10
4. Dumbo -8/10
5. Bambi - 8/10
6. Saludos Amigos - 6/10
7. The Three Caballeros - 7/10
8. Make Mine Music - 6/10
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 6/10
10. Melody Time - 7/10
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 9/10
12. Cinderella - 8/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 7/10
14. Peter Pan - 10/10
15. Lady and the Tamp - 9/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 8/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 8/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 7/10
19. The Jungle Book - 7/10
20. The Aristocats - 5/10
21. Robin Hood - 5/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8/10
23. The Rescuers - 3/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6/10
25. The Black Cauldron - 4/10
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 7.5/10
27. Oliver & Company - 5/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 10/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under -4/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 10/10
33. Pocahontas - 2/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 10/10
35. Hercules - 7/10
36. Mulan - 8/10
37. Tarzan - 9/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - 8/10
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 9/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 8/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 9/10
42. Treasure Planet - 7/10
43. Brother Bear - 6/10
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9/10
2. Pinocchio -10/10
3. Fantasia - 10/10
4. Dumbo -8/10
5. Bambi - 8/10
6. Saludos Amigos - 6/10
7. The Three Caballeros - 7/10
8. Make Mine Music - 6/10
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 6/10
10. Melody Time - 7/10
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 9/10
12. Cinderella - 8/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 7/10
14. Peter Pan - 10/10
15. Lady and the Tamp - 9/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 8/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 8/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 7/10
19. The Jungle Book - 7/10
20. The Aristocats - 5/10
21. Robin Hood - 5/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8/10
23. The Rescuers - 3/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6/10
25. The Black Cauldron - 4/10
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 7.5/10
27. Oliver & Company - 5/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 10/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under -4/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 10/10
33. Pocahontas - 2/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 10/10
35. Hercules - 7/10
36. Mulan - 8/10
37. Tarzan - 9/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - 8/10
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 9/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 8/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 9/10
42. Treasure Planet - 7/10
43. Brother Bear - 6/10
-
Tangela
-
Loomis
- Signature Collection
- Posts: 6357
- Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2003 4:44 pm
- Location: Sydney, Australia ... where there is no Magic Kingdom :(
- Contact:
Well, this is partly why I don't like ratings systems of any kind - giving a number to a film without a explanation is a but wacky.Tangela wrote:DDMAN26 wrote: 23. The Rescuers - 3/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6/10
25. The Black Cauldron - 4/10
For example, a number of people have rated Snow White and Hunchback as a 10/10 (or a similar combination of Snow White and a later film). Both are great films. I personally love them both. But how do you even begin to compare the two of them? Both might be worth 10/10, but were made in completely different times and spaces. Then you start to move into more dangerous territory, and by giving Hunchback 10/10, it is just as good as...I don't know....The Godfather, which one might also rate highly. Both fine films, but chalk and cheese. I guess my point is that I don't like these "ratings" systems because it forces people to unfairly compare possibly completely different films.
This is not a comment on the people who have posted here, as you all know the films quite well presumably, but a comment on star and number ratings generally. It is just a problem I have. I'm dealing.
Oh, and Lilo and Stitch - 10/10.
Behind the Panels - Comic book news, reviews and podcast
The Reel Bits - All things film
Twitter - Follow me on Twitter
The Reel Bits - All things film
Twitter - Follow me on Twitter
-
Mr. Toad
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4360
- Joined: Thu Sep 11, 2003 8:49 pm
- Location: Victoria, BC
- Contact:
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9/10
2. Pinocchio - 8/10
3. Fantasia - 10/10
4. Dumbo - 9/10
5. Bambi - 6/10
6. Saludos Amigos - 6/10
7. The Three Caballeros - 7/10
8. Make Mine Music - 7/10
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 6/10 - an average of 8 for mickey and the beanstock and 4 for pogo or whatever that dumb bears name was
10. Melody Time - 5/10
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 9/10
12. Cinderella - 7/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 9/10
14. Peter Pan - 9/10
15. Lady and the Tamp - 7/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 9/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 8/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 6/10
19. The Jungle Book - 9/10
20. The Aristocats - 8/10
21. Robin Hood - 5/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8/10
23. The Rescuers - 3/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6/10
25. The Black Cauldron - .5/10
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 6.5/10
27. Oliver & Company - 6/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 8.5/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 6.5/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 9/10
33. Pocahontas - 7/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 6/10
35. Hercules - 6/10
36. Mulan - 9/10
37. Tarzan - 8/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - 9/10
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 8.5/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 4/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 8/10
42. Treasure Planet - 7/10
43. Brother Bear - 8/10
2. Pinocchio - 8/10
3. Fantasia - 10/10
4. Dumbo - 9/10
5. Bambi - 6/10
6. Saludos Amigos - 6/10
7. The Three Caballeros - 7/10
8. Make Mine Music - 7/10
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 6/10 - an average of 8 for mickey and the beanstock and 4 for pogo or whatever that dumb bears name was
10. Melody Time - 5/10
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 9/10
12. Cinderella - 7/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 9/10
14. Peter Pan - 9/10
15. Lady and the Tamp - 7/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 9/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 8/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 6/10
19. The Jungle Book - 9/10
20. The Aristocats - 8/10
21. Robin Hood - 5/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8/10
23. The Rescuers - 3/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6/10
25. The Black Cauldron - .5/10
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 6.5/10
27. Oliver & Company - 6/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 8.5/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 6.5/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 9/10
33. Pocahontas - 7/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 6/10
35. Hercules - 6/10
36. Mulan - 9/10
37. Tarzan - 8/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - 9/10
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 8.5/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 4/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 8/10
42. Treasure Planet - 7/10
43. Brother Bear - 8/10
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 7/10 (I find the plot very bland, but I have to give it credit for being Walt's first full-length animated feature)
2. Pinocchio - 7.5/10 (Was always too dark for me as a kid and some of that feeling has rubbed off on me now)
3. Fantasia - Haven't seen it.
4. Dumbo - Haven't seen it. (At least not that I can remember)
5. Bambi - Haven't seen it. (Oh the horror!)
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't seen it.
7. The Three Caballeros - Haven't seen it.
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't seen it.
9. Fun and Fancy Free - Haven't seen it.
10. Melody Time - Haven't seen it.
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Haven't seen it.
12. Cinderella - 7/10 (Not sure why but I've never been entirely fond of this movie. Still a good movie though overall)
13. Alice in Wonderland - 7/10 (It's good but not great)
14. Peter Pan - 8.5/10 (Love the book, love the book adaption)
15. Lady and the Tamp - 6.5/10 (Not great, not bad)
16. Sleeping Beauty - 7.5/10 (Pretty good, but it'll never hold a special place in my heart)
17. 101 Dalmatians - 6.5/10 (Enjoyable, but certainly not on level with my favorites)
18. The Sword in the Stone - Haven't seen it.
19. The Jungle Book - 6/10 (Was never too fond of this one, but it certainly isn't a bad movie)
20. The Aristocats - Haven't seen in a long long time so I won't rate it.
21. Robin Hood - 6.5/10 (Like 101 Dalmatians, it's enjoyable, but not on level with my favorites)
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - Haven't seen in a long time so I won't rate it.
23. The Rescuers - Haven't seen in a long long time so I won't rate it.
24. The Fox and the Hound - Haven't seen in a long time so I won't rate it.
25. The Black Cauldron - 5.5/10 (Bleh. Hate the animation and the only character I really like is Gurgi, the thief)
26. The Great Mouse Detective - Haven't seen in a long time so I won't rate it.
27. Oliver & Company - 6/10 (Decent movie but nothing special)
28. The Little Mermaid - 9.5/10 (Ariel, oh Ariel, she's such a loveable character)
29. The Rescuers Down Under - Haven't seen in a long long time so I won't rate it.
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10 (Will love this movie till the day I die)
31. Aladdin - 9/10 (Gotta love the music! And, well, everything else about it!
)
32. The Lion King - 9/10 (A pure epic)
33. Pocahontas - Haven't seen yet.
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Haven't seen yet. (Getting it through the Buy 3 Get 1 Free deal)
35. Hercules - 8/10 (Just saw this for the first time recently and wow! was I impressed! Felt alot like Aladdin to me, just not quite as good)
36. Mulan - Haven't seen in a long time so I won't rate it.
37. Tarzan - 9/10 (Wow! I love this movie. Just everything about it, it's sooo awesome)
38. Fantasia 2000 - Haven't seen yet.
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 8/10 (Humor's great, animation's great, and the characters are great)
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 6/10 (Was good the first time through but I have trouble with repeat viewings)
41. Lilo & Stitch - 8/10 (Love the characters and plot, but for some reason, it just doesn't give me the warm feeling that other Disney flicks do)
42. Treasure Planet - 8.5/10 (What Atlantis tried to do was perfected in this movie)
43. Brother Bear - Haven't seen yet. (March 30th needs to get here quicker!)
2. Pinocchio - 7.5/10 (Was always too dark for me as a kid and some of that feeling has rubbed off on me now)
3. Fantasia - Haven't seen it.
4. Dumbo - Haven't seen it. (At least not that I can remember)
5. Bambi - Haven't seen it. (Oh the horror!)
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't seen it.
7. The Three Caballeros - Haven't seen it.
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't seen it.
9. Fun and Fancy Free - Haven't seen it.
10. Melody Time - Haven't seen it.
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Haven't seen it.
12. Cinderella - 7/10 (Not sure why but I've never been entirely fond of this movie. Still a good movie though overall)
13. Alice in Wonderland - 7/10 (It's good but not great)
14. Peter Pan - 8.5/10 (Love the book, love the book adaption)
15. Lady and the Tamp - 6.5/10 (Not great, not bad)
16. Sleeping Beauty - 7.5/10 (Pretty good, but it'll never hold a special place in my heart)
17. 101 Dalmatians - 6.5/10 (Enjoyable, but certainly not on level with my favorites)
18. The Sword in the Stone - Haven't seen it.
19. The Jungle Book - 6/10 (Was never too fond of this one, but it certainly isn't a bad movie)
20. The Aristocats - Haven't seen in a long long time so I won't rate it.
21. Robin Hood - 6.5/10 (Like 101 Dalmatians, it's enjoyable, but not on level with my favorites)
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - Haven't seen in a long time so I won't rate it.
23. The Rescuers - Haven't seen in a long long time so I won't rate it.
24. The Fox and the Hound - Haven't seen in a long time so I won't rate it.
25. The Black Cauldron - 5.5/10 (Bleh. Hate the animation and the only character I really like is Gurgi, the thief)
26. The Great Mouse Detective - Haven't seen in a long time so I won't rate it.
27. Oliver & Company - 6/10 (Decent movie but nothing special)
28. The Little Mermaid - 9.5/10 (Ariel, oh Ariel, she's such a loveable character)
29. The Rescuers Down Under - Haven't seen in a long long time so I won't rate it.
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10 (Will love this movie till the day I die)
31. Aladdin - 9/10 (Gotta love the music! And, well, everything else about it!
) 32. The Lion King - 9/10 (A pure epic)
33. Pocahontas - Haven't seen yet.
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Haven't seen yet. (Getting it through the Buy 3 Get 1 Free deal)
35. Hercules - 8/10 (Just saw this for the first time recently and wow! was I impressed! Felt alot like Aladdin to me, just not quite as good)
36. Mulan - Haven't seen in a long time so I won't rate it.
37. Tarzan - 9/10 (Wow! I love this movie. Just everything about it, it's sooo awesome)
38. Fantasia 2000 - Haven't seen yet.
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 8/10 (Humor's great, animation's great, and the characters are great)
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 6/10 (Was good the first time through but I have trouble with repeat viewings)
41. Lilo & Stitch - 8/10 (Love the characters and plot, but for some reason, it just doesn't give me the warm feeling that other Disney flicks do)
42. Treasure Planet - 8.5/10 (What Atlantis tried to do was perfected in this movie)
43. Brother Bear - Haven't seen yet. (March 30th needs to get here quicker!)
-
Son of the Morning
- Gold Classic Collection
- Posts: 177
- Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2004 1:46 pm
- Contact:
Note: This rating system is a bit skewered. At first, I was going to have it all be relative... '50' being an average Disney movie, et cetera. It didn't work out that way...
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 89/100
2. Pinocchio - 93/100
3. Fantasia - 96/100
4. Dumbo - 82/100
5. Bambi - 91/100
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't seen yet
7. The Three Caballeros - Haven't seen yet
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't seen yet
9. Fun and Fancy Free - Haven't seen yet
10. Melody Time - Haven't seen yet
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Haven't seen yet
12. Cinderella - 90/100
13. Alice in Wonderland - 92/100
14. Peter Pan - 95/100
15. Lady and the Tamp - 88/100
16. Sleeping Beauty - 95/100
17. 101 Dalmatians - 81/100
18. The Sword in the Stone - 90/100
19. The Jungle Book - 84/100
20. The Aristocats - 74/100
21. Robin Hood - 89/100
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 86/100
23. The Rescuers - 67/100
24. The Fox and the Hound - 79/100
25. The Black Cauldron - Haven't seen yet
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 78/100
27. Oliver & Company - 66/100
28. The Little Mermaid - 95/100
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 81/100
30. Beauty and the Beast - 100/100
31. Aladdin - 99/100
32. The Lion King - 98/100
33. Pocahontas - 90/100
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 96/100
35. Hercules - 85/100
36. Mulan - 89/100
37. Tarzan - 74/100
38. Fantasia 2000 - 99/100
39. The Emperor's New Groove - Haven't seen yet
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 43/100
41. Lilo & Stitch - 86/100
42. Treasure Planet - Haven't seen yet
43. Brother Bear - Haven't seen yet[/b]
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 89/100
2. Pinocchio - 93/100
3. Fantasia - 96/100
4. Dumbo - 82/100
5. Bambi - 91/100
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't seen yet
7. The Three Caballeros - Haven't seen yet
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't seen yet
9. Fun and Fancy Free - Haven't seen yet
10. Melody Time - Haven't seen yet
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Haven't seen yet
12. Cinderella - 90/100
13. Alice in Wonderland - 92/100
14. Peter Pan - 95/100
15. Lady and the Tamp - 88/100
16. Sleeping Beauty - 95/100
17. 101 Dalmatians - 81/100
18. The Sword in the Stone - 90/100
19. The Jungle Book - 84/100
20. The Aristocats - 74/100
21. Robin Hood - 89/100
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 86/100
23. The Rescuers - 67/100
24. The Fox and the Hound - 79/100
25. The Black Cauldron - Haven't seen yet
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 78/100
27. Oliver & Company - 66/100
28. The Little Mermaid - 95/100
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 81/100
30. Beauty and the Beast - 100/100
31. Aladdin - 99/100
32. The Lion King - 98/100
33. Pocahontas - 90/100
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 96/100
35. Hercules - 85/100
36. Mulan - 89/100
37. Tarzan - 74/100
38. Fantasia 2000 - 99/100
39. The Emperor's New Groove - Haven't seen yet
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 43/100
41. Lilo & Stitch - 86/100
42. Treasure Planet - Haven't seen yet
43. Brother Bear - Haven't seen yet[/b]
<a href="http://dvdaficionado.com/dvds.html?id=c ... nation">MY DVD COLLECTION</a>
-
PublicEnemy#1
- Gold Classic Collection
- Posts: 259
- Joined: Thu Feb 12, 2004 7:08 pm
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - A-
2. Pinocchio - Haven't seen in a while, will watch VHS later
3. Fantasia - Haven't seen in a while
4. Dumbo - Haven't seen in a while
5. Bambi - Haven't seen in a while
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't seen
7. The Three Caballeros - Haven't seen
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't seen
9. Fun and Fancy Free - Haven't seen
10. Melody Time - Haven't seen at all
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Haven't seen at all
12. Cinderella - A-
13. Alice in Wonderland - A-
14. Peter Pan - Haven't seen in a while
15. Lady and the Tamp - Haven't Seen in a while
16. Sleeping Beauty - A-
17. 101 Dalmatians - Haven't seen in a while
18. The Sword in the Stone - Haven't seen in a while
19. The Jungle Book - Haven't seen in a while
20. The Aristocats - Haven't seen in a while, will watch VHS later
21. Robin Hood - Haven't seen in a while
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - Haven't seen in a while
23. The Rescuers - A-
24. The Fox and the Hound - Haven't seen
25. The Black Cauldron - Haven't seen
26. The Great Mouse Detective - Haven't seen
27. Oliver & Company - Haven't seen in a while
28. The Little Mermaid - A+
29. The Rescuers Down Under - A-
30. Beauty and the Beast - A+++
31. Aladdin - A+
32. The Lion King - A+
33. Pocahontas - A-
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - A
35. Hercules - B+
36. Mulan - A-/B+
37. Tarzan - B+
38. Fantasia 2000 - 99/100
39. The Emperor's New Groove - Haven't seen
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - B
41. Lilo & Stitch - A-/B+
42. Treasure Planet - Haven't seen
43. Brother Bear - Haven't seen
I obviously need to catch up...
2. Pinocchio - Haven't seen in a while, will watch VHS later
3. Fantasia - Haven't seen in a while
4. Dumbo - Haven't seen in a while
5. Bambi - Haven't seen in a while
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't seen
7. The Three Caballeros - Haven't seen
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't seen
9. Fun and Fancy Free - Haven't seen
10. Melody Time - Haven't seen at all
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Haven't seen at all
12. Cinderella - A-
13. Alice in Wonderland - A-
14. Peter Pan - Haven't seen in a while
15. Lady and the Tamp - Haven't Seen in a while
16. Sleeping Beauty - A-
17. 101 Dalmatians - Haven't seen in a while
18. The Sword in the Stone - Haven't seen in a while
19. The Jungle Book - Haven't seen in a while
20. The Aristocats - Haven't seen in a while, will watch VHS later
21. Robin Hood - Haven't seen in a while
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - Haven't seen in a while
23. The Rescuers - A-
24. The Fox and the Hound - Haven't seen
25. The Black Cauldron - Haven't seen
26. The Great Mouse Detective - Haven't seen
27. Oliver & Company - Haven't seen in a while
28. The Little Mermaid - A+
29. The Rescuers Down Under - A-
30. Beauty and the Beast - A+++
31. Aladdin - A+
32. The Lion King - A+
33. Pocahontas - A-
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - A
35. Hercules - B+
36. Mulan - A-/B+
37. Tarzan - B+
38. Fantasia 2000 - 99/100
39. The Emperor's New Groove - Haven't seen
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - B
41. Lilo & Stitch - A-/B+
42. Treasure Planet - Haven't seen
43. Brother Bear - Haven't seen
I obviously need to catch up...
-
AwallaceUNC
- Signature Collection
- Posts: 9439
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 1:00 am
- Contact:
Some of these I'm having to rate based on what I remember, as I haven't seen a few of these in a long time, but here goes:
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9/10
2. Pinocchio - 8/10
3. Fantasia - 6/10
4. Dumbo - 7/10
5. Bambi - 3/10 (haven't seen in nearly 15 years!)
6. Saludos Amigos - #s 6-10 I haven't seen in a long time, and they are all kind of blurring together, so I won't rate them yet).
7. The Three Caballeros
8. Make Mine Music
9. Fun and Fancy Free
10. Melody Time
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Don't remember well enough
12. Cinderella - 10/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 8.8/10
14. Peter Pan - 7/10
15. Lady and the Tamp - 8/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 9/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 8.5/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 8/10
19. The Jungle Book - 7/10
20. The Aristocats - 8/10
21. Robin Hood - 8/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - Don't remember well enough
23. The Rescuers - 8/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 7/10
25. The Black Cauldron - 7/10
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 7.5/10
27. Oliver & Company - 7.5/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 10/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 7/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 10/10
33. Pocahontas - 7.5/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 8/10
35. Hercules - 8/10
36. Mulan - 5/10
37. Tarzan - 7/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - Haven't Yet Seen
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 7.9/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 7/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 6.5/10
42. Treasure Planet - Haven't Seen Yet
43. Brother Bear - Haven't Seen Yet
-Aaron
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9/10
2. Pinocchio - 8/10
3. Fantasia - 6/10
4. Dumbo - 7/10
5. Bambi - 3/10 (haven't seen in nearly 15 years!)
6. Saludos Amigos - #s 6-10 I haven't seen in a long time, and they are all kind of blurring together, so I won't rate them yet).
7. The Three Caballeros
8. Make Mine Music
9. Fun and Fancy Free
10. Melody Time
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - Don't remember well enough
12. Cinderella - 10/10
13. Alice in Wonderland - 8.8/10
14. Peter Pan - 7/10
15. Lady and the Tamp - 8/10
16. Sleeping Beauty - 9/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - 8.5/10
18. The Sword in the Stone - 8/10
19. The Jungle Book - 7/10
20. The Aristocats - 8/10
21. Robin Hood - 8/10
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - Don't remember well enough
23. The Rescuers - 8/10
24. The Fox and the Hound - 7/10
25. The Black Cauldron - 7/10
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 7.5/10
27. Oliver & Company - 7.5/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 10/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 7/10
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 10/10
33. Pocahontas - 7.5/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 8/10
35. Hercules - 8/10
36. Mulan - 5/10
37. Tarzan - 7/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - Haven't Yet Seen
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 7.9/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 7/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - 6.5/10
42. Treasure Planet - Haven't Seen Yet
43. Brother Bear - Haven't Seen Yet
-Aaron
• Author of Hocus Pocus in Focus: The Thinking Fan's Guide to Disney's Halloween Classic
and The Thinking Fan's Guide to Walt Disney World: Magic Kingdom (Epcot coming soon)
• Host of Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Pod, the longest-running Disney podcast
• Entertainment Writer & Moderator at DVDizzy.com
• Twitter - @aaronspod
and The Thinking Fan's Guide to Walt Disney World: Magic Kingdom (Epcot coming soon)
• Host of Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Pod, the longest-running Disney podcast
• Entertainment Writer & Moderator at DVDizzy.com
• Twitter - @aaronspod
I just saw Hunchback, and added my rating to my list. I really liked how it kept a reletively small scope on essentially 4 characters, and the emotional effect from Quasi's humiliation in the Festival was just suberbly heartbreaking. Also, Frollo was a great villian, although a bit single-sided. As others have brought out before, most the humor was totally out of place, and lowered my grade on the movie somewhat.
ok, here I go:
-SNOW WHITE 9.5
This movie is almost perfect, perhaps it is too cheesy for these days, so I find some scenes quite boring, like the "someday my prince will come" sequence that makes me press the "forward" button.
-PINOCHIO 7
I never liked this too much, visually is amazingly beautiful, but makes me yawn sometimes, specially when the cricket sings.
-FANTASIA 8
This movie is a classic masterpiece, and the wizard aprentice sequence is an icon.
-DUMBO 8.5
Beautiful movie, I cry every single time I see the scene when Dumbo visits his mom in that cell.
-BAMBI 8
haven't seen this movie in ages, the only thing I can remember is that I used to like it
-SALUDOS AMIGOS 6
-TREE CABALLEROS 7
-MAKE MINE MUSIC 7.5
-FUN AND FUNCY FREE 7
-MELODY TIME 7
-ICHABOD AND MR. TOAD 7.5
-CINDERELLA 10
this movie is absolutely wonderfull, the story, the animation, the music, all on this movie is great.
-ALICE IN WONDERLAND 9
visually beautiful, some missing parts from the book, but it is entertaining and fun.
-PETER PAN 9
another classic, when I think of disney, I always remember tinkerbell as an icon, and Hook is a great villian.
-LADY AND THE TRAMP 10
beautiful dog movie, romantic and suspencefull, a masterpiece with all its letters.
-SLEEPING BEAUTY 10
this movie s art!!!!! is a moving panting, the screenplay is not perfect, some plot holes, but still an awesome movie.
-101 DALMATIANS 10
this one has style, a fashion movie, the music, the backgrounds, the animation, simply beautiful
-JUNGLE BOOK 9
I found this movie quite entertaining, the mexican dubbing is outstanding and the songs make me sing for hours
-SWORD IN THE STONE 8
-ARISTOCATS 8
-ROBIN HOOD 9
-WINNIE THE POOH 9
-RESCUERS 8
good story and animation, Medusa is great, but I don't like the songs at all.
-FOX AND THE HOUND 9
yes, one of those movies that make me cry too, only four disney classics can do that
-BLACK CAULDRON 7
-GREAT MOUSE DETECTIVE 8
-OLIVER AND COMPANY 8
-LITTLE MERMAID 10
the best disney classic since dalmatians (IMO), this movie is flawless, fun and romantic
-RESCUERS DOWN UNDER 8
-BEAUTY AND THE BEAST 10
need I say more? this is the perfect animated movie
-ALADDIN 10
another flawless masterpiece
-LION KING 10
a phenomenon, a classic movie (not just animated), this is the most succesfull, requested, beloveb and hated tradicionally animated movie off all time
-POCAHONTAS 8
sorry, this is my least favorite 90's classic, just not as powerfull as its predecesors
-HUNCKBACK 9.5
if those gargoyles were'nt there this movie would be perfect, vusually stunning, musically awesome.
-HERCULES 9
another stylish movie, very fun to see
-MULAN 8.5)
-TARZAN 10
ohhh!!! that jungle is beautiful, wow... and phill's songs make this movie just great
-EMPEROR'S NEW GROOVE 9
Disney's funniest movie
-ATLANTIS 7
is this one really a disney movie??
-LILO AND STITCH 9
well, this is a real disney movie, the most original of them all
-TREASURE PLANET 7.5
a well deserved failure for the adapted story, not for the visuals. BEN is the worst character in all disney history
-BROTHER BEAR 9.5
eight years ago, this movie could have been really succesful, beautiful backgrounds and lovely characters
-SNOW WHITE 9.5
This movie is almost perfect, perhaps it is too cheesy for these days, so I find some scenes quite boring, like the "someday my prince will come" sequence that makes me press the "forward" button.
-PINOCHIO 7
I never liked this too much, visually is amazingly beautiful, but makes me yawn sometimes, specially when the cricket sings.
-FANTASIA 8
This movie is a classic masterpiece, and the wizard aprentice sequence is an icon.
-DUMBO 8.5
Beautiful movie, I cry every single time I see the scene when Dumbo visits his mom in that cell.
-BAMBI 8
haven't seen this movie in ages, the only thing I can remember is that I used to like it
-SALUDOS AMIGOS 6
-TREE CABALLEROS 7
-MAKE MINE MUSIC 7.5
-FUN AND FUNCY FREE 7
-MELODY TIME 7
-ICHABOD AND MR. TOAD 7.5
-CINDERELLA 10
this movie is absolutely wonderfull, the story, the animation, the music, all on this movie is great.
-ALICE IN WONDERLAND 9
visually beautiful, some missing parts from the book, but it is entertaining and fun.
-PETER PAN 9
another classic, when I think of disney, I always remember tinkerbell as an icon, and Hook is a great villian.
-LADY AND THE TRAMP 10
beautiful dog movie, romantic and suspencefull, a masterpiece with all its letters.
-SLEEPING BEAUTY 10
this movie s art!!!!! is a moving panting, the screenplay is not perfect, some plot holes, but still an awesome movie.
-101 DALMATIANS 10
this one has style, a fashion movie, the music, the backgrounds, the animation, simply beautiful
-JUNGLE BOOK 9
I found this movie quite entertaining, the mexican dubbing is outstanding and the songs make me sing for hours
-SWORD IN THE STONE 8
-ARISTOCATS 8
-ROBIN HOOD 9
-WINNIE THE POOH 9
-RESCUERS 8
good story and animation, Medusa is great, but I don't like the songs at all.
-FOX AND THE HOUND 9
yes, one of those movies that make me cry too, only four disney classics can do that
-BLACK CAULDRON 7
-GREAT MOUSE DETECTIVE 8
-OLIVER AND COMPANY 8
-LITTLE MERMAID 10
the best disney classic since dalmatians (IMO), this movie is flawless, fun and romantic
-RESCUERS DOWN UNDER 8
-BEAUTY AND THE BEAST 10
need I say more? this is the perfect animated movie
-ALADDIN 10
another flawless masterpiece
-LION KING 10
a phenomenon, a classic movie (not just animated), this is the most succesfull, requested, beloveb and hated tradicionally animated movie off all time
-POCAHONTAS 8
sorry, this is my least favorite 90's classic, just not as powerfull as its predecesors
-HUNCKBACK 9.5
if those gargoyles were'nt there this movie would be perfect, vusually stunning, musically awesome.
-HERCULES 9
another stylish movie, very fun to see
-MULAN 8.5)
-TARZAN 10
ohhh!!! that jungle is beautiful, wow... and phill's songs make this movie just great
-EMPEROR'S NEW GROOVE 9
Disney's funniest movie
-ATLANTIS 7
is this one really a disney movie??
-LILO AND STITCH 9
well, this is a real disney movie, the most original of them all
-TREASURE PLANET 7.5
a well deserved failure for the adapted story, not for the visuals. BEN is the worst character in all disney history
-BROTHER BEAR 9.5
eight years ago, this movie could have been really succesful, beautiful backgrounds and lovely characters
I'ts enough for this restless warrior just to be with you...
Since no one was being really honest about the ratings... well, here is my harsh yet realistic review of almost all things done Disney.
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9.5/10 -- the one that started it all, enjoyable to today
2. Pinocchio - 8.5/10 -- When you wish upon a star, nuff said
3. Fantasia - 6/10 -- innovative idea... just doesn't work
4. Dumbo - 8.5/10 -- Everyone has been Dumbo during their life
5. Bambi - 8/10 -- Can they do that in a cartoon????
6. Saludos Amigos - 3/10 -- WW2
7. The Three Caballeros - 4/10 --WW2
8. Make Mine Music - 4/10 -- WW2
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 5/10 --WW2
10. Melody Time - 4/10 --WW2
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 8/10 -- Halloween tradition
12. Cinderella - 9/10 -- 12 o'clock magic
13. Alice in Wonderland - 9/10 -- Acid Trip
14. Peter Pan - 9.5/10 -- So much better if you know the background to the story and writer
15. Lady and the Tamp - 6/10 -- Too many animals
16. Sleeping Beauty - 8/10 -- Masterpiece... ruined by the three good witches
17. 101 Dalmatians - 5/10 -- Too many animals
18. The Sword in the Stone - 4/10 -- Pretty boring
19. The Jungle Book - 5/10 -- Forgetable
20. The Aristocats - 2/10 -- Music was too noisy... headache
21. Robin Hood - 7/10 -- Childhood favorite
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8/10 -- Innocence
23. The Rescuers - 8/10 -- pure magic, awesome soundtrack
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6.5/10 -- Good lesson, poor execution
25. The Black Cauldron - 6/10 -- Awesome potential, seems to drag at certain areas
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 6/10 -- The rat and cat are too ugly
27. Oliver & Company - 3.5/10 -- Boring
28. The Little Mermaid - 9.5/10 -- Disney Magic
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 4/10 -- An insult to the original
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10 -- Disney magic
31. Aladdin - 10/10 -- Disney magic
32. The Lion King - 9/10 -- Disney magic
33. Pocahontas - 6/10 -- Nothing memorable
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 8.5/10 -- Powerful scenes
35. Hercules - 4/10 -- Weak
36. Mulan - 6/10 -- Weak
37. Tarzan - 6/10 -- Weak
38. Fantasia 2000 - 5/10 -- Same as Fantasia but a sequel
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 7/10 -- Weak but entertaining
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 5/10 -- Great animation, weak story
41. Lilo & Stitch - 7/10 -- Interesting but not Disney magic
42. Treasure Planet - 7/10 -- Interesting but not Disney magic
43. Brother Bear - 7/10 -- Too much rehash...
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 9.5/10 -- the one that started it all, enjoyable to today
2. Pinocchio - 8.5/10 -- When you wish upon a star, nuff said
3. Fantasia - 6/10 -- innovative idea... just doesn't work
4. Dumbo - 8.5/10 -- Everyone has been Dumbo during their life
5. Bambi - 8/10 -- Can they do that in a cartoon????
6. Saludos Amigos - 3/10 -- WW2
7. The Three Caballeros - 4/10 --WW2
8. Make Mine Music - 4/10 -- WW2
9. Fun and Fancy Free - 5/10 --WW2
10. Melody Time - 4/10 --WW2
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - 8/10 -- Halloween tradition
12. Cinderella - 9/10 -- 12 o'clock magic
13. Alice in Wonderland - 9/10 -- Acid Trip
14. Peter Pan - 9.5/10 -- So much better if you know the background to the story and writer
15. Lady and the Tamp - 6/10 -- Too many animals
16. Sleeping Beauty - 8/10 -- Masterpiece... ruined by the three good witches
17. 101 Dalmatians - 5/10 -- Too many animals
18. The Sword in the Stone - 4/10 -- Pretty boring
19. The Jungle Book - 5/10 -- Forgetable
20. The Aristocats - 2/10 -- Music was too noisy... headache
21. Robin Hood - 7/10 -- Childhood favorite
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - 8/10 -- Innocence
23. The Rescuers - 8/10 -- pure magic, awesome soundtrack
24. The Fox and the Hound - 6.5/10 -- Good lesson, poor execution
25. The Black Cauldron - 6/10 -- Awesome potential, seems to drag at certain areas
26. The Great Mouse Detective - 6/10 -- The rat and cat are too ugly
27. Oliver & Company - 3.5/10 -- Boring
28. The Little Mermaid - 9.5/10 -- Disney Magic
29. The Rescuers Down Under - 4/10 -- An insult to the original
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10 -- Disney magic
31. Aladdin - 10/10 -- Disney magic
32. The Lion King - 9/10 -- Disney magic
33. Pocahontas - 6/10 -- Nothing memorable
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 8.5/10 -- Powerful scenes
35. Hercules - 4/10 -- Weak
36. Mulan - 6/10 -- Weak
37. Tarzan - 6/10 -- Weak
38. Fantasia 2000 - 5/10 -- Same as Fantasia but a sequel
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 7/10 -- Weak but entertaining
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 5/10 -- Great animation, weak story
41. Lilo & Stitch - 7/10 -- Interesting but not Disney magic
42. Treasure Planet - 7/10 -- Interesting but not Disney magic
43. Brother Bear - 7/10 -- Too much rehash...
-
AwallaceUNC
- Signature Collection
- Posts: 9439
- Joined: Thu Dec 11, 2003 1:00 am
- Contact:
Agreed. Also, if no Disney movie has earned a full 10 out of 10, then that kind of skews things, imo... provides no measure of excellence in terms of Disney films. I think it's been reached a few times, but that's just my opinion.
Slash wrote:
-Aaron
Slash wrote:
Really? This surprises me. I'm not crazy over the plot, or the book-to-screen process for this one, but the songs and the fact that it's a best-seller gives it bigger props in my book. So you've peaked my interest, lol. Care to comment?19. The Jungle Book - 5/10 -- Forgetable
-Aaron
• Author of Hocus Pocus in Focus: The Thinking Fan's Guide to Disney's Halloween Classic
and The Thinking Fan's Guide to Walt Disney World: Magic Kingdom (Epcot coming soon)
• Host of Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Pod, the longest-running Disney podcast
• Entertainment Writer & Moderator at DVDizzy.com
• Twitter - @aaronspod
and The Thinking Fan's Guide to Walt Disney World: Magic Kingdom (Epcot coming soon)
• Host of Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Pod, the longest-running Disney podcast
• Entertainment Writer & Moderator at DVDizzy.com
• Twitter - @aaronspod
-
MisterMalificent
- Member
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 4:28 pm
- Location: california
1. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs - 8/10
2. Pinocchio - havent seen it
3. Fantasia - havent seen it
4. Dumbo - havent seen it
5. Bambi - havent seen it
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't Seen Yet
7. The Three Caballeros - havent seen it
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't Seen Yet
9. Fun and Fancy Free - havent seen it
10. Melody Time - Haven't Seen Yet
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - havent seen it
12. Cinderella - havent seen it
13. Alice in Wonderland - 8.5/10
14. Peter Pan - havent seen it
15. Lady and the Tamp - havent seen it
16. Sleeping Beauty - 10/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - havent seen it
18. The Sword in the Stone - havent seen it
19. The Jungle Book - 9/10
20. The Aristocats - havent seen it
21. Robin Hood - havent seen it
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - havetn seen it
23. The Rescuers - haventy seen it
24. The Fox and the Hound - 10/10
25. The Black Cauldron - Haven't Seen Yet
26. The Great Mouse Detective - havetn seen it
27. Oliver & Company - 9/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 8.5/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - havetn seen it
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 9/10
33. Pocahontas - 7.5/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 7.5/10
35. Hercules - 8/10
36. Mulan - 10/10
37. Tarzan - 7.5/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - havent seen it
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 9/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 7/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - havetn seen it
42. Treasure Planet - Haven't Seen Yet
43. Brother Bear - havent seen it
2. Pinocchio - havent seen it
3. Fantasia - havent seen it
4. Dumbo - havent seen it
5. Bambi - havent seen it
6. Saludos Amigos - Haven't Seen Yet
7. The Three Caballeros - havent seen it
8. Make Mine Music - Haven't Seen Yet
9. Fun and Fancy Free - havent seen it
10. Melody Time - Haven't Seen Yet
11. The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr. Toad - havent seen it
12. Cinderella - havent seen it
13. Alice in Wonderland - 8.5/10
14. Peter Pan - havent seen it
15. Lady and the Tamp - havent seen it
16. Sleeping Beauty - 10/10
17. 101 Dalmatians - havent seen it
18. The Sword in the Stone - havent seen it
19. The Jungle Book - 9/10
20. The Aristocats - havent seen it
21. Robin Hood - havent seen it
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh - havetn seen it
23. The Rescuers - haventy seen it
24. The Fox and the Hound - 10/10
25. The Black Cauldron - Haven't Seen Yet
26. The Great Mouse Detective - havetn seen it
27. Oliver & Company - 9/10
28. The Little Mermaid - 8.5/10
29. The Rescuers Down Under - havetn seen it
30. Beauty and the Beast - 10/10
31. Aladdin - 10/10
32. The Lion King - 9/10
33. Pocahontas - 7.5/10
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame - 7.5/10
35. Hercules - 8/10
36. Mulan - 10/10
37. Tarzan - 7.5/10
38. Fantasia 2000 - havent seen it
39. The Emperor's New Groove - 9/10
40. Atlantis: The Lost Empire - 7/10
41. Lilo & Stitch - havetn seen it
42. Treasure Planet - Haven't Seen Yet
43. Brother Bear - havent seen it
-
MisterMalificent
- Member
- Posts: 26
- Joined: Mon Feb 16, 2004 4:28 pm
- Location: california
Am I the only person here thinks Mulan is one of Disney's best, I mean the story is incredible, some parts even give me goosebumps , I love the music especially the piece when Mulan goes and steals her dads armor, i bought the soundtrack for it. LOL , I also think sleeping beauty is Disneys BEST love merryweather. I kinda didnt like Tarzan, I love Groove because it is hillarious , atlantis was ookay,