amazon980 wrote:Can anyone here do better?
Everyone here acts like this disneys best movie ever.
Actually, I know of at least one person here who can do so much better.
And no, it's not one of Disney's best, but it is part of one of the greatest Disney franchises, and since TLM and TLM:AB both got great covers, I'd at least think they would try a little harder to get this one to fit in nicely with the other two.
nomad2010 wrote:UmbrellaFish wrote:It looks more like a coloring book cover than a DVD cover...
exactly! no shading really. no definition to the characters. not to mention they are extremely off model.
Agreed on
UmbrellaFish's comment. However,
nomad2010, this still seems like a rough draft, just bigger- I'm pretty sure shading and stuff will be added later.
Now for my own
opinion- as a HUGE TLM fan, I don't think this cover does the film any justice. If anything, it reflects the terrible era of badly animated DTV sequels. I think the only thing they got right on this cover is how Ariel's shells have that extra thing in the center, like she did on the original cover. I'll even give them most of her face and tail, but her waist is way too thin, and like many people have stated- she looks way too young.
If they're approaching this cover chronologically, then if Melody is a preteen mermaid, Flounder should be putting on some weight. I know he goes off-model in the film, but that's only ONE SCENE, his character obviously changed, and they need to either acknowledge that, or not include him on the cover at all.
Morgana's face looks a little... weird, as well, and Triton looks way too chunky (although that's how he appears in the film so, I'll let this one slip). Sebastian, he actually looks like he's been cut out of the original cover and just rotated, and I'm actually betting that that's all they did. And "Meet Ariel's Daughter"? Are you kidding me? I would think they'd want to promote the new game or bonus features, preferably the deleted song.
You know, looking at it now, I actually do like the layout, it's just the minor things such as major off-model-ness and stuff...
Bottom line: I'd rather have a boring layout with everyone on-model than an amazing layout with everything being off-model. I still doubt this is the final.