Cheshire_Cat wrote:
Don't get me wrong, I really enjoyed the film, but I couldn't help but feel a little depressed. I honestly didn't want Andy to give the toys away. At least, if he had stored them in the attic, he could have seen them again periodically during his visits back home from college.
However, Andy's mom and Bonnie's mom seem to be friends, so I guess that Andy would be able to at least hear from Bonnie's mom how the toys were doing. I don't think it's likely that Andy will never hear from the toys again.
I feel like it's such a perfect ending because:
1. What you mentioned: the friendship between the Davis and Anderson family.
2. If they had been left in the attic, they would've most likely never been played with by Andy again, instead having to wait many more years in a closed, cramped space for playtime. Even with the hope they had after escaping Sunnyside, eventually they would get bored and just wait. Imagine how Jessie would feel- years under the bed abandoned by Emily, years in a storage box waiting for Woody, years in a toy box (but not fully) waiting for true playtime, years in an attic waiting for Andy's children.
3. The loss of Woody. If Woody went to college with Andy, he'd just be a display piece. Yes he'd have his owner, but he'd likely be "shelved" and just stuck there, acting as a childhood memory of home for Andy. Yeah that's a nice idea, but he'd be very, very lonely. His friends in the attic would likely miss him terribly too. As if both haven't already lost most of their friends to yard sales/garbage cans.
This is why the scene with Andy and his mom is so important. Andy says that his mother will always be with him, no matter where he goes (haha, just like the Hannah Montana song. Eh, sorry.

). Woody looks at the picture of him and all his friends (sorry if I'm being a little obvious) and realizes that he'll always remember Andy and he wants to stay with him, but staying with him isn't the right thing to do. Knowing how lonely his friends will be, he writes a note to get them (and him) donated to Bonnie, where he knows they'll be in safe hands. This is key in Woody's character development: he has learned to let go of his obsession with being Andy's favorite, his deep attachment to Andy, all of his memories with him. to start a new life with someone new. No one wants this to happen, but they know it's for the best. That's why most audience members (including myself) were bawling at the end, because it is really hard to let go of these characters you've known for 15 years. That's what makes the ending so perfect for me, what makes the third film the best one of them all, and what makes the Toy Story Trilogy one of the greatest series of them all.