The Top 20 Disney Animated Classics 2012 - RESULTS

singerguy04 · Post by **singerguy04** » Sun Jan 29, 2012 7:32 pm

Avaitor wrote:
Super Aurora wrote: Actually Lion King isn't no. 1. Pinocchio is

here's my list in image form.: http://img824.imageshack.us/img824/2406/tierd.jpg

goes left to right in favorite order.
Uh, where is Princess and the Frog in your tier?

It's under his "OKAY TEIR".

Avaitor · Post by **Avaitor** » Sun Jan 29, 2012 7:43 pm

singerguy04 wrote:
Avaitor wrote: Uh, where is Princess and the Frog in your tier?
It's under his "OKAY TEIR".

Ah, I see it now, haha.

Sorry, I must've missed it somehow.

Khonnor · Post by **Khonnor** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 2:32 am

Super Aurora wrote:FUCk! it was close I was in middle of typing mine's

Can you allow mine's in?

Ha!

Why do you have me make a choice? Let everyone else decide, haha...

Uhmm, there 90 minutes between me closing the voting and your post...it's not like you missed it by a minute or so...

So unless no one minds and not another 20 people want to still submit their votes, I'm okay with it....

Khonnor · Post by **Khonnor** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 3:59 am

All votes have been counted and I'll post the results (all 51!!) every couple of hours till February 1st.

I wanna thank everyone for this opportunity and for trusting me. If I made a mistake (which I'm sure I might have done) I sincerely apologise in advance....

Thank you to all the people who voted, here and through PM. To all the people who didn't get the chance, hopefully you'll get a second try next year as I hope this will now be an annual thing and we don't have to wait another 8 years or so.

So, without further ado... here are numbers 50 to 34
I'll post the title and behind it, between brackets, the number of points it received. If it was part of the previous Top 20, I'll also add its previous position. At the end I'll post a list of the DAC still available to make it in the Top 20. And this years results will be posted in the first post of this thread at the end.

50. Make Mine Music (0) / Home On The Range (0)
49. Saludos Amigos (2)
48. Melody Time (8)
47. Chicken Little (10)
46. Fun And Fancy Free (11)
45. Dinosaur (17)
44. Atlantis: The Lost Empire (38)
43. Bolt (47)
42. The Three Caballeros (48)
41. Brother Bear (54)

40. The Aristocats (59)
39. Winnie The Pooh (64)
38. Adventures Of Ichabod & Mr. Toad (66)
37. Oliver & Company (67)
36. The Rescuers Down Under (84)
35. Meet The Robinsons (86)
34. Fantasia 2000 (95)

Still in the running:

01. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 1937
02. Pinocchio 1940
03. Fantasia 1940
04. Dumbo 1941
05. Bambi 1942
12. Cinderella 1950
13. Alice in Wonderland 1951
14. Peter Pan 1953
15. Lady and the Tramp 1955
16. Sleeping Beauty 1959
17. 101 Dalmatians 1961
18. The Sword in the Stone 1963
19. The Jungle Book 1967
21. Robin Hood 1973
22. The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh 1977
23. The Rescuers 1977
24. The Fox and the Hound 1981
25. The Black Cauldron 1985
26. The Great Mouse Detective 1986
28. The Little Mermaid 1989
30. Beauty and the Beast 1991
31. Aladdin 1992
32. The Lion King 1994
33. Pocahontas 1995
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame 1996
35. Hercules 1997
36. Mulan 1998
37. Tarzan 1999
40. The Emperor's New Groove 2000
42. Lilo & Stitch 2002
43. Treasure Planet 2002
49. The Princess And The Frog 2009
50. Tangled 2010

Dr Frankenollie · Post by **Dr Frankenollie** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 11:06 am

I'm sad none of the package features got in the top thirty, but I expected that. For the remaining DACs, I think you should break the list up more Khonnor; perhaps you could include images or brief descriptions?

St.GeorgeMickeyMouseFlynn · Mon Jan 30, 2012 1:57 pm

I'm betting the so-called Fab Four will all finish in the Top 5. Sadly

Khonnor · Post by **Khonnor** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 4:07 pm

Dr Frankenollie wrote:I'm sad none of the package features got in the top thirty, but I expected that. For the remaining DACs, I think you should break the list up more Khonnor; perhaps you could include images or brief descriptions?

I'm breaking them up by points. These all received less than 100 points.

The next few will be between 100 and 200 points.....etc etc.

The top 20 will indeed be posted with images....just be patient now...

Khonnor · Post by **Khonnor** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 4:16 pm

The Results - Part II: Numbers 27-33

33. Robin Hood (100)
32. The Black Cauldron (106)
31. The Sword In The Stone (109)
30. The Fox And The Hound (135)
29. Treasure Planet (139)
28. The Rescuers (188)
27. The Many Adventures Of Winnie The Pooh (189)

So far, all of the titles that were in the Top 20 all those years ago, still haven't appeared between numbers 27-50.
I am surprised we "dislike" the 70s and early 80s so much, when some of those movies, at least to me, made my Disney childhood memories. Movies like The Rescuers and The Fox And The Hound.

Khonnor wrote:Still in the running:

01. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 1937
02. Pinocchio 1940
03. Fantasia 1940
04. Dumbo 1941
05. Bambi 1942
12. Cinderella 1950
13. Alice in Wonderland 1951
14. Peter Pan 1953
15. Lady and the Tramp 1955
16. Sleeping Beauty 1959
17. 101 Dalmatians 1961
19. The Jungle Book 1967
26. The Great Mouse Detective 1986
28. The Little Mermaid 1989
30. Beauty and the Beast 1991
31. Aladdin 1992
32. The Lion King 1994
33. Pocahontas 1995
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame 1996
35. Hercules 1997
36. Mulan 1998
37. Tarzan 1999
40. The Emperor's New Groove 2000
42. Lilo & Stitch 2002
49. The Princess And The Frog 2009
50. Tangled 2010

St.GeorgeMickeyMouseFlynn · Mon Jan 30, 2012 4:18 pm

The Rescuers at 28!

Awfully low.

PixarFan2006 · Post by **PixarFan2006** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 4:25 pm

Robin Hood at 33's awfully high!, But that's probably just me.

Disney's Divinity · Post by **Disney's Divinity** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 4:50 pm

St.GeorgeMickeyMouseFlynn wrote:I'm betting the so-called Fab Four will all finish in the Top 5. Sadly

I doubt it. Sleeping Beauty and The Hunchback of Notre Dame are extremely popular on this forum <strike>for some strange reason</strike>. Aladdin and The Little Mermaid are close to the top though.

I really wish Pinocchio would end high up the list.

Rose Dome · Post by **Rose Dome** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 5:45 pm

I'm sad about The Rescuers, but it didn't seem to be on a great number of lists

I hope that The Great Mouse Detective makes it into the top 20...

St.GeorgeMickeyMouseFlynn wrote:I'm betting the so-called Fab Four will all finish in the Top 5. Sadly

I think so, but you can't stop the unstoppable.

Welcome to the forums btw

Heartless · Post by **Heartless** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 6:34 pm

St.GeorgeMickeyMouseFlynn wrote:I'm betting the so-called Fab Four will all finish in the Top 5. Sadly

Nah.. Top 10 maybe, but I don't think the Top 5.

So far, everything is pretty much as expected.
Black Cauldron, I'm rooting for ya in the Top 20! (which is really all im interested in to be honest).

qindarka · Post by **qindarka** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 7:06 pm

The Black Cauldron is already out, at number 32.

Disney Duster · Post by **Disney Duster** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 8:07 pm

I'm glad Super Aurora's list made it in, but damn man why did you wait so long?

Goliath, I will re-watch it. It's coming to Blu soon, so I could rent it or borrow a friend's someday. I'll see how I feel about those scenes...

I wanted to ask for The Black Cauldron for Christmas, but I feel like holding out for the Blu-ray...

Bambi is not style over substance. Unlike Sleeping Beauty, all the moments really matter. I think that people like you and Dr. Frankenollie think movies need more action, dialogue, and sure, I'll even use the word plot, to be considered "substance", but all substance must be is stuff that moves you or is necessary for some reason. Only the twitterpatted crap bothers me, and it's not unecessary for these characters to mate, its an important stage of life and the film's about showing animal lives, its just the way that Flower and Thumper get betwitched by sexy vixen versions of themselves is downright disgusting as is the "Gay Little Spring Song" coming right after his mother just died.

Bambi does not overdo its beauty at all. It is perfect. It is btoh amazingly beautiful and simple, unlike Sleeping Beauty. Sleeping Beauty does probably overdo it. In fact, it reminds me of what they wanted to do with Bambi but changed because the characters got lost in the backgrounds. Sleeping Beauty needed to ease up a bit.

Rescuers animation didn't look low-key to me. It looked empty. From what I remember. It was like the art Disney was known for went down. I'm sorry. Maybe I'll feel differently when I watch it again. But I just looked at some screencaps and only some of the trippy colors, like in the beginning, are what I'd call good art, and only just the concept of it, not the actual, finished, sketchy, charcoaled product. The Sword in the Stone makes the sketchiness look okay. Not this film. Though I agree with Walt that none of the sketchiness looks very good. Ever.

zackisthewalrus · Post by **zackisthewalrus** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 8:25 pm

So sad to see the package features go out so early, but not unexpected. I can't wait to see how the rest of the list turns out...

singerguy04 · Post by **singerguy04** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 8:54 pm

I'm disappointed that Fantasia 2000 is ranked so low. I'm also sad to see that Treasure Planet is out as well. I was secretly hoping it would make the top 20 as well because I think it's such a vastly under-appreciated film.

Heartless · Post by **Heartless** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 9:22 pm

qindarka wrote:The Black Cauldron is already out, at number 32.

Ah damnit. Skipped over that second results post, it seems.

Super Aurora · Post by **Super Aurora** » Mon Jan 30, 2012 10:00 pm

Disney Duster wrote:I'm glad Super Aurora's list made it in, but damn man why did you wait so long?

I forgot my disney favorite order so I had to search through entire forum to fin that photoshop list I made to remember what it was. Too long ass time.

Khonnor · Post by **Khonnor** » Tue Jan 31, 2012 3:55 am

The Results - Part III: Numbers 23-26

26. The Great Mouse Detective (230)
25. The Emperor's New Groove (231)
24. The Jungle Book (259)
23. The Princess And The Frog (276)

I must admit I was surprised people ranked The Jungle Book and The Princess And The Frog very low and wasn't on a lot of people's lists. I always thought The Jungle Book was a big favorite among people that like Disney. I must admit it's not one of my top-favorites either, but did expect it to rank higher. It was Number 13 in the previous Top 20, so I'm guessing it's the one that made the biggest drop, from 13 to 24!
The Emperor's New Groove dropped from Number 20 to 25, not a big change, but enough to miss out on being in the Top 20 again.

I also thought, because Princess And The Frog was sort of the comeback to 2D animation, people would rank it higher. I must say I didn't enjoy it as much as I had hoped and actually fell asleep during it and have yet to watch it again, but somehow do feel Tangled became such a hit thanks to Princess being released the year prior. Don't know why though.

Khonnor wrote:Still in the running:

01. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 1937
02. Pinocchio 1940
03. Fantasia 1940
04. Dumbo 1941
05. Bambi 1942
12. Cinderella 1950
13. Alice in Wonderland 1951
14. Peter Pan 1953
15. Lady and the Tramp 1955
16. Sleeping Beauty 1959
17. 101 Dalmatians 1961
28. The Little Mermaid 1989
30. Beauty and the Beast 1991
31. Aladdin 1992
32. The Lion King 1994
33. Pocahontas 1995
34. The Hunchback of Notre Dame 1996
35. Hercules 1997
36. Mulan 1998
37. Tarzan 1999
42. Lilo & Stitch 2002
50. Tangled 2010

DVDizzy Forum

Latest Movie Reviews

🎬 DVDizzy Top Stories️️

The Top 20 Disney Animated Classics 2012 - RESULTS