Is Belle a little TOO perfect?
- Cheshire_Cat
- Gold Classic Collection
- Posts: 222
- Joined: Thu Nov 18, 2010 8:59 am
- Location: Texas
Is Belle a little TOO perfect?
Without a doubt, Belle is one of the most admired heroines in the DAC canon. Of course, this has much to do with the fact that she's a more two-dimensional character compared to earlier Disney heroines. Instead of sitting around and singing about how she hopes to find the "man of her dreams" one day, she sings about how she wishes for more excitement in her mundane life.
Still, I couldn't help but wonder whether or not she's just too perfect. Does she really have any personality flaws? You couldn't exactly make a case of her being reclusive, because the only reason for that is because nobody in the village is really on the same intellectual and emotional level as she is. I suppose one could make a slight case that she's too curious, based off the "West Wing" scene, but, then again, that was only one scene in the entire movie, and her curiosity in that matter was understandable.
What do you think? Perhaps I'm just overanalyzing things?
Still, I couldn't help but wonder whether or not she's just too perfect. Does she really have any personality flaws? You couldn't exactly make a case of her being reclusive, because the only reason for that is because nobody in the village is really on the same intellectual and emotional level as she is. I suppose one could make a slight case that she's too curious, based off the "West Wing" scene, but, then again, that was only one scene in the entire movie, and her curiosity in that matter was understandable.
What do you think? Perhaps I'm just overanalyzing things?
- Elladorine
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4372
- Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2006 1:02 pm
- Location: SouthernCaliforniaLiscious SunnyWingadocious
- Contact:
- Cheshire_Cat
- Gold Classic Collection
- Posts: 222
- Joined: Thu Nov 18, 2010 8:59 am
- Location: Texas
I'm loving these replies. You guys are so funny!
That's a physical imperfection. I'm talking about personality flaws.enigmawing wrote:Well, she does have that one strand of hair that keeps falling out of place . . .
We don't know that she never washes it, do we?Julian Carter wrote:She wears the same clothes for months. She never washes that damn blue frock of hers.
Well, all that food was probably prepared just for her, anyway, so that's forgiveable.MJW wrote:Bad table manners? I mean the way she stuck her finger in that "gray stuff, it's delicious!" and licked it without taking the piece she touched? Rude!
How was Belle to know that her leaving would put the Beast in immediate danger, though? Besides, she could have planned to return as soon as her father was healthy again.Tae wrote:She doesn't have the ability to think in difficult situations/lacks foresight? Saving her father by putting the beast in danger was a pretty dumb thing to do. Understandable, since she didn't have a lot of time to think about her actions, but a flaw nonetheless.
- Disney Duster
- Ultimate Collector's Edition
- Posts: 13381
- Joined: Fri Jun 17, 2005 6:02 am
- Gender: Male
- Location: America
Re: Is Belle a little TOO perfect?
Don't you mean three-dimensional? And no, the other princesses sang and wished to have something better than their mundane life, too. They just specified it by saying a prince was part of it - and so did Belle when she talked about how her favorite part of the book was a prince charming in disguise. What you said about Belle is not what makes her different or more three-dimensional or better.Cheshire_Cat wrote:Without a doubt, Belle is one of the most admired heroines in the DAC canon. Of course, this has much to do with the fact that she's a more two-dimensional character compared to earlier Disney heroines. Instead of sitting around and singing about how she hopes to find the "man of her dreams" one day, she sings about how she wishes for more excitement in her mundane life.
As for her flaws, what do you mean her being curious is understandable? She promised to take her father's place in the Beast's castle and she goes against his orders about a private room of his. It's a flaw. She did something she knew she wasn't supposed to do. You might as well say other flaws of others characters are understandable and thus not flaws. Are Ariel's rash decisions and risking her own freedom for a man she knows little about not flaws just because they are understandable with the emotions she goes through and that she's a teenager?
I agree she planned to return to the Beast though. She even promises to return, remember?
- singerguy04
- Collector's Edition
- Posts: 2591
- Joined: Wed Feb 09, 2005 4:40 pm
- Location: The Land of Lincoln
Sorry, I should have clarified; I meant her showing the townspeople the magic mirror.Cheshire_Cat wrote:How was Belle to know that her leaving would put the Beast in immediate danger, though? Besides, she could have planned to return as soon as her father was healthy again.Tae wrote:She doesn't have the ability to think in difficult situations/lacks foresight? Saving her father by putting the beast in danger was a pretty dumb thing to do. Understandable, since she didn't have a lot of time to think about her actions, but a flaw nonetheless.
- Super Aurora
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4835
- Joined: Wed Oct 04, 2006 7:59 am
She hates Gaston. That means she not perfect.
<i>Please limit signatures to 100 pixels high and 500 pixels wide</i>
http://i1338.photobucket.com/albums/o68 ... ecf3d2.gif
http://i1338.photobucket.com/albums/o68 ... ecf3d2.gif
- AliceinWonderland
- Gold Classic Collection
- Posts: 239
- Joined: Thu Apr 10, 2008 11:02 am
I know i've heard (at a d23 panel) that most of the princess stories are told with in a day or few days. so she wouldnt be in the dress for monthsJulian Carter wrote:She wears the same clothes for months. She never washes that damn blue frock of hers.
If you think about it.. she goes through town, her dad goes off to the fair (day 1) she goes to find her dad, her dad runs back to town and tells the towns people about the beast (day 2) the snow fight and ball scene, she released and back again for the final battle (day 3)
- Cheshire_Cat
- Gold Classic Collection
- Posts: 222
- Joined: Thu Nov 18, 2010 8:59 am
- Location: Texas
Re: Is Belle a little TOO perfect?
Yes, I meant three-dimensional. I get the terminology confused sometimes.Disney Duster wrote:Don't you mean three-dimensional?Cheshire_Cat wrote:Without a doubt, Belle is one of the most admired heroines in the DAC canon. Of course, this has much to do with the fact that she's a more two-dimensional character compared to earlier Disney heroines. Instead of sitting around and singing about how she hopes to find the "man of her dreams" one day, she sings about how she wishes for more excitement in her mundane life.
The "Prince Charming" bit being Belle's favorite part doesn't neceessarily indicate that that's what she wants for herself. It could just indicate that she enjoys romanticism. But that's a different topic to delve into.Disney Duster wrote:And no, the other princesses sang and wished to have something better than their mundane life, too. They just specified it by saying a prince was part of it - and so did Belle when she talked about how her favorite part of the book was a prince charming in disguise. What you said about Belle is not what makes her different or more three-dimensional or better.
She got no information on the room other than that it was "FORBIDDEN!" and she was staying in an enchanted castle. Her feeling impelled to explore is perfectly understandable, since, under those same circumstances, I'm sure we'd all feel the same impulse.Disney Duster wrote:As for her flaws, what do you mean her being curious is understandable? She promised to take her father's place in the Beast's castle and she goes against his orders about a private room of his. It's a flaw. She did something she knew she wasn't supposed to do.
I don't think she explicitly promised to return in the movie. In the original fairy tale, yes, but not in the movie.Disney Duster wrote:I agree she planned to return to the Beast though. She even promises to return, remember?
-
- Limited Issue
- Posts: 83
- Joined: Mon Feb 13, 2012 9:08 pm
Yes, she comes off as too perfect because she's not a terribly well written character. I mean she's not bad, just her characterization is shallow. After the criticism they got for Ariel (who is a fantastic character) Disney tried to make their next to female leads more feminist. Nice idea, but they didn't know what they were doing and did what most hollywood writers do when they write "strong female character", give her perfecty girl powery traits and let that be her characterization.
Belle READS, she's not swayed by the town hunk, she gives up her life for her father's, she doesn't take being treated badly, she see beauty within, she does the right thing.
Those are not bad things, but I don't see much else to her. I guess a bad thing about her would be her going into the west wing when the monster says NEVER GO TO THE WEST WING, but other than that...
I do like her BTW.
Belle READS, she's not swayed by the town hunk, she gives up her life for her father's, she doesn't take being treated badly, she see beauty within, she does the right thing.
Those are not bad things, but I don't see much else to her. I guess a bad thing about her would be her going into the west wing when the monster says NEVER GO TO THE WEST WING, but other than that...
I do like her BTW.
As far as the time progression... it's not just three days. But I don't think it's months either... the library scene and the "something there" Sequence are there to imply passage of time: them getting to know each other and getting closer. And she DOES change her dress several times. I assume the blue dress was washed while she wore the others.
Flaws... hmmm... she is a bit impulsive and wreckless. And as far as going into the West Wing... she didnt wait even a day to disobey the beast! It was HER idea to stay in the castle!!
Flaws... hmmm... she is a bit impulsive and wreckless. And as far as going into the West Wing... she didnt wait even a day to disobey the beast! It was HER idea to stay in the castle!!
- Elladorine
- Diamond Edition
- Posts: 4372
- Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2006 1:02 pm
- Location: SouthernCaliforniaLiscious SunnyWingadocious
- Contact:
-
- Limited Issue
- Posts: 83
- Joined: Mon Feb 13, 2012 9:08 pm
The only other bit of impulsiveness or wrecklessness I can think of is when she shows the magic mirror to the town. BUT can it still be counted as wreckless, if it was the good moral thing to do? She was trying to save her father from going to an asylum.Marce82 wrote:As far as the time progression... it's not just three days. But I don't think it's months either... the library scene and the "something there" Sequence are there to imply passage of time: them getting to know each other and getting closer. And she DOES change her dress several times. I assume the blue dress was washed while she wore the others.
Flaws... hmmm... she is a bit impulsive and wreckless. And as far as going into the West Wing... she didnt wait even a day to disobey the beast! It was HER idea to stay in the castle!!
I don't think the story takes place over months either, like, do we really think poor Maurice survived in the woods for months?