(I was trying to write a summary, but that was turning out to be super long, too, haha.)
So, an update to my long previous posts:
I put the majority of my live-action titles for sale on eBay (they're still listed in the Trade forum if anyone is still interested)- some of them, yes, occasionally I will watch, but for the most part, they're just sitting on my shelf. I'd like to catch up on the animated CD soundtracks, so I figured that I'll use some money I make on the DVDs (if they sell) and buy some CDs, which will get a lot of use).
I'm still torn on the sequels. I have
Belle's Magical World up for sale. I can't part with
Lady and the Tramp II, I don't think, since I do quite like it, and I don't think that I could part with
Return to Never Land, either, since I do like that, too. I still have to watch
Tinker Bell and
Ariel's Beginning; I do quite enjoy TLM II, but maybe after watching TLM III, I'll have a better idea of whether or not to keep both. As far as the Stitch sequels, I'm thinking of selling them; I'll watch the TV show, but I don't care enough to watch the sequels, apparently. I don't care much for TJB2, but that was theatrical, just like
Return to Never Land, so part of me almost feels like I need it, but I just had an epiphany:
Doug's 1st Movie was also theatrical, and I've never seen that and am okay with that. With TLM II, also, I love the music in it, and that's almost reason enough to keep it (I eventually want to get soundtracks of the Disney movies I have, and I know that TLM II has a soundtrack CD, and I need the DVD if I have the CD!). As much as I love
Brother Bear and Mandy Moore, I've only watched
Brother Bear 2 once...I liked it, but I mean, I don't know if I need it. One might say, if you're not sure, just hold on to it, which I might do for the ones I'm unsure of. With the upcoming rerelease of
Dumbo, I don't know if I'll need the 60th Anniversary DVD anymore, if the new one is superior in every way, but the darn
Dumbo II preview is what's making me keep it, but I probably don't need that, especially with my current mindset, so should I sell
Dumbo and rebuy it when it comes out? And what about
Hercules- we know that a better edition will come out soon, so should I just sell it and rebuy the better edition when it comes out? As far as the Treasures go, I have my Annette Treasure up for sale, but I don't know about the others. I won't sell the Behind the Scenes one, but the 2 Mickey in B&Ws I could sell- I have them for the history aspect, but I don't watch them often; same for Oswald. I have Disney Rarities and haven't watched most of the shorts on it. I have the Wartime one, and I have the Classic Cartoon Favorites and Funny Factory...I need to decide if I want to keep shorts. I'd most likely keep the holiday short collections. Bobby did buy a bunch of the CCFs, though, so he wouldn't let me sell them, I'm sure. And, here my mind goes again, if I do sell the classic short DVDs (whether Treasures or not), will my kids grow up not knowing about Mickey and the other classic characters in terms of how they became famous (I mean, they'll grow up with
Once Upon a Christmas, and the other features they're in, but still...ugh, my mind.
As for the original question this thread asks, I have all the animated classics and will always continue buying those- I enjoy each and every one of the animated classics (some more than others, of course). I have all the Pixar films, and am planning on continuing to buy their animated films- not so sure about the live-action films. I'm keeping my favorite live action titles, and also the musicals; the live action titles I'm keeping are:
So Dear to My Heart
The Absent-Minded Professor
The Parent Trap
Babes In Toyland (I didn't like the first half of the film, but I did like the second half, and it's a musical, so I'm keeping it. Maybe I'll learn to like the first half!)
Summer Magic
Mary Poppins
The One and Only, Genuine, Original Family Band
Bedknobs and Broomsticks
Pete's Dragon
The Muppet Movie (not Disney, per se, but they released the DVD)
The Great Muppet Caper (ditto)
Return to Oz
Who Framed Roger Rabbit
Honey, I Shrunk the Kids
Newsies
The Mighty Ducks
A Muppet Christmas Carol
D2: The Mighty Ducks
The Santa Clause
Frank & Ollie
Muppet Treasure Island
D3: The Mighty Ducks
The Parent Trap
Remember the Titans
The Princess Diaries (although it's fullscreen & I should upgrade)
Walt: The Man Behind the Myth
Freaky Friday
Ice Princess
HSM
Jump In!
HSM2
Enchanted
Camp Rock
HSM3
Secret of the Magic Gourd (I thought that it was cute, but I don't think I'd watch this often, so might sell this. But, again, it has Corbin doing the voice. I'm torn on this one.)
Jonas Brothers: The Concert Experience
Hannah Montana: The Movie
Alex and EW did give me advice earlier, and if you've made it through this whole post (lol), then I can say that I still need advice.
Okay, so going through UD's non-DAC or Pixar animated lists...
To keep or not to keep, that is the question, and I need advice!
A Christmas Carol- Obviously not out yet. I'm excited to see it in the theater. It is a Christmas movie, so if I love it, I'll buy it.
The Wild- I enjoyed it the one time that I watched it. Might be worth keeping.
Valiant- Saw it for free at the theater. It wasn't the best movie ever, but it was alright. Might not keep, though.
Pooh's Heffalump Movie- Will keep.
Teacher's Pet- Will keep.
Piglet's Big Movie- Will keep.
The Jungle Book 2- Leaning more towards no.
Return to Never Land- 99% sure I'm keeping.
Recess: School's Out- Never watched it. Already up for sale.
The Tigger Movie- Will keep.
Doug's 1st Movie- Never seen it, don't have it.
James and the Giant Peach- Will keep, definitely!
A Goofy Movie- Will keep, definitely.
The Nightmare Before Christmas- ditto
DuckTales: The Movie- Will keep. I haven't watched it since I was a kid, but I bought the DVD. So I guess I'm borderline? Ugh.
Other:
The Brave Little Toaster- Will keep.
101 Dalmatians Christmas- Bought, never watched. Will probably donate to the thrift store. Yes, it's Christmas, but it's based off the TV show. Which I liked, but I don't care enough about it to watch, apparently, since I've owned the VHS tape for years.
American Legends- I'm borderline about keeping this or selling it.
DTV:
Tinker Bell and the whatever her new movie is called- Haven't watched the first one, so once I watch that, maybe I'll decide.
Princess Enchanted Tales- Watched once, already up for sale.
Ariel's Beginning- Haven't watched yet; need to watch before I decide.
The Return of Jafar- I love the 3rd movie in the series, and of course the first, but have never cared too much for this one, although I love "Forget About Love". Very torn about this. Is it wrong to own #1 and #3 but not #2? And my love for Jasmine is there, too (not including the
Princess Enchanted Tales, I guess).
Aladdin and the King of Thieves- Definite keeper.
Pooh's Grand Adventure- The only time I watched this, I fell asleep, so I don't think I ever finished it. I've heard good things about it. Is it good enough that I should give it a second chance?
Beauty and the Beast: The Enchanted Christmas- Since it's Christmas and has some nice songs, I'll more than likely keep it. Even if Forte bothers me in all his CG <strike>unglory</strike> glory.
Beauty and the Beast: Belle's Magical World- The one time I watched it, it made me sleepy, so I only watched 2 cartoons, maybe, and it made no lasting impression on me- I don't remember it. Already is up for sale. I don't feel bad about not having the 3rd in this series for some reason.
Pocahontas II- Another that I'm torn about. I like some of the music in it, and I like how Pocahontas goes to England. I like John Rolfe. I love John Smith in the first one, though, and he's different in this one, which bothers me to no end. Decisions, decisions.
The Lion King II- I'm kind of indifferent about this. I mean, I like it, but I hardly ever watch it. It's not one of my favorite sequels, but not one of my least favorites- I guess it's in the middle.
Mickey's Once Upon a Christmas- Will keep.
Winnie the Pooh: Seasons of Giving- Never saw, don't own. Was thinking of buying it, but I won't now with my new mindset.
An Extremely Goofy Movie- I saw it once. It was pretty good, actually, but how often will I watch it? I'm torn on this one, too.
Buzz Lightyear of Star Command- Never watched, is up for sale.
The Little Mermaid II- I love the music in this movie very much. I do like the movie, but if the music were different, maybe I'd be more willing to part with it. Honestly, I just randomly sing songs...well, I do that anyway, but I mean from this movie, all the time. Just yesterday I was singing "Tip and Dash" in the bathroom.
Lady and the Tramp II- I can't see myself parting with this one. It's special to me for some reason. Probably because I bawl my eyes out while watching it.

I do love it. I used to say that TLM II & this were tied for my favorite sequel, but I've been thinking about it, and I think this wins top place.
Mickey's Magical Christmas: Snowed In at the House of Mouse- I have it on VHS, never watched it...since it's Christmas, maybe I should watch it and if I love it, I can buy it on VHS.
Cinderella II- While I do enjoy the Baker story, I never watch this. Would it be wrong to have the original film and C III and not this one? What will my nonexistant-but potential children say about that? (Honestly, that thought is in my head about the whole situation...)
The Hunchback of Notre Dame II- I love the Jennifer Love Hewitt song. I do. But I never watched the whole film. The animation is quite poor, compared to the original film, which is breathtaking. Would sell if I do indeed sell my sequels, since I've never cared to watch the whole thing. Although I've always liked the idea of Quasi getting a girlfriend.
Tarzan and Jane- Watched it once. Love the Mandy Moore song at the end, but the movie is just blah, I think. All I remember is that there's a party at the end. Maybe I fell asleep the one time I watched this...? Probably would sell, but I do love Mandy Moore...(even though I have up for sale a few of her live-action titles that I never watch).
Mickey's House of Villains- I don't think that I've ever watched this, unless I saw it on TV or something once, but don't remember it. Is already up for sale.
Winnie the Pooh: A Very Merry Pooh Year- Never saw, haven't bought.
101 Dalmatians II- Never cared to watch it. I watched one scene one time, of some song, but I haven't given it a chance. Is it worth watching?
Atlantis: Milo's Return- Another one I'm borderline on. I like it enough, but it's not nearly as good as the original film. I can't even remember anything that happens in it.
Stitch! The Movie- Watched it once. Don't really remember much, except for sandwiches? Would sell if I sold my sequels.
The Lion King 1 1/2- I actually do enjoy this. So I'd probably have to keep TLK 2 if I kept this. Uncle Max, Ma, and "Digga Tunnah" would be the reasons I would keep this.
Winnie the Pooh: Springtime with Roo- I watched this when I bought it, and not since. I don't remember a thing about it. Would probably sell it?
The Three Musketeers- This was really well done. I don't think that I would sell this, even though I hardly watch it.
Mickey's Twice Upon a Christmas- Will keep.
Mulan II- I watched this once or twice. I liked it enough, but it's not as good as the original. I'm sort of torn, but leaning more towards sell, since it's not one of my favorites.
Tarzan II- Watched one or two scenes before, but never watched the whole thing. Is it worth watching?
Lilo and Stitch 2: Stitch Has a Glitch- Haven't watched it. Based on what EW said, it isn't worth watching? Would sell if I sold the sequels.
Pooh's Heffalump Halloween Movie- I watched this once, don't remember much about it. Isn't half of it just a TV episode? Would sell, probably.
Kronk's New Groove- Watched once. Was cute- I do enjoy squirrels. I don't remember much about it. It isn't as funny as the original film, right? Would you keep this?
Bambi II- I watched it once. I think I enjoyed it, but it's not memorable to me...everyone apparently loves it, but I'll still ask: Is it worth giving a second chance?
Brother Bear 2- I love
Brother Bear, and I love Mandy Moore. I watched this once. I think I liked it, but again, it wasn't too memorable, although it was more memorable to me than
Bambi II was. I wonder if Bobby would be sad if I sold this; he loves
Brother Bear, but I don't know if he cares about the sequel. He hates when I sell anything, though.
The Fox and the Hound 2- Watched 2 or 3 scenes in it, ones with songs in them. Obviously not nearly as good as the original. I love the Lucas Grabeel song, and I do love Tod & Copper, but it is worth giving a chance to?
Cinderella III- How can I not keep this?
So, there's my super-de-dooper long post. 100 pink elephants to anyone who gives advice, because I need it. I could use the money on other things, but at the same time, this is Disney animation, with characters I love. Some of them, like the Stitch sequels, I've kind of made my mind on, in terms of if I sell any of my sequels, I'll sell those. I do enjoy the original film, don't get me wrong, but I just don't care enough about the sequels, I guess.