DVDizzy Forum

Christopher_TCUIH wrote:So I wondering if anyone has screen captures of this edition or a link to a website that has them? I saw the pictures on UD's review and I have to say the colors on Alice look really "Ronald McDonald"! I wanted to compare to see if it's a true upgrade and if its worth buying. Thanks in advance
-Christopher

Here are a few:

Blu-Ray.com's AIW screenshots (*They've also posted a review.)

DVDBeaver's AIW review (*Includes comparisons to other versions.)

Hope this helps!

@jinkinquackers: Thank you so much! I appreciate it a lot! It really did help

You're very welcome, Christopher_TCUIH!

@Farerb
I just saw your post here and wow those screenshots make a world of a difference!
https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.ph ... 24&page=53

That is the Alice in Wonderland I recognize, and not that oversaturated mess on the Blu-Ray. I really hope they re-release this (on 4K?) with the new transfer being used on Google Play because I want to own this. Let's hope they do something similar with Cinderella because that is another film long overdue. I never expected they'd fix Alice so here's hoping.

I think the Alice in Google Play is the DVD master only in 1080p. Google Play also has the previous HD version of The Sword in the Stone, the one which is 1.33.

farerb wrote:I think the Alice in Google Play is the DVD master only in 1080p. Google Play also has the previous HD version of The Sword in the Stone, the one which is 1.33.

Yes, it does resemble the DVD although I'm not sure if it's 100% the same (just in HD) just from looking at it. That would be a pity if they never release this copy in any format beyond this.

That's the Blu-Ray transfer if I'm correct. Looks awful especially compared to those screenshots you posted. Alice in that bright blue dress and sunshine yellow hair especially sticks out.

Yes it is. I just thought it was nice seeing Kathryn Beaumont doing the live action reference.

Doing more screenshots comparing:

DVD/YouTube:


Blu-ray:


As much as I had problems with the Blu-ray, I think the DVD/YouTube actually look worse.

^ When you say YouTube, did someone just upload the DVD (which one?) to YouTube, or do you mean when you purchase the movie through YouTube?

I redeemed the film through digital code. The version Google Play/YouTube has is an upscaled version of the DVD (the one that comes with the Blu-ray, not the Gold Collection), the one Movies Anywhere has is the Blu-ray version.

Thank you- I had no idea that different versions played depending on which site you watch the digital copy on. Is it just me, or does the DVD/YouTube pic you posted above look clearer than the Blu-ray?

That might be because of the source cause that one I really did take from a YouTube video cause I can't take screenshots from Movies Anywhere. Also I have to reduce the pictures size in order to upload here.

I was on the laptop when I posted before; on my phone, they both look decent, but Alice in particular is a bit darker in the dvd one.