DVDizzy Forum

what do you people think if the BEST disney DVD that has comprehensive and a lot of extras, easy to navigate, good sound and restoration, and just is a really great DVD with lots of bonus features.

I think its Aladdin PE. Great movie, great image and sound quality, GREAT extras, and a classic film! I really don't like the Lion king one since its hard to navigate and the extras are kind of sketchy.

I don't judge a movie's worth by how easily I can navigate the menus..

Lightyear wrote:I don't judge a movie's worth by how easily I can navigate the menus..

I'm talking about the DVD, not the actual movie itself

I loved Aladdin, too, but I really like the Sleeping Beauty one also; it's one of the two.

I think most people would agree with Aladdin.

Animation
Best Platinum Edition: Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Best Special/Anniversary/Whatever Edition: Pocahontas
Best Single-Disc: Treasure Planet

Live Action
Best 2-Disc (Catalogue): Mary Poppins
Best 2-Disc (New Release): Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl
Best Single-Disc: Bedknobs and Broomsticks (this would've easily gone to The Princess Diaries, but now that that's become a 2-Disc, it seems pointless to give it to the older edition)

Just watched ALADDIN again yesterday, and I'm inclined to agree.

My personal favorite would be a tie between: Snow White and Beauty and the Beast for overall best DVD presentation. Aladdin is a VERY close second.

oh ok, just on special features alone.. Let's see.. I thought Bambi was pretty easy to navigate, good content..

Was disapointed with the incredibles..

Wish more DVD's showed the actors doing the voice overs.

Best Disney DVD overall: Snow White Platinum edition
Best Disney Platinum: Snow White
Best Special Edition: Not sure
Best Pixar DVD: Monster's Inc.
Best Set Top Game: Timon and Pumbaa Virtual Safari
Best Documentary: A Diamond in The Rough(Making of Aladdin)
Best Single Disc DVD: Treasure Planet

There's so many to choose from. I guess mine would go something like this:
Best Platinum: Snow White
Best Special/Collector's Edition: Tarzan, Emperor's New Groove, Atlantis
Best Single Disc: Treasure Planet
Best PIXAR: This is hard. Ultimate Toy Box or Monsters Inc.
Diamond in the Rough is the best documentary.
As for best game: Uh, no comment.

My favorite DVD is snow white and the seven dwarfs.

I find it amusing how some people won't say it just because the movie is only so-so. Atlantis is one of the finest DVDs out there. Start off with a great package (in the UK it gets a special bottle-like slipcover), a visual commentary, DTS sound, a 2 hour making-of with no fluff what-so-ever, deleted scenes, CGI demonstrations, tons of galleries and publicity material and hardly anything childish included! Sure, the movie may not be loved, but give the great packaging a bit of credit!

The Fantasia Legacy is still the best Disney dvd.

Bambi!


I doubt this thread get somewhere, and don´t get me wrong, but I think that for everyone of us our favorite Disney DVD would probably be for us the best DVD

The absolute best Disney DVD is

Either The Incredibles or Monsters Inc.

Great Retrospective Pieces:
Aladdin
Mary Poppins
Bambi
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs

Great "Looking Deep in the archives" Pieces:
Alice in Wonderland
Sleeping Beauty
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Walt Disney Treasures series

Great Recent Productions Pieces:
Monsters Inc
The Incredibles
Pocahontas (all the material was produced originally for a laserdisc release around the time of initial release)

Good 1 Disc Sets:
Dumbo
Bedknobs and Broomsticks
Peter Pan

I'd say the best DVD release is either the Platinum editons of Bambi or Aladdin.

The Pocahontas 10th anniversary edition was really great also!!!

DDMAN26 wrote:The Fantasia Legacy is still the best Disney dvd.

I totally have to agre with you there. It really has some amazing stuff on it. My favorite feature was about the scrap book.

My personal favorite is the BEAUTY AND THE BEAST DVD.