DVDizzy Forum

Well everyone, here's round 9 - THE FINAL ROUND!! (again sorry about the delay!) Disney's 41st through 40th Animated classics!! These are,

-Lilo & Stitch
-Treasure Planet
-Brother Bear
-Home on the Range


So, What's your favorite of these?

For me it was close between Lilo and Stich and Brother Bear, but in the end I chose Brother Bear because I liked the story better. Plus all the Alien-space stuff in Lilo and Stich was annoying to me (I never liked any space shows or movies like Star Wars, Star Trek, etc.). But anyway, yea. Brother Bear was my pick

I voted for Brother Bear, when I first saw it I was overwelmed with the Disney magic it has that was not in movies like "Lilo & Stitch" and "Treasure Planet" (I do like those 2 though!). I haven't seen Home on the Range yet (Wednesday or Thursday I'm going to see it) so I don't really have an opinion about that movie. Brother Bear holds a special place in my heart. To me it was one of the best Animated Disney movie of all time. So, Brother Bear it is!

I agree with Jens I didn't like Lilo, Treasure, or Home very much.

1. Treasure Planet (by leaps and bounds- I LOVE this movie)
2. Lilo & Stitch
3. Brother Bear
4. Home On The Range

Lilo & Brother are a toss-up for me.

Kelly, this has been lots of fun and a wonderful idea. Thanks.

-Aaron

Home on the Range

WITH OUT A DOUBT LILO AND STITCH THE BEST MOVIE EVER the little blue alien is so cute! Anwyas here is my order

Lilo and Stitch
Brother Bear
Home on The Range
Treasuer Planet

Top 4:

01. Brother Bear
02. Lilo & Stitch
03. Treasure Planet
04. Home on the Range

awallaceunc wrote:1. Treasure Planet (by leaps and bounds- I LOVE this movie)

I couldn't have said it better myself!

1. Lilo and Stitch (by far)
2. Brother Bear
3. Treasure Planet
4. Home on the Range (haven't seen it)

Lilo and stitch!

I'm going to have to say Lilo and Stitch too!
Not only does it take place in my home state, but I LOVE Stitch, he's adorable.

Brother Bear since it had some good storytelling and featured excellent music by Phil Collins, one of the greatest music artists in the world.

I love 'em all dearly, but I've gotta show more love for the groovy little blue dude with spunk (and Elvis!) Lilo & all the way, by far. After two disappointments in The Emporer's New Groove and the had-great-potential-but-was-wasted Atlantis, it was incredibly refreshing to see Lilo & Stitch - a film that dared to go against the Disney formula while remaining faithful to the spirit of the studio and, in a way, being a wonderful return to form. The title characters and their relationship is what really drives the movie and gives it its emotional force. You find yourself caring for and understanding them, their moodiness and imperfections. It’s a testament to the film’s emotion that I simply cannot watch it, <b><i><u>ever</b></i></u>, without crying at least once. The first time I saw it I was sobbing like a baby in the back of the theater through the entire last third of the film. Lilo & Stitch is a wonderful film that reaffirms that Disney can still capture the magic when they want to, and that's why it's the best thing they've done since The Lion King.

Jake Lipson wrote:it's the best thing they've done since The Lion King.

Funny, that's exactly the phrase I've used twice in describing Treasure Planet to people this week.

-Aaron

awallaceunc wrote:Funny, that's exactly the phrase I've used twice in describing Treasure Planet to people this week.

Oh, Treasure Planet is a GREAT movie. As I think you can tell from my <a href=http://www.ultimatedisney.com/hercules.html target=blank>Hercules DVD review for the site</a>, I love Ron Clements and John Musker and have immense respect for them. All of their movies for Disney -- Treasure Planet included -- rank with my favorites, and I'm quite the TP supporter too. It's a REAL shame it didn't do well. The quality was definately there in spades -- I blame its failure on a bad release slot (I don't care if it was Thanksgiving, there's NO excuse for Disney putting it out when Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, their own The Santa Clause 2, and at least a dozen other movies were vying for the same family/kids/teens market) and terrible marketing. I thought the trailers were cool, but they played up the wrong aspects of what made the movie great. Anyway, I'm not going to bother to type out a rant on this topic because I know it'll keep me up till 3 am or so and will wear out my fingers from all the typing, but suffice to say I am VERY disappointed with the marketing of TP.

But I just find L&S better. That's not knocking any of these, because I *LOVE* all four of them very dearly, but...L&S just totally dominates.

1. Treasure Planet
2. Brother Bear
3. Home on the Range
4. Lilo & Stitch

I voted Brother Bear...I have'nt seen home on the range yet hehe but i like the other two movies to

"Lilo & Stitch" is the better movie, but I've gotta go with "Brother Bear". This movie really surprised me.

1-Brother Bear
2-Lilo & Stitch
3-Home on the Range (wonderful animation and art direction)
4-Treasure Planet

Lilo and Stitch by a bit over Brother Bear for me.

Have not seen Home on the Range yet but given all its production problems and reviews I doubt it would contend.