DVDizzy Forum

Posted: **Mon May 24, 2004 9:03 pm**

Who should win American Idol Season 3?
I really like Diana DeGarmo and Fantasia Barrino but I can't decide who to vote tommorrow night.
I will see it tommorrow at 8 p.m. on FOX.
I thought that Matt Rogers and Geroge Huff left the competition to early both were very good singers.
I really want Diana DeGarmo to win she has talent!!!

So could you vote on your favorite American Idol.
Go! Go! Diana DeGarmo!!!

Posted: **Mon May 24, 2004 9:12 pm**

Ugh Fantasia no contest. DeGarmo's the next Justin Guairini, no question. It should be LaToya vs. Fantasia.

Posted: **Mon May 24, 2004 9:20 pm**

Damn - where's the "I Don't Care" option?

Posted: **Mon May 24, 2004 9:31 pm**

I don't watch A.I but from what i've seen. I like Fantasia better. I have named DeGarmo the next "Free Willy"

I don't know what goes thru her mind when she picks out her clothes. she's not barbie.

Posted: **Mon May 24, 2004 11:51 pm**

Well, honestly, Fantasia *should* win. She is by far more original, and really just owns the stage, she was even told (by I forgot who) that if this weren't a competition, he'd give her a record deal straight away.
However...Fantastia is not really my style, I'd much rather see Dianna win. And I read somewhere that Simon believes that Dianna will win...but I guess that only time will tell.
No matter who wins this season, though, Clay is still my favorite American Idol.

Posted: **Tue May 25, 2004 6:25 am**

Secret Disney Man wrote:Ugh Fantasia no contest. DeGarmo's the next Justin Guairini, no question. It should be LaToya vs. Fantasia.

and if Fantasia loses, she'll be the next Clay Aiken

I havent kept up with the show much but I've heard her sing and I was pretty blown away

Posted: **Tue May 25, 2004 12:16 pm**

toonaspie wrote:
Secret Disney Man wrote:Ugh Fantasia no contest. DeGarmo's the next Justin Guairini, no question. It should be LaToya vs. Fantasia.
and if Fantasia loses, she'll be the next Clay Aiken

I havent kept up with the show much but I've heard her sing and I was pretty blown away

Bingo!

Diana was really good at first but got worse as the show progressed.

Posted: **Tue May 25, 2004 2:03 pm**

Well, I personally prefer Diana since she's from like the same county as I am. I really don't care for Fantasia - Sure she has some good songs, but she's just waaaaaaay bad in my books. The way she does some of her vocals. Whatever, I hope for Diana to win, even though I prefered Camille and LaToya.

Posted: **Tue May 25, 2004 4:50 pm**

jabroni76 wrote:Well, I personally prefer Diana since she's from like the same county as I am. I really don't care for Fantasia - Sure she has some good songs, but she's just waaaaaaay bad in my books. The way she does some of her vocals. Whatever, I hope for Diana to win, even though I prefered Camille and LaToya.

Ugh Camille couldn't sing for beans. But LaToya deserved to win the whole Kit'N Caboodle.

Posted: **Tue May 25, 2004 6:33 pm**

MickeyMouseboy wrote:I have named DeGarmo the next "Free Willy" I don't know what goes thru her mind when she picks out her clothes. she's not barbie.

Oh ha ha ha. She's quite the beefcake

I'm sure your girlfriend is the spitting image of Barbie, huh?
Honestly.

Myself, I'm not terribly impressed with either of them. However, I do feel that Fantasia has the stronger voice.

Posted: **Tue May 25, 2004 7:40 pm**

My reason for voting for Diana is simply because in this industry, An incredibly voice is not what sells. otherwise you would all be listening to classically trained singers. Pop music stars like Maddona, Brittany, JLo, Avril,Cher, are some of the biggest pop stars now, But their voices are not the best youve ever heard. I think Diana has the best chance at recording a popular album. Everyone thohught Macy Gray was such a talent ( I hear Fantasia being compared to her) but who listens to her records anymore?

Posted: **Wed May 26, 2004 5:19 pm**

Defitnley Fantasia She has such a unique quality to her I can't really put my finger on Diana reminds me to much of a JLO and one is enough. So I hope Fantasia wins!

Posted: **Wed May 26, 2004 6:33 pm**

GOGOinVegas wrote: Everyone thohught Macy Gray was such a talent ( I hear Fantasia being compared to her) but who listens to her records anymore?

I know plenty who like Macy Gray than any popstar. That's why Fantasian should win. And one reason I don't want Diana to win is because I fear she's gonna be the next Kelly Clarkson: Good on show, bad on CD.

Posted: **Wed May 26, 2004 6:36 pm**

I dont watch American Idle.
I dont watch a lot of TV.
But I think Fantasia should win!!

Fantasia is one of best Diseny movie!!
Diana shuld lose

Yea go Fantasia!!
Sorcarers Aprentice rocks!!!!!
I watch it on MMILC the Treasure
It on there with other Micky cartoons
MMMILC is one of best Treasure
The Treasure rules
I highly recomend all Treasure
Best summer movie yet!!

Posted: **Wed May 26, 2004 8:35 pm**

... OK...

Well you can be happy Jack. Fantasia won.

Posted: **Wed May 26, 2004 11:01 pm**

Toya is gone, WGAF

Posted: **Wed May 26, 2004 11:38 pm**

BOYBOTT AMERICAN IDOL!

Posted: **Thu May 27, 2004 12:01 am**

MickeyMouseboy wrote:BOYBOTT AMERICAN IDOL!

...boycott you mean?

Fantasia won, and she really did deserve it. It wouldn't have made sense for Dianna to win.
Although I would have liked her to...

Posted: **Thu May 27, 2004 12:50 am**

Jack wrote:I dont watch American Idle.
I dont watch a lot of TV.
But I think Fantasia should win!!
Fantasia is one of best Diseny movie!!
Diana shuld lose
Yea go Fantasia!!
Sorcarers Aprentice rocks!!!!!
I watch it on MMILC the Treasure
It on there with other Micky cartoons
MMMILC is one of best Treasure
The Treasure rules
I highly recomend all Treasure
Best summer movie yet!!

Oh my that is so FUNNY

Posted: **Thu May 27, 2004 2:00 pm**

Yuki wrote:
MickeyMouseboy wrote:BOYBOTT AMERICAN IDOL!
...boycott you mean?

Fantasia won, and she really did deserve it. It wouldn't have made sense for Dianna to win.
Although I would have liked her to...

lol yes that's what I meant to write!