DVDizzy Forum

I figured since Jules' Household Appliances HoH game seems to be dead in the water, that I'd start this one that I've been meaning to do for awhile...

The Rules of the Game
The basic premise of "Hurt or Heal" is similar to Survivor. Players vote off which films they don't want to survive, but the twist is they can also save films they want to keep.

For this game, we're dealing with various Controversial Disney Topics. These range from outrageous stuff like "Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is!" to "The Disney Princess Line Must Die!". In addition, there will be other well-known controversies that did occur in Disney History, such as "Fantasia Should Have Been Edited". I know there's plenty of controversial topics out there that we could cover, but for this game, I'm only randomly thinking of 20. The purpose of this Hurt or Heal is to find out which controversial topic will be considered the most controversial. So heal the one you want to see get the most controversy, and hurt the one you feel isn't controversial enough.

Each Controversial Disney Topic (CDT) starts off with 10 points. Players may choose to do one of three actions:

1. "Hurt" a CDT by deleting 2 points.
2. "Heal a CDT by adding 2 points.
3. "Hurt" a CDT by deleting 1 point, and "Heal" a CDT by adding 1 point.

Players can only take ONE action a day. Thus, no one is allowed to get a CDT removed by "hurting" it until it's eliminated, and no one is allowed to raise a CDT's points by continually "healing" it in consecutive posts. "Day" is defined as the 24-hour period between 12:00 am and 11:59 pm in whatever timezone players reside in. Thus, a player may vote at 6:43 pm, then again at 2:18 am, and still have it considered one action a day. Players cannot take actions twice in the same day, for example: at 9:42 am and at 5:16 pm.

When a CDT reaches 0 points, it is eliminated from the game and cannot be brought back.

When a CDT reaches 20 points, no further points can be added. Points can still be taken away, then added again (i.e. 20 points to 18 points to 19 points to 20 points again), but 20 is the absolute limit.

To play the game, simply copy the list and adjust the points to reflect your action. Make sure to bold the CDT(s) you've adjusted so the next player knows what's been hurt or healed.

To re-iterate:

Players may take only ONE OF THREE Actions per day
-Hurt a CDT and subtract 2 points
-Heal a CDT and add 2 points
-Hurt a CDT for 1 point and Heal a CDT for 1 point

When a CDTreaches 0 points, it's ELIMINATED

CDT'sCANNOT exceed 20 points

So...let the healing process begin! Get out there and hurt them!

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 10 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 10 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 10 points

Scaps

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 10 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 12 points (+2)
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 10 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 8 points (-2)
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 12 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 10 points (-2 points)
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 8 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 12 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 10 points (-3 points)
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 8 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 13 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 10 points

Good idea Scaps Cleaned up the points a bit, looked a little off.

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 6 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 8 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 12 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points (-2)

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 6 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 6 points (-2)
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 12 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Chernabog_Rocks wrote:Good idea Scaps Cleaned up the points a bit, looked a little off.

Yeah, one is still a bit off.

Regarding the "redub the Shrill"...

Flanger-Hanger hurt it and removed 2 points, but forgot to change the 10 points to 8.

Then jeremy88 did a combo hurt/heal (I assume, even though it says -3 when it should say -1), but still kept it at 10 points.

So it should read 7 points, not 6...

Anyway, casting my first hurt/heal...

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 7 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 6 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 14 points (+2)
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 7 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 6 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 16 points (+2)
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 7 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points (-1)

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 6 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 17 points (+1)
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 7 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 4 points (-2)
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 17 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Okay, wait, Escapay, please help me. I want to use an example to explain my confusion.

I think re-dubbing Snow White's voice is the most horrible thing to do, especially if the original isn't made available. I mean, that's changing the original film, I can't believe since everyone wants to view the way a film originally was they could be okay with this. But I'm sure you mean just re-dubbing it at all, in which case I think it's still wrong and one of the worst things to do. So does that mean I think it's the most controversial, or should get the most controversy?

And then if that's the case, does that mean I should heal it, because I think it should be the most controversial? And then, did I do it all right?:

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points (+2)
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 4 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 17 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Mike wrote:But I'm sure you mean just re-dubbing it at all,

Yep.

All the topics are controversial in that the very idea of them will send fans and non-fans in a great big fury debate over whether or not it's a good idea (or whether or not it's true, such as the "Walt's head is frozen!" one). Thus, just the very idea of re-dubbing Snow White's voice (be it in the "the film will now be presented this way for future generations" or "it's a nice novelty") will spark controversy.

Regarding how to hurt/heal, you hurt a topic if you don't think it's controversial enough to merit being the last controversial topic left, and you heal a topic if you want it to stand out as the most controversial (which is somewhat the same as getting the most controversy).

For example, I personally don't think there's much controversy in the creation of Disney's California Adventure, but I'm sure there are many theme park aficionados who can argue that the place never should have been made. Thus, if inclined, I'd hurt it rather than heal it, so it gets eliminated sooner. I'd be more likely to heal the shafting of the Vault Disney programming, as to me that would be more controversial.

Since you think the redub is absitively-posilutely wrong in every way shape and form, that likely means you think it's the most controversial, thus the "healing" of the topic is what you wanted to do.

Albert

Oh, I thought the Snow White one was more pro-redub. That's why I hurt it because I don't think it should ever re-dubbed. Anyways, looks like I know what my next option is going to be.

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 2 points (-2)
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 17 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar - 0 points (-2) Eliminated!
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 17 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 10 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 19 points (+2)
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Just a couple friendly reminders:

1. Please remember to bold what you're hurting and/or healing so others can see.

2. When something is eliminated, please add the Eliminated List.

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points (-1)

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points (+1)
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points (+2)
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar

Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 10 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 7 points (-2)
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 9 points

Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 10 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points

Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points

Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 8 points

Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar