DVDizzy Forum

RULES:

Below is a list of non-Disney animated films. Vote for the one you like the LEAST. Base your vote not on how good or bad it is, but by how much you do or do not enjoy it.

You may only vote for TWO films per round. Your vote may not be changed. DO NOT EDIT YOUR POST. If I see your post has been edited, your entry will not be included in the tally.

Films listed in RED have been voted out.

FILMS:

1) AN AMERICAN TAIL
2) THE LAND BEFORE TIME
3) SHREK
4) THE IRON GIANT
5) THUMBELINA
6) CATS DONT DANCE
7) ANASTASIA
8 ) THE SWAN PRINCESS
9) ICE AGE
10) ANTZ
11) ALL DOGS GO TO HEAVEN
12) THE PRINCE OF EGYPT
13) THE ROAD TO EL DORADO
14) THE QUEST FOR CAMELOT
15) BALTO
16) FERN GULLY
17) CHARLOTTE'S WEB
18 ) THE SECRET OF NIMH
19) CHICKEN RUN
20) SINBAD: LEGEND OF THE SEVEN SEAS
21) SPIRIT: STALLION OF THE CIMARRON
22) SHARK TALE
23) MADAGASCAR
24) THE TRIPLETS OF BELLVILLE
25) ROBOTS
26) THE PAGEMASTER
27) THE PEBBLE AND THE PENGUIN
28 ) ROCK-A-DOODLE
29) WE'RE BACK! A DINOSAUR STORY
30) THE PRINCESS AND THE GOBLIN

17) CHARLOTTE'S WEB
24) THE TRIPLETS OF BELLVILLE

Those are definitely the worst of the two.

Prince of Egypt and Anastasia were BRILLIANT!!

Iron Giant gone? Shucks....

Anyways...

The Prince of Egypt
Charlotte's Web

Save Anastasia!!!!!!!!!!!

Charlotte's Web

Anastasia

Charlotte's Web is kind of weak, and the producers of Anastasia should have been sued by Disney!

Disney formula? No such thing. And regardless if 20th Century Fox copy-cated any "formula" - it was still was of the best non-Disney animated films ever. If Disney would have put out that same product - you'd be whistling a different tune.

MovieMusicals.net wrote:Disney formula? No such thing. And regardless if 20th Century Fox copy-cated any "formula" - it was still was of the best non-Disney animated films ever. If Disney would have put out that same product - you'd be whistling a different tune.

No, not really. I found it to be a bit mediocre. The songs were decent, but the characters were bland, and Rasputin and Bartok were carbon copies of Jafar and Iago. It's better than Charlotte's Web, but Triplets of Belleville is such a unique movie that I think it deserves to make the final two. I wish Fern Gully was here instead of Charlotte's Web.

ANASTASIA
CHARLOTTE'S WEB

Anastasia
Charlottes Web

Poor Iron Giant.

I haven't seen The Triplets of BelleVille, but I can say the other three weren't that good.


Anastasia was boring
Charlottes Web was also boring

and The Prince of Egypt was, you guessed it, boring.

Raydawggie wrote:

MovieMusicals.net wrote:Disney formula? No such thing. And regardless if 20th Century Fox copy-cated any "formula" - it was still was of the best non-Disney animated films ever. If Disney would have put out that same product - you'd be whistling a different tune.

No, not really. I found it to be a bit mediocre. The songs were decent, but the characters were bland, and Rasputin and Bartok were carbon copies of Jafar and Iago. It's better than Charlotte's Web, but Triplets of Belleville is such a unique movie that I think it deserves to make the final two. I wish Fern Gully was here instead of Charlotte's Web.

Don't fight too hard Raydawaggie, remember this is the same person that said Finding Nemo would've been a success if it was in 2D! Remember!