I just listened to all the songs on my MP3 player, and I made this review. Keep in mind I haven’t seen the Broadway play, I’ve just heard all the songs.
Fathoms Below- I enjoy this one. A lot. “As for me I’m about to heave ho!” love that line. Ariel’s voice was a nice touch.
Daughters of Triton- Eh, it’s okay. But it was so weird listening to the new lyrics, after all I’m used to the song being extremely short, so it just being a little longer was a surprise.
The World Above- It’s okay. Not my favorite new song, but I love Sierra’s voice. And I like the tune.
Human Stuff- I like the new Scuttle songs and the guy who plays Scuttle. He kinda reminds me of Rosie O’Donnell, though. And even though he’s not Buddy Hackett, it still good. It’s got a great catchy tune. I enjoy it a lot. “Wonderful stuff, human stuff!”
I Want the Good Times Back- I like the song a lot, but I can’t imagine Ursula singing this in the original movie. It does explain Ursula’s background very well, though. Once again, a great tune! I think Sherie’s changing the way she she talks/sings in the middle of the song is kinda strange. I agree with Siren, I like that the eels sing. Does Ursula say damn in this song?
Part of Your World- I’ve heard this song a million times on The View, Good Morning America, and Today. It’s not Jodi, but it’s still good. Sierra does justice to the song.
Part of Your World (Reprise)-It’s good, also. I wonder how this part is staged in the musical.
She’s in Love- I’ve mentioned before that I enjoyed this song. Unfortunately, I don’t see this song fitting in the movie either, at least not without some alterations. It kinda gives me a “Hercules” Muses feeling. Apparently, Flounder doesn’t know Ariel’s already in love. That surprises me. I suppose he’s not in the Part of Your World (Reprise). “Ariel and someone swimming in the sea K-I-S-S-I-N-G!” favorite quote. Like the ocean puns in here.
Her Voice- Starts kinda boringly. Gives me a “Pocahontas” feeling. “And her voice is sweet as angel sighing” favorite quote of this song. Sweet song, though.
The World Above (Reprise) - Whoever plays Triton has possibly the strongest voice of the entire cast. I enjoyed this one.
Under the Sea- Sebastian being my favorite character from the movie, I was very critical of this guy. But he’s not bad. I know this song inside and out, so I was kinda confused when the chorus starts singing the lyrics that Sebastian sings in the original film. Anyway, I enjoyed this song, also. I wonder if Samuel E. Wright will ever be cast as Sebastian?...
Under the Sea (Reprise) - Nice build up, but I wonder how this fits into the musical, because it wouldn’t fit in the movie.
Sweet Child- Great title!

Not my favorite song, but I enjoyed it. Very eerie. “You can’t mean…Aunt Ursula?” such a cool line.
Poor Unfortunate Souls- Enjoyed it. But enjoyed Pat Caroll’s better. Once again, Sherie’s changing her voice is very odd. And I don’t like that “Pathetic” is sung so, for lack of better words, strongly. And I prefer “Now sing! Sing!” rather than, “Now sing! Sing your voice over to me!” I love to see this scene in the play.
Positoovity- Cute little song. Another word to add to the TLM Fan Dictionary. Right between popsicle and prehysterical.

This song is officially my anthem!
Beyond My Wildest Dreams- This would have been perfect for the movie! But apparently there was a Bible in Ariel’s grotto. Hmm… Anyway, I didn’t initially like the “squeal-singing”, but now that I’ve listened to it hundreds of times, I’ve come to like it.I really like Sierra’s voice, also.
Les Poissons- My least favorite song from the movie, but I knew this song would be perfect for Broadway. And I imagine it is.
Les Poissons (Reprise) - Enjoyed it. Kinda reminds me of “Be Our Guest”.
One Step Closer- I enjoyed it. It gave me a feeling of both H.C. Andersen’s Little Mermaid and Disney’s The Little Mermaid. I didn’t particularly like Eric’s singing voice in this song, but I assume it must be hard to sing a song like this. I also liked the introduction to this song. Lovely tune.
I Want the Good Times Back (Reprise) - I liked this song. It’s a good introduction to the events of “Kiss the Girl”.
Kiss the Girl- Beautiful song as ever. I still think it would have been cute if Eric had guessed Ariel’s name as Jodi…
Sweet Child (Reprise) - Good song. Not my favorite, but it’s good. I wonder where this takes place in the musical, and are they singing to Ariel? I couldn’t tell.
If Only- I loved this. Simply loved this.
The Contest- Enjoyed it. Loved how it referenced “Part of Your World”. But it did give me an “American Idol” feeling, which doesn’t fit TLM.
Poor Unfortunate Souls (Reprise) - Eh, it’s okay… I liked the interaction between the two siblings. You don’t know how cool it is to call Triton and Ursula siblings, especially if you’re not a TLM fan.
If Only (Reprise) - Sweet song. It’s like the “I love you Daddy” scene put to music, which is my favorite scene of the entire movie.
All in all, I enjoyed the new songs. Someday, I hope I can see this play. I figure this play’s gonna have another 10 years on stage, though, simply on the popularity of the TLM movie.