DVDizzy Forum

Posted: **Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:08 pm**

SmartAleck25 wrote:Oh come on. Can't we let a non-famous Disney heroine win for once?

Nope.

Posted: **Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:11 pm**

SmartAleck25 wrote:Oh come on. Can't we let a non-famous Disney heroine win for once?

Well, there were Pocahontas and Tiana...

Posted: **Sat Nov 06, 2010 4:23 pm**

Ariel - 7
Mulan - 4 (+2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sat Nov 06, 2010 5:30 pm**

YES, thank you Chernaborg_Rocks! Now if only The Sequel of Disney would follow...

Disney's Divinity, I honestly have no idea what Pocahontas was doing up there... Better than Cinderella? Nah...

Posted: **Sat Nov 06, 2010 9:26 pm**

Good news and bad news. I am healing Mulan, but I never calculated when I healed Ariel, so now it looks like this:

Ariel - 9
Mulan - 6 (+2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sat Nov 06, 2010 10:02 pm**

Ah...my computer says 12, my forum says 11. Bah. Would've deleted, but somebody had to post at the same time...

Posted: **Sat Nov 06, 2010 10:03 pm**

Disney's Divinity wrote:
SmartAleck25 wrote:Oh come on. Can't we let a non-famous Disney heroine win for once?
Well, there were Pocahontas and Tiana...

I have seen Tiana on tons of merchandise already haha. I wouldn't say she is hurting in the publicity department. Poca and Mulan have been shafted for years it's time for revenge!!!

Ariel - 9
Mulan - 8 (+2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sat Nov 06, 2010 11:00 pm**

Ariel - 9
Mulan - 6 (-2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 1:44 am**

I think Mulan is more of a heroine then Ariel too!
It's not a matter of popularity here but heroisme!!!!

At least Mulan fights for her country, what does Ariel do???
(just for the record: TLM is stll my fav. movie, but Ariel is just not heroic)

She just gives up her voice for a guy she met like 3 days and to get married and leave her family???
Not very heroic and in real life this wouldn't end well: they have problems paying the water bills and who gets custody over Sebastian????

Go Mulan, fighter of her country and honour your family!!!

Ariel - 7 (- 2)
Mulan - 6

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 5:20 am**

Ariel - 7
Mulan - 4 (-2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 8:04 am**

stitchje1981 wrote:At least Mulan fights for her country, what does Ariel do???

Well, she does save Flounder several times early on, Eric at the ship, and then him and the two sidekicks again at the end. Of course, two of those situations were kind of her fault, but at least it shows that she doesn't just cause problems and abandon her friends to solve them.

But, yes, Mulan is probably more heroic in the sense your thinking of (although there wasn't a war for Ariel to join in her movie...). But for this poll I was guessing heroine = female protagonist.

omg, silly.

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 8:07 am**

stitchje1981 wrote:I think Mulan is more of a heroine then Ariel too!
It's not a matter of popularity here but heroisme!!!!

At least Mulan fights for her country, what does Ariel do???
(just for the record: TLM is stll my fav. movie, but Ariel is just not heroic)

She just gives up her voice for a guy she met like 3 days and to get married and leave her family???
Not very heroic and in real life this wouldn't end well: they have problems paying the water bills and who gets custody over Sebastian????

Go Mulan, fighter of her country and honour your family!!!

for that!

Ariel - 7
Mulan - 6 (+2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 8:20 am**

Ariel - 7
Mulan - 4 (-2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 1:05 pm**

Ariel - 7
Mulan - 6 (+2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 2:35 pm**

Divinity, um...She saved Flounder once with the shark, and then Eric. What...were...the other times?! I think she's heroic, but, she didn't show it more than those times I don't think.

Cinderella saved the mice, and that was a bunch of times, too (from the trap, from the cat, and getting Bruno). So she was heroic in that sense. As well as "fighting for a belief"m which you may or may not be able to say about other heroine, like Ariel, perhaps.

stitchje1981 all Hurt or Heal games are about popularity. You heal who you like more and hurt who you don't.

Except in this case, I'm just tired of Ariel always winning! Mwahahaha!

Ariel - 5 (-2)
Mulan - 6

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 3:36 pm**

Ariel - 5
Mulan - 4 (-2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 4:05 pm**

Ariel - 5
Mulan - 6 (+2)

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Sun Nov 07, 2010 7:26 pm**

Ariel - 3 (-2)
Mulan - 6

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Mon Nov 08, 2010 1:46 am**

Lol Disney Duster

You can't help it that everyone just likes fish (even a half one)

Ariel - 1 (-2)
Mulan - 6

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

Posted: **Mon Nov 08, 2010 5:00 am**

Ariel - 3 (+2)
Mulan - 6

Eliminated:
Nala
Lady
Eilonwy
Perdita
Kida
Belle
Alice
Wendy
Maid Marian
Penny
Jane
Rapunzel
Giselle
Miss Bianca
Meg
Jasmine
Aurora
Esmeralda
Snow White
Cinderella
Pocahontas
Tiana

DVDizzy Forum

Hurt or Heal: Disney Heroines