Here's my top 10:
1. Gold Collection DVD: I really like this cover. I always thought it was an alternate version of the theatrical poster, but
Mooky and
Sicoe Vlad are right; they just replaced Pocahontas' face with her face in the Masterpiece VHS, and Meeko's pose. I prefer the original poster, but this is still a beautiful cover.
It's true! That's exactly the frame from the film the original poster was based on.
2. Masterpiece VHS: The VHS cover we got in Spain is the same as the UK one and I'm fond of it, but I actually think the US one is better. I like that they chose that iconic pose of Pocahontas that was also used as
one of the theatrical posters. She doesn't look as good as in the still from the poster, but not bad either. I'm not a big fan of the bottom half, though, with the characters just posing there artificially. And I especially dislike John Smith looking at the camera, but I get what they were trying to do; showing the two conflicting parties, one on each side.
3. UK VHS: This one is clearly based on the Masterpiece VHS. I like it too, and as I said, I have good memories of it. There are also certain elements I prefer here, like the color of the background. I'm not sure it's the sky, though, I think it's just the background of the part with Pocahontas that blends into the sky at the bottom. However, though Pocahontas doesn't look bad here, this is not the same iconic pose of her anymore and the symmetry and symbology of the lower part is partially lost. Here Powhatan is smiling and doesn't seem bothered by the invaders. Not to mention, at least he and Ratcliffe are drawn worse. I still like the cover, though.
4. Italian VHS: As I previously mentioned, in my opinion Pocahontas looks more accurate here (and more beautiful) than in many other covers. The other characters don't look bad either. What I don't like here, though, is the background. I guess they wanted to do something similar to the Masterpiece cover with the opposing characters, but it doesn't work very well and their poses are even more ridiculous here. I wish it was just Pocahontas with the forest behind. I guess something about the drawing or coloring makes it look a bit cheap as well, like
JeanGreyForever pointed out, but that doesn't bother me too much.
5. French DVD: Like
Mooky, I never liked how Pocahontas looked in the shot featured here, but the idea of the feather is clever and it's an elegant cover.
6. Deluxe Laserdisc: This one is classy too. Pocahontas is well drawn and the effect of the colorful leaves versus the rest in monochromatic hues is cool. However, I think they could've done something a bit more interesting with all these elements.
7. Japanese VHS/Laserdisc: I like how different it is from all the other covers and the layout is good. I just wish the characters had been more on-model. Plus, Smith is just posing there again. He could be doing something a little more interesting. It seems they don't know what to do with him in most of the covers.
8. Brazilian Musical Edition DVD: I had a coloring book with that pose and I've always liked how Pocahontas looked there. It's not as well drawn here as in the clipart, but not too bad either, and Grandmother Willow is on model for once! I don't think this is the best image to represent the movie, but given that it's for an alternate musical version, that doesn't mind too much. Though, come to think of it, shouldn't the musical edition show a scene from one of the musical numbers?
9. Zavvi Steelbook: This uses the same drawing of Pocahontas than the DMC Exclusive and the Heroes cover, but at least here it's used to create a nice composition and the ornate frame adds interest (though I agree with
JeanGreyForever that the colors of it are not the most appropriate for the movie). Poor Flit seems to be dragged by the wind here, but he complements the layout nicely. However, why did they have to make the lower part of Pocahontas fade here? She seems to be a ghost. If it's to make the title more visible, they could've just put a frame behind it.
10. 10th Anniversary Edition DVD: This one is not very well drawn and not too representative of the film, plus I hate the green border (the
UK version without it is better), but at least the composition is pleasant. Plus, I have bigger issues with the remaining covers.
I agree with the ones who said that the Musical Masterpiece DVD is the worst one. The layout is not bad, but the execution is horrible.
Mooky wrote:3. Musical Masterpiece Edition - it's true that Pocahontas is off-model (making her hair shorter is a crime!), but I think this cover has a great layout and I like the colors. Another messed up thing is that Grandmother Willow's face is obscured by the title. Yikes.
I had noticed Pocahontas' shorter hair, but not that we can't see Grandmother Willow because of the title. Poor Grandmother Willow, she's not treated very well in the covers. Where she's not off-model, she's obscured by something, like the strange glow around Pocahontas in the DMC Exclusive or the title again in the Brazilian cover.