DVDizzy Forum

I don't know where I read it but I saw someone mentioning the girl who played Luna Lovegood in HP. She would be perfect as Alice. Especially a Burton version of Alice.

oh Im excited about this,
I only wish it was going to be the looking glass war's, because I think burton could do wonders for that- I doubt he will want to make two alice-related films

PatrickvD wrote:I don't know where I read it but I saw someone mentioning the girl who played Luna Lovegood in HP. She would be perfect as Alice. Especially a Burton version of Alice.

Oh,that whould be perfact .
She's so cute,she'll fit.

Alice is 8 or 9 yrs old and Evanna Lynch (Luna) is just as old as I am !

Annasophia Robb is the most likely choice :

<a href="http://photobucket.com" target="_blank"><img src="http://i231.photobucket.com/albums/ee23 ... sophia.jpg" border="0" alt="Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket"></a>


1.Tim Burton seems to like to work with his actors from previous movies. (Annasophia was the sporty bubble gum girl who turned purple and fat in Tim Burton's Charlie & the Chocolate Factory)

2. She worked with Disney before in The Bridge to Terabithia and made a great job.

3. She's a blond babyface just like Alice.

Jack Skellington wrote:Alice is 8 or 9 yrs old and Evanna Lynch (Luna) is just as old as I am !

Annasophia Robb is the most likely choice :

<a href="http://photobucket.com" target="_blank"><img src="http://i231.photobucket.com/albums/ee23 ... sophia.jpg" border="0" alt="Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket"></a>


1.Tim Burton seems to like to work with his actors from previous movies. (Annasophia was the sporty bubble gum girl who turned purple and fat in Tim Burton's Charlie & the Chocolate Factory)

2. She worked with Disney before in The Bridge to Terabithia and made a great job.

3. She's a blond babyface just like Alice.

She's a bit more older.
Anyway i think Evanna will fit.
By the way-the girl's name from Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is Voilet.

There is nobody named Voilet in the movie.

There is,however,a charector named Violet.

And believe it or not,Alice is supposed to be seven.

PeterPanfan wrote: And beleive it or not,Alive is supposed to be seven.

In American MeGee's Alice she's 20,isn't it better?.
Evanna will be perfact in my opinion.

Ariel'sprince wrote:

PeterPanfan wrote: And beleive it or not,Alive is supposed to be seven.

In American MeGee's Alice she's 20,isn't it better?.
Evanna will be perfact in my opinion.

well she has been out of wonderland for some time,
thats why everything has gone awry.

Someday... wrote:

Ariel'sprince wrote: In American MeGee's Alice she's 20,isn't it better?.
Evanna will be perfact in my opinion.

well she has been out of wonderland for some time,
thats why everything has gone awry.

Oh,okay.

Is Burton's Alice going to be based more on the book, or have more of the classic animated masterpiece?

Is Burton's Alice going to be based more on the book, or have more of the classic animated masterpiece?

Is "I'm Late" going to be in his version?

It's going to be a separate book adaptation, so the songs from the animated film won't be in this. I don't think it's going to be a musical, period, either way. I'm excited to hear what Danny Elfman cooks up for this film, though.

ughhh, I love his style but his remakes are TERRIBLE.

technically this isn't a remake...its just a different version.

It's has to have A Merry Unhappy Birthday and Golden Afternoon.

It's not Alice without it, I'm Late also has to be in the movie as well.

Why? You can always watch the animated film with those songs in it.
I'd like this film to be as different from the Disney version as possible. Not that I dislike the Disney version, no, I love it, but I don't see any point in doing the same thing again.

I must say I'm a little sceptical about this. Burton's Planet of the Apes remake was terrible compared to the original. However, I liked very much his take on Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. In places, it was way better than the 70's film version, but it added some things which I thought it would have done better without.

BTW, you do mean A Very Merry Unbirthday, don't you? (Although I think the official title is just The Unbirthday Song.)

Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory is a classic and didn't need to be remade, neither did Planet of the Apes.

it's just not Alice without these songs, when one thinks of Alice its Disney's masterpiece, not Lewis Carol's novel.

SwordInTheStone777 wrote:Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory is a classic and didn't need to be remade, neither did Planet of the Apes.

it's just not Alice without these songs, when one thinks of Alice its Disney's masterpiece, not Lewis Carol's novel.

First, "Willy Wonka" was not remade. He made a film version of the novel again, hence why it is called "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory", not "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory". It's an entirely different film. It would be a remake had he based his film on the script from the 70's movie. And frankly, if you've ever read the book, the 70's movie left a lot to be desired.

And if one thinks of the movie "Alice" and not the source material, then that's just sad. There's no reason why Tim Burton should use the songs. He's making a movie based on the book, not a carbon copy of the animated film with live-action/CGI elements.

SpringHeelJack wrote:

SwordInTheStone777 wrote:Willy Wonka and The Chocolate Factory is a classic and didn't need to be remade, neither did Planet of the Apes.

it's just not Alice without these songs, when one thinks of Alice its Disney's masterpiece, not Lewis Carol's novel.

First, "Willy Wonka" was not remade. He made a film version of the novel again, hence why it is called "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory", not "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory". It's an entirely different film. It would be a remake had he based his film on the script from the 70's movie. And frankly, if you've ever read the book, the 70's movie left a lot to be desired.

And if one thinks of the movie "Alice" and not the source material, then that's just sad. There's no reason why Tim Burton should use the songs. He's making a movie based on the book, not a carbon copy of the animated film with live-action/CGI elements.

IAWTC.

Also, not everyone thinks of Disney when it comes to Alice. Some people might think of the book first, or other film/stage adaptations.

Yes, I bet some people do, but most people think of The Disney Masterpiece.