Just Myself wrote:Luke, dude, all those films you mentioned will kill this , and I'll say why:
1. Monsters and Nemo were excellent. This was good, maybe great, but nowhere near excellent and that was the average audience reaction.
2. Most of the audience was repeat viewers. Kids always take their friends to the movies after they've seen them. If this didn't have repeat audiences, NT and MTF would have beat it by at least $50 million.
Just Myself wrote:Dude, Star Wars is gonna kick this films ass. It's not as good as the other Pixar movies, it didn't make as much money as them, and it's not gonna be top selling DVD of 2005. It will probably be in the top 10, maybe 5, but not at number one.
Well, I told ya so.
Link
The final tallies for 2005:
1. The Incredibles, 17.38 M units
2. Star Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith, 10.36 M units
3. Madagascar, 10 M units
4. Shark Tale, 10 M units
5. The Polar Express, 8.13 M units
6. Meet the Fockers, 7.21 M units
7. National Treasure, 7.2 M units
8. Cinderella, 6.56 M units
9. Ray, 6.53 M units
10. Batman Begins, 6.15 M units
People may question the public's taste, but more people did buy the best film of 2004 than any other movie, so

to the people (i.e. public).