Page 3 of 8
Posted: Sat Aug 09, 2008 9:15 pm
by Escapay
stlewis75 wrote:If it's all right, then, I'd like to return to the past on this thing and put the vote back to what it was before I misunderstood and ran it off course. I say we go back to about July 23rd... but still keep Disney Duster's and Escapy's votes since then. Mostly I'm just erasing all of my own votes for the last couple of weeks now that I understand what's going on. If this is okay with everyone, let's just start at this point:
Sounds fine by me.
Albert
Hurt or Heal: Disney Controversy
Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 1:40 pm
by Disney Duster
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 8 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 6 points (-2) Slipcovers are great, no controversy!
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Re: Hurt or Heal: Disney Controversy
Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2008 10:20 am
by Disney Duster
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 8 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 4 points (-2)
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Posted: Tue Aug 19, 2008 5:59 am
by UmbrellaFish
I guess I'll join in...
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 10 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 8 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 2 points (-2)
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Posted: Tue Aug 19, 2008 7:40 am
by TheSequelOfDisney
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points (+2)
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 8 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 2 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Hurt or Heal: Disney Controversy
Posted: Tue Aug 26, 2008 12:22 pm
by Disney Duster
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 9 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 8 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Slipcovers - 0 points (-2) Eliminated!
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Re: Hurt or Heal: Disney Controversy
Posted: Thu Oct 02, 2008 1:30 pm
by Disney Duster
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points (+ 2)
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 8 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 10 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 10 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 2:19 pm
by Big Disney Fan
Wow, I don't believe it! This thread is a year and a half old before I came along. Why was this abandoned early on? We need to keep this up.
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 8 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 11 points (+1)
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 9 points (-1)
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 6:10 pm
by zackiellovedisney
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 9 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points (+2)
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 11 points (+1)
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 9 points (-1)
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Thu Dec 24, 2009 9:55 pm
by Margos
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 7 points (-2)
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 10 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 11 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 9 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 9:38 am
by Big Disney Fan
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 7 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 8 points (-2)
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 11 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 9 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 4:41 pm
by zackiellovedisney
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 7 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 6 points (-2)
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 11 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 9 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Fri Dec 25, 2009 5:39 pm
by Margos
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 5 points (-2)
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 6 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 11 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 9 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2009 10:10 am
by Big Disney Fan
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 5 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 6 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 12 points (+1)
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 8 points (-1)
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2009 12:20 pm
by Margos
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 3 points (-2)
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 6 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 12 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 8 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Sat Dec 26, 2009 8:39 pm
by zackiellovedisney
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 8 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 4 points (+1)
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 5 points (-1)
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 12 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 12 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 8 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Sun Dec 27, 2009 12:34 pm
by Big Disney Fan
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 7 points (-1)
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 4 points
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 5 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 13 points (+1)
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 12 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 8 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers
Posted: Sun Dec 27, 2009 2:04 pm
by Escapay
BDF wrote:Why was this abandoned early on?
Because nobody likes controversy apparently.
Posted: Sun Dec 27, 2009 2:24 pm
by Big Disney Fan
Escapay wrote:BDF wrote:Why was this abandoned early on?
Because nobody likes controversy apparently.
Well, I figured we should keep this thread alive until it's truly over. I felt it should have another lease on life and finish what got started.
And apparently the people who revived it do like controversy and seeing which one stands out above the rest.
Posted: Sun Dec 27, 2009 10:16 pm
by Margos
Controversies Concerning Walt
Walt's Head Is Frozen! Really, It Is! - 7 points
Was Walt really an Anti-Semitic, Communist-Hatin', Parent-Resenting, Nasty Old Grouch? - 2 points (-2)
Controversies Concerning Disney Animated Classics
Please Re-Dub Snow White's Voice With Someone Less Grating To Your Ears - 11 points
Fantasia Should Have Been Edited - 12 points
Phasing out 2D Animation in favor of CGI...only to go back to 2D again - 10 points
Controversies Concerning Theme Parks
The Damn Hand-and-Wand at Epcot, and Fugly Hat at MGM - 5 points
The Creation of Disney's California Adventure - 10 points
The Closing of Downtown Disney's Pleasure Island - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Company & Marketing
The Overindulgence of Direct-To-Video Sequels - 11 points
Michael Eisner Last Few Years Weren't That Bad - 10 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Die! - 13 points
The Disney Princess Line Must Flourish! - 10 points
Controversies Concerning The Disney Channel
Getting rid of the "Vault Disney" programming on The Disney Channel - 20 points
The Overpromotion and Overhype of High School Musical - 12 points
Disney Channel Circle of Stars and the bunch of Smiley McTweenStars that have come since - 10 points
Controversies Concerning DVD
OAR Widescreen Movies Getting P&S/Open-Matte Fullscreen DVDs - 10 points
The Very Idea of The Disney Vault - 10 points
The Sorry Excuse of a Platinum Edition for Peter Pan - 8 points
Eliminated:
Disney Should Not Have Bought Pixar
Slipcovers