UmbrellaFish wrote:First impression is they have a lot more shorts than I thought they would. I’m not an expert, it doesn’t look like they have everything, but they have a lot more than I expected. This is a great positive for me as I have almost no Treasures and was hopeful this would fill the gap.
What cartoons do they have? Can you provide a list? I assume there's more than what they had initially mentioned.
Also, almost ("almost" being the operative word) all of the classic shorts, starring Mickey, Donald and the rest, have been released on the Disney Treasures line. There are a few exceptions, however. For instance, a small handful have been released on other DVDs, but not the Treasures set, such as the Chip 'n' Dale shorts, of which there were three. Of those three, two, "Chicken In the Rough" and "Two Chips and a Miss", were released in 2005 on the Classic Cartoon Favorites line of DVDs, and the third short, "The Lone Chipmunks", was released as a bonus on a DVD of a "Davy Crockett" movie (I forget which one, though; probably "Davy Crockett and the River Pirates").
Also, "Susie the Little Blue Coupe" and "Casey Bats Again" were conspicuously missing from the Rarities DVD, home of the "special" cartoons they did that could technically be considered an extension of the Silly Symphonies (which, for me, is a catch-all term for any short that is not a Mickey, a Donald, a Goofy or a Pluto), but "Susie" was featured as a bonus on DVD releases of "The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad" and "The Love Bug", as well as the "Small World of Fun" line of DVDs, while "Casey Bats Again" was featured as a bonus on the DVD release not of "Make Mine Music", oddly enough, but of "Melody Time".
And then there's Goofy. Two of his shorts, "How To Ride a Horse" and "El Gaucho Goofy", were not featured on the Goofy DVD, but that's understandable given that they were originally released as part of other movies ("The Reluctant Dragon" and "Saludos Amigos", respectively), but his two shorts in the 1960s on how (not) to drive safely on the freeway, "Freewayphobia" and "Goofy's Freeway Troubles", have never been released on DVD at all (or even VHS). As well, several educational shorts starring Donald in the 1960s were never released on the four-part Donald set: "Steel and America", "Donald's Fire Survival Plan" and "Family Planning" (which seems like a throwback to those South American films of the '40s). Finally, two other 1960s cartoons have not been released on DVD at all: "Scrooge McDuck and Money" and "It's Tough To Be a Bird", both of which, if I recall, can be found on YouTube (or at least they were; I don't know if they still are or if they have been taken down).
Whether any of the above cartoons I mentioned will be included remains to be seen, unless they appear on the list that I asked for about cartoons featured here. So, again I ask, can you list what shorts are featured on Disney Plus? Based on your comments, I assume there is more than what they have already mentioned?
I’ve got Dumbo on. The Song of the Roustabouts is still there. I see the crows are still there, too.
Hooray! As I've said before, regardless of racial insensitivity, the crows are among the few sympathetic characters in the movie, they are pivotal to the story, and they provide one of the movie's most well-known songs ("When I See an Elephant Fly"). It sounds like The Boardwalk Times (the fansite that originated the rumor of the crows being missing ("Boardwalk" refers to the Boardwalk Resort at WDW)) owes us and the Hollywood press (Variety, The Hollywood Reporter and others picked up on the rumor) an apology!
Briefly during the Fantasia “intermission,” a Fantasia title card is brought up I’m not sure if I recall it being this way on my Blu-Ray? Of course Sunflower is still missing. I think the disclaimer here accounts for the Chinese mushrooms, which are similarly racist but still present.
Funny, I seem to recall that the title card came at the
end of the Blu-Ray, but then I don't have the Blu-Ray, only the DVD, which does feature the title card during the intermission. Also, the two black centaurettes are still present, right? They are the ones with zebra bodies who are seen serving wine to Bacchus when he first appears.
If you click on “The Muppets Collection” it says “Sorry, content you are trying to access is not available currently.”
So does that mean that you can't watch "The Muppet Movie", "The Great Muppet Caper", etc.? That sucks. Maybe it's just not available yet.