Page 2 of 2
Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 2:50 pm
by castleinthesky
Raydawggie wrote:Normal Survivors don't go a month between rounds and pick up again suddenly with no real warning. As glad as I am that Mr. Toad picked up the game again, he really should have given an all-around amnesty for this round. After all, I think most of us had given this game up for done.
The Past is over, you cannot go back and say round one abscences can be ignored because it affected every one of our rounds from their fourth. If the beginning round didn't count, the game would be seriously different.
Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:01 pm
by Eatmorchiken
Well this is interesting to say the least...
I'm sorry Pridelands. I did forget to send my answers in. I've been very busy lately, and have checked back as frequently as I could, but it was getting tiresome, never knowing when the game was going to be back on.
If I'm out, I'm out. and good luck to Pridelands!
Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:01 pm
by Prince Eric
Raydawggie wrote:Normal Survivors don't go a month between rounds and pick up again suddenly with no real warning. As glad as I am that Mr. Toad picked up the game again, he really should have given an all-around amnesty for this round. After all, I think most of us had given this game up for done.
The same could be said for Round 1 buddy. Everyone should have been on there toes. Besides, I don't know why you or anyone wants to be stuck in the beginning stages of this game. Move foward already! Don't halt!

If they're not playing, they're dead wieght! The teams should look like this:
Disney Royale
*Andy*
AwallaceUNC
castleinthesky
Cydney
Enchantress
LucyLover
Prince Eric
Pridelands
Dave Wadding
Disney Guru
MickeyMousePal
Raydawggie
RJKD3
Robin Hood
Timon/Pumba Fan
Keep in mind, Pridelands STILL must vote somewhat out from the previous round.
Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:06 pm
by Raydawggie
Prince Eric wrote:The same could be said for Round 1 buddy. Everyone should have been on there toes. Besides, I don't know why you or anyone wants to be stuck in the beginning stages of this game. Move foward already! Don't halt!

If they're not playing, they're dead wieght! The teams should look like this:
Quotation condensed by moderator. Please try to keep only directly relevant posts in your quotations. Thank you.
Keep in mind, Pridelands STILL must vote somewhat out from the previous round.
Okay, you want to play it that way, let's go. But I'm waiting back to hear from Mr. Toad on the immunity issue. If we can't sabotage you guys by throwing and voting our new members off, they shouldn't be able to sabotage us by throwing the round knowing they're safe. Fair's fair.
Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:10 pm
by Prince Eric
Raydawggie wrote:Okay, you want to play it that way, let's go. But I'm waiting back to hear from Mr. Toad on the immunity issue. If we can't sabotage you guys by throwing and voting our new members off, they shouldn't be able to sabotage us by throwing the round knowing they're safe. Fair's fair.
Quotation condensed by moderator. Please try to keep only directly relevant posts in your quotations. Thank you.
Once a rule is enacted, it can't be repealed. That is psychologically unethical. Rules cannot be arbitrary like that. If we didn't protest anything, you guys can't either.

Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:12 pm
by Raydawggie
Prince Eric wrote:Once a rule is enacted, it can't be repealed. That is psychologically unethical. Rules cannot be arbitrary like that. If we didn't protest anything, you guys can't either.
Quotation condensed by moderator. Please try to keep only directly relevant posts in your quotations. Thank you.
Are you kidding me? You protested the whole twist, and as a result, Mr. Toad enacted the immunity rule AFTER THE FACT. Now, I'm doing the same thing. What exactly is your objection to my suggestion? It sounds like you want an unfair advantage.
Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:15 pm
by Prince Eric
Raydawggie wrote:Are you kidding me? You protested the whole twist, and as a result, Mr. Toad enacted the immunity rule AFTER THE FACT. Now, I'm doing the same thing. What exactly is your objection to my suggestion? It sounds like you want an unfair advantage.
Quotation condensed by moderator. Please try to keep only directly relevant posts in your quotations. Thank you.
It sounds like you want to SABOTOGE. Oh, wait, a minute, those were YOUR own words. I didn't protest. I eagerly anticipated it, I just expressed my concerns that this wasn't Ichabod's initial intentions.

Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:19 pm
by Raydawggie
Prince Eric wrote:It sounds like you want to SABOTOGE. Oh, wait, a minute, those were YOUR own words. I didn't protest. I eagerly anticipated it, I just expressed my concerns that this wasn't Ichabod's initial intentions.
Quotation condensed by moderator. Please try to keep only directly relevant posts in your quotations. Thank you.
And all I'm doing is pointing out another flaw in the twist. And don't worry, I don't mean any harm to your former tribemates. After all, a Judd is worth 10 Silases.

Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:21 pm
by Prince Eric
Let's get back to basics. Mr. Toad didn't know that ChayChay was supposed to elimated, so that put the teams at a 9-4 split, once you guys chose who to give the boot. The purpose of the twist was to even up the teams. So in my opinion, Mr. Toad should reconsider the twist and see if wants to use another method for redrawing teams, or postpone it once we're back to an even number. I have never heard of a forced swap that still leaves tribes uneven on the real Survivor.

Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 3:35 pm
by Prince Eric
I propose we just wait and see who needs to get voted off of the Pridelands before we make The Twist official. Chronologically, that makes sense. The Twist should have come AFTER we found out who needed to go, so we can know for sure what people we're dealing with.

Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 10:12 pm
by MickeyMousePal
What happen to the break down of the points for each tribe member?
Posted: Wed Oct 19, 2005 11:16 pm
by Mr. Toad
MickeyMousePal - you all submitted the exact same answers, you all got 15(although the truth was probably 14-I gave you Mickeys Christmas Carol even though it was probably incorrect)
RJKD got 16, Raydawggie 14, Robin Hood 10, and ChayChay was awarded 15 points(although it was really Enchantress impersonating ChayChay-see what happens when you dont say who you are).
Dave Wadding is eliminated. And he was so happy to see his new team members.
Posted: Thu Oct 20, 2005 1:03 pm
by castleinthesky
Mr. Toad wrote:
RJKD got 16, Raydawggie 14, Robin Hood 10, and ChayChay was awarded 15 points(although it was really Enchantress impersonating ChayChay-see what happens when you dont say who you are).
Tha makes no sense. How can Chay Chay get points even though the e-mail had no name?? You assummed it was ChayChay even though it wasn't. Hmmm, but it didn't state a name. So ChayChay should not get points and should be eliminated for missing 2 rounds.
Posted: Thu Oct 20, 2005 1:06 pm
by Raydawggie
castleinthesky wrote:Mr. Toad wrote:
RJKD got 16, Raydawggie 14, Robin Hood 10, and ChayChay was awarded 15 points(although it was really Enchantress impersonating ChayChay-see what happens when you dont say who you are).
Tha makes no sense. How can Chay Chay get points even though the e-mail had no name?? You assummed it was ChayChay even though it wasn't. Hmmm, but it didn't state a name. So ChayChay should not get points and should be eliminated for missing 2 rounds.
Little late to the party, aren't you? Mr. Toad did both things already.Berating the host......someone's not getting invited back for All-Stars.

Posted: Thu Oct 20, 2005 1:10 pm
by castleinthesky
Raydawggie wrote:Little late to the party, aren't you? Mr. Toad did both things already.Berating the host......someone's not getting invited back for All-Stars.

well, lol, sorry.
