Posted: Wed Apr 18, 2007 7:53 am
from what article is that picture from? and what event?
Disney, DVD, and Beyond Forums
https://dvdizzy.com/forum/
I agree, and that might be what they do. But I hope they stay with the original story and have the mother name her daughter Rapunzel because of the rapunzel she ate while she was pregnant.Snow White wrote:In actually Disney version, Rapunzel and her Prince are only abstact figures… if Glen Keane want that the name of the main character will be Claire, he must make this: Claire is the birthname of the heroine and Rapunzel is the nickname created by the evil witch (it’s the same solution adopted for Disney’s “Spleeping Beauty”). There is no other solution.
I know that in every fairy tale the pincess falls in love with a handsome prince, but I found your comment to be cruel. People who are overweight or are not very beautiful might be sad to see only the beautiful people starring in movies and falling in love. Sometimes people who are overweight have problems that prevent them from being thin as other people. So if Disney didn't have the usual handsome lead get the beautiful girl, that might be seen as something positive for less beautiful people, because beautiful people are rare, and more people look like the pizza boy! People may actually applaud Disney for not inflicting the idea that you have to be beautiful to star in something or get to be with the person you want.Snow White wrote:The Prince… oh my God! I watched concept art of the Prince and he is terrible, he is very ugly! The Prince in a classical fairy tale must to be Prince Charming, not the horrible fat pizza boy that all people have seen in concept art!!! The Prince must to be an handsome boy, a dream Prince!
That sounds nice, but France has been used already. It is not proven, but evidence suggests that Disney's Cinderella is set in 18th century France, and Disney's Beauty and the Beast is known to be set in France. I would suggest a different location. I read that it is a German fairy tale, so maybe it should be in Germany, even though Disney's Snow White was set in Germany, it is only in that one film.Snow White wrote:In MY VERSION of the story, the movie is setting in a lush country (similar to France of XVIII century)
This sounds a little like Sleeping Beauty's story. Rapunzel is kept hidden from the world, like Briar Rose was kept hidden, and she meets a prince who she doesn't know is a prince.Snow White wrote:Rapunzel is a pure, perfect heroine: she is beautiful, sweet, kind-heart and she is a dreamer girl: she is imprisoned into a huge tower/in a forest and she want to be free (similar to Jasmine)! One day she meets an handsome knight, who is really the Prince, but he don’t reveal her that he is a Prince… she thinks that he’s a simply knight or a simply hunter.
I like that! Disney has never done it like that before! We've never heard the beating heart or seen much passion from two characters in love in a Disney film. It might make their love for each other more believable and when they are far apart, more unbearable. Sounds good!Snow White wrote:They fall in love (this scene is too important and must to be very romantic: their eye must meets, their heart must beat fast, the scene is full of love and passion).
That is an interesting turn, but I feel too many stories are based on Romeo and Juliet.Snow White wrote:I imagine Rapunzel and her Prince will live a star-crossed Romeo-and-Juliet romance and their families (for her, the witch, for him the king) were hell-bent on keeping them apart.
I don't think you should cross two fairy tales to make one. I don't know the plot of "Maid Madleen", but I would not rely heavily on it.Snow White wrote:The beginning of my story is very similar by the Brothers Grimms story… but I change the second part of the story (and I found my ispiration in another fairy tale by Brothers Grimm, “Maid Maleen” which is a similar version of “Rapunzel”)
Do you mean the witch talks to the king and wants Rapunzel walled up? I thought the witch loved Rapunzel so much she wouldn't do that, unless she is angry at Rapunzel for seeing a stranger. Will she still try to visit Rapunzel in the tower, maybe by using magic to go through the wall?Snow White wrote:The king (who is an old and authoritarian king) want to abdicate in favor of his son, but he want that his son will marry the daughter of a rich Baroness. The Prince refuses to marry the daughter of the Baroness because he is in love with Rapunzel, but the two woman convince the king to wall Rapunzel in the tower because Rapunzel is the cause of Prince’s blindness.
Interesting use of the squirrel and fairies! They will be able to help her with some things she needs! I also like that she goes on a journey to find the Prince. It encourages girls to take control of their situation.Snow White wrote:The king orders that Rapunzel is locked up in her tower, so many knights of the king wall Rapunzel in her tower.
Rapunzel discovers the way to escape from the tower with the help of her squirrel and fairies.
Out of her tower, she want to reunite with ther true love. So she begin a difficult journey to search her true love.
Oh, why do we have to make someone ugly be so bad? It will hurt people who are not beautiful if they see a movie where ugly people are treated so badly. The daughter should just be very wicked or something she can change. People can't change their looks easily and it's not their fault they look the way they do.Snow White wrote:At the Castle, the Prince is blackmailed to marry the daughter of the Baroness in order to free and protect Rapunzel (he don’t know that the king walled Rapunzel into the tower). The mother of the future bride know that her daughter is hideously ugly: they want to have power so they scheme to have the throne.
This is very interesting, but I don't think it should have anything to do with her being ugly.Snow White wrote:One day, Rapunzel come to Prince’s castle and she is forced to participate at the complot of the evil Baroness. The Baroness sends Rapunzel in place of her daughter at the engagement ball because she don’t want that the court sees the face of her ugly daughter!
I'm glad your ending is close to the original fairy tale. I see you did not include the twins Rapunzel bears. That might be better for a Disney film because the twins suggested Rapunzel had sex with the prince and Disney should not teach children to have sex and bear children when they are so young!Snow White wrote:At the engagement ball, Rapunzel discovers that the mysterious knight is the Prince! She discovers the terrible blackmail and she reveals her true identity at the Prince. Two tears of the heroine make a miracle: the tears touche Prince’s eyes and he see again.
So Prince and Rapunzel are reunited and they reveal the scheme of the Baroness against the king.
Rapunzel and her Prince must battle the evil witch who was at the ball and the final battle is coming…
At the end, the Baroness and her evil daughter are send in exile, the king recognize the heart nobility of Rapunzel and the king name her Princess, so Rapunzel and her Prince can live happily ever after.
I've read that too. Here it is on imdb.comTheSequelofDisney wrote:Isn't it true that Kristin Chenowith is voicing Rapunzel? I think I read that somewhere, but I'm not sure of whether it was accurate or not. Thanks if anyone can answer.
Well didn't she marry the prince at the end of the story?Disney's Divinity wrote:Rapunzel wasn't in any way a princess.
I meant beforehand. And the movie hasn't come out, so she's not a princess yet!Well didn't she marry the prince at the end of the story?
I would like depth, too, and I particularly like that example. What version was that you saw?Disney's Divinity wrote:And, from one version I've seen of Rapunzel, the witch locks the girl up in the tower because she doesn't want her to be corrupted by men. I'd like them to give the villainess depth like that.