UltimateDisney.com | DVDizzy.com: New and Upcoming DVD & Blu-ray Schedule | DVD and Blu-ray Reviews | Upcoming Cover Art | Search This Site
Forever Funny: T.V. Sets DVD Review
"Well, the way they make shows is, they make one show. That show's called a pilot. Then they show that show to the people who make shows, and on the strength of that one show, they decide if they're going to make more shows. Some pilots get picked and become television programs. Some don't, become nothing." - Jules Winnfield, Pulp Fiction
Fifteen years ago, Samuel L. Jackson's afroed hitman offered the above explanation to his partner in crime Vincent Vega. Many pitched shows don't even get to film a pilot. Those that do get one shot to prove their ideas are strong enough to support a series. Most of those never make it on the air. For those that are picked up, the odds of them sticking around for a long run are quite against them, especially today. And yet, there are new scripted television series every fall, a few of which will find the audience and creativity needed to enjoy a successful, prosperous run. Most of these classics began with that single test episode.
Dipping into its vast CBS television library, Paramount Home Entertainment delivers Forever Funny: T.V. Sets, a single disc holding the premiere episodes (four of them, pilots) of seven of the most popular and enduring situation comedies of all-time.
Dating from the early 1950s ("I Love Lucy") through the mid-1990s ("Frasier"), the chosen series are each among the lucky few to have racked up accolades while making their marks on pop culture. All but one of the shows accrued over 100 episodes, running for 5 seasons or longer. The two most recent shows ("Cheers" and its spin-off "Frasier") remained active for 11 seasons; their highly-rated back-to-back run spanned 22 years and totaled over 500 installments. The one exception to longevity, "The Honeymooners", lived on for years in "The Jackie Gleason Show" sketches, while its original "Classic 39" episode run is still treasured.
Some of the shows are considered artistic achievements. "Taxi" won 3 to 6 Emmy awards for each of its five seasons. "Cheers" garnered 27 Emmys over the years as every core cast member was recognized with at least a nomination. "Frasier" experienced Emmy victory 37 times. On the other hand, one featured show -- "The Brady Bunch" -- never got so much as one award nomination of any kind until 15 years after it left the air. And yet, that family sitcom is considered legendary television.
It's probably too soon to lump "Frasier" in the same league, but most of the others boast an extraordinary reach. Consider how few films, songs, and current events from 1951 are remembered by the general public and then try to find someone who has never heard of "I Love Lucy."
All seven respected series have come to DVD before, and all but "Taxi" have been released in their entirety. If you love any of these sitcoms, you probably own at least their first season DVDs and therefore their episode featured here. But anyone who has refrained from collecting the shows due to cost, interest, or overwhelmingness should probably take notice of this new disc. Though multi-series compilations may not be as easy to market as a single brand name and cast shot (and I'm not sure the title-juggling mime/clown cover helps), Paramount is aiming this impulse-priced disc at drugstores and groceries. The studio reports being pleased with last fall's water-tester, Holiday Treats, which held 8 sitcom Christmas episodes. Next week, we get both Forever Funny (whose lineup includes 5 of Holiday's eight shows) and Action Packed (bearing four drama premieres). Other "T.V. Sets" discs are currently in the works, including science fiction and crime/law ones.
The episodes here are arranged loosely chronologically, with a few swaps that don't necessarily make sense.
1. I Love Lucy: "The Girls Want to Go to a Nightclub" (23:46) (Originally aired October 15, 1951) In this episode, landlords/neighbors Fred (William Frawley) and Ethel Mertz (Vivian Vance) wish to spend their wedding anniversary in different ways. When they can't reach a compromise, Ethel and Lucy (Ball) look for dates for a night of dancing at the Copacabana. When they discover Fred and Ricky (Arnaz) are doing the same for boxing fights, the ladies seize an opportunity, disguising themselves as hillbillies and acting strange.
2. The Odd Couple: "The Laundry Orgy" (25:40) (Originally aired September 24, 1970)
Felix and Oscar try to figure out how to keep their dates with the Pigeon Sisters (Monica Evans and Carole Shelley) without cancelling Poker Night. The two sets of roommates make a party out of doing their laundry together. When they get back to the apartment, though, the odd couple bickers.
3. The Honeymooners: "TV or Not TV" (25:59) (Originally aired October 1, 1955)
In this episode, Alice wants to own a TV and complains that Ralph is too cheap to buy one. He comes up with the idea for him and friend/neighbor Ed Norton (Art Carney) to go halves and share the set. Needless to say, comic complications arise when Ed wants to wear his space helmet watching Captain Video and Ralph does not.
4. Taxi: "Like Father, Like Daughter" (24:40) (Originally aired September 12, 1978)
The drivers of New York's Sunshine Cab Company take advantage of a pay phone that lets them keep their change, but Alex (star Judd Hirsch) is reluctant to reconnect with his estranged teenage daughter. Elaine (Marilu Henner) comes to work there "part-time", as does a fresh-faced fare (Randall Carver).
5. The Brady Bunch: "The Honeymoon" (24:41) (Originally aired September 26, 1969)
6. Frasier: "The Good Son" (23:42) (Originally aired September 16, 1993)
7. Cheers: "Give Me a Ring Sometime" (24:54) (Originally aired September 30, 1982)
VIDEO and AUDIO
All seven shows are presented in 1.33:1 fullscreen, the standard television aspect ratio until recently. Naturally, one finds greater variance here than on most DVDs. That is most evident in comparing the two black & white shows. "I Love Lucy" looks amazingly clear and sharp, but then it was shot on 35mm film as opposed to the usual cheaper methods. Said methods were employed on "The Honeymooners" and it shows. With no secondary audio tracks, toggling is a non-issue, but even checking the DVD's audio is prohibited. Still, my DVD-ROM confirmed what I suspected that each track is encoded in two channels. People don't expect whiz-bang from sitcoms, but the sound palettes do run deeper than dialogue; there are laugh tracks and music features prominently in most of the shows, especially "Odd Couple" and "Taxi." The mixes are as satisfactory as the picture generally is, with the one exception again being "Honeymooners", whose audio is very quiet and muffled. The biggest disappointment regarding the sound is Paramount's usual one: there are closed captions but no English subtitles.
BONUS FEATURES, MENUS and PACKAGING
There are no bonus features or previews, only a single static menu screen enabling episode selection or complete continuous playback. Show logos adorn pastel colored eggs, suggesting the disc would have been apt for Easter gift-giving had it come a couple of months earlier.
Though no inserts are found inside the keepcase, the back cover supplies cast photos, 1-sentence synopses, air dates, and episode titles. What more could a person want?
CLOSING THOUGHTS
Forever Funny is like a public domain compilation you might find for a dollar or two, but instead of old, largely forgotten programs looking like crap, you get 7 shows nearly all considered classics presented in the high quality you'd expect from one of the big studios. One more premiere episode would have been nice (matching Holiday Treats' total) and another two could have fit without pushing the disc's compression any. Still, this amounts to quite a nice and historical sitcom compilation for just about $10. Even if you have a couple of these shows' first seasons on DVD, the refreshing variety, great selection, and appeal of having the premieres gathered together could still be worth the low asking price for sitcom lovers.
|
Related Reviews:
UltimateDisney.com | DVDizzy.com: New and Upcoming DVD & Blu-ray Schedule | DVD and Blu-ray Reviews | Upcoming Cover Art | Search This Site
Other Paramount/CBS "T.V. Sets" Discs: Action Packed • Holiday Treats
New to DVD: Paul Blart: Mall Cop • Hatching Pete / Dadnapped • CSI: Crime Scene Investigation - The First Season (Blu-ray)
The Odd Couple (Centennial Collection) • The Odd Couple: The Third Season • Happy Days: The Fourth Season
NewsRadio: The Complete Series • Benson: The Complete First Season • Silver Spoons: The Complete First Season
Walt Disney Treasures: Mickey Mouse Club • Walt Disney Treasures: Annette • Never a Dull Moment
The Muppet Show: Season Two • The Golden Girls: The Complete First Season • Home Improvement: The Complete First Season
The Barefoot Executive • The Ugly Dachshund • The Hustler • Esther Williams Collection • Swing Vote
Reviewed May 17, 2009.
Text copyright 2009 DVDizzy.com. Images copyright 1951 Desilu Productions, 1955 Jackie Gleason Enterprises, 1969 Redwood Productions,
1978 John Charles Walters Productions, 1982 Charles/Burrows/Charles Productions, 1993 Grub Street Productions,
1951-1993 CBS Studios, Inc., Paramount Television, and 2009 Paramount Home Entertainment/CBS DVD. Unauthorized reproduction prohibited.