New and Upcoming DVD Release Schedule | DVD Reviews | UltimateDisney.com | Search This Site
"Dirt" The Complete First Season DVD Review
For every actor who's gotten their start on television and transitioned to movie stardom in just a few years (like Robin Williams, Bruce Willis, Tom Hanks and Shia LaBeouf, to name a few), there are about five who were a part of a huge hit TV show that never went onto anything bigger. Look at the casts of the landmark "Cheers" and "Seinfeld" and consider how few of them we see on the big screen with regularity or in a leading role. A more recent example is the long-running "Friends"; of the ensemble sitcom's six stars, only one -- Jennifer Aniston -- has continued to remain of high interest to the general public and that's been due as much to her celebrity marriage and divorce as her roles in film.
Aniston's fellow Friends continue, however, to get work. Courteney Cox recently followed Lisa Kudrow and Matthew Perry back to television with her hour-long FX drama "Dirt". Unlike "The Comeback" and "Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip", "Dirt" was renewed for a second season. "Dirt" adds to a minor trend of Hollywood serving an inside look at its unique, alluring world. On TV, HBO's "Entourage" appears to be its closest kin, but the abundance of making-of featurettes and audio commentaries on many of the DVDs you own confirm that the phenomenon isn't limited to semi-fictional cable series. The angle that distinguishes "Dirt" has relevance to the media at large; it focuses on the market of celebrity gossip that is currently distributed at an all-time high. Trashy tabloids, starstruck respectable magazines, their TV and Internet counterparts, and everything in between all add up to a culture that supposedly can't get enough of celebrities aged 17-40 (primarily, 20-30) and the various parties, romances, personal dramas, and tragedies that concern them.
Cox's lead character Lucy Spiller lives off of celebrity gossip. As editor-in-chief of two different entertainment publications that are merged early on, her journalism consists of ruthless paparazzi, top-secret sources, blackmail, valuable silences, and all sorts of Hollywood scandal.
If you look down upon rags like US Weekly but think somehow an interesting drama could be made about the people who make it, you're wrong. If you flip through the pages of such publications, most likely acknowledging the guilty pleasure of photos and fluff stories of famous young actors and musicians, you might have higher hopes for a show like "Dirt", but you too are likely to be disappointed.
"Dirt" is frankly a very unsavory show, which doesn't render the field of celebrity worship any less shallow while approaching it from the angles of cutthroat journalists and the newsmaking personalities. Part of the problem is that the depiction of Hollywood is utterly bleak. Starlets and young actors are all riddled with drug dependencies, infidelities, secret alternative lifestyles. "Who's in rehab this week?" has become a staple question of celebrity news this year, but the fictitious train wrecks here are more graphic and depressing than amusing in passing or apt for a late-night joke.
Another drawback is the very nature of the series -- it is fictional. For many people, it's a chore enough to care about what Britney, Paris, Lindsay, and Jessica are up to now. Investing in the dramas of pretend celebrities is quite a challenge; either a character emerges suddenly and we're left to ponder which real famous performers they're composited from, or they linger and we see shades of real life celebrities lose meaning in the move to "inspired by." I'm not sure if this dilemma is one that could be overcome; real celebrity news is hot for a moment then forgotten. The area that should stifle the rising question of "Who cares?" is the series' leads, but Cox's icy, desensitized, depraved, workaholic protagonist doesn't seem to deserve any of our sympathy. In the role of second fiddle, Ian Hart gets to show off his acting chops as functional schizophrenic photographer Don Konkey, but while weird neuroses and visual trickery might make for an imaginative filmmaking experience, they do not endear us to this conflicted paparazzo, who for the stretch of a few episodes is "living with" a pregnant starlet who has recently committed suicide (Shannyn Sossamon).
Given less time, supporting characters are even less compelling. The most focal celebrities are a self-indulged, screwed up young couple of actors who have Nick/Jessica overtones. The heavy-lidded Holt McLaren (Josh Stewart) sells his soul for a movie deal and in the process, helps send his video game-loving wife Julia Mallory (Laura Allen) into drugs, bisexual affairs, and rehab. At central workplace DirtNow, we also occasionally see confrontational pencil-sideburned publisher Brent Barrow (Jeffrey Nordling) and hard-working young reporter Willa McPherson (Alexandra Breckenridge, curiously deprived a core cast credit). They're generally called upon to serve a function and usually one that's either obvious or tangential.
As if to make up for all its design and execution shortcomings, "Dirt" pushes basic cable standards with profanity and sexuality that, like a few other FX original series, are more graphic than anything south of subscription channels like HBO and Showtime. The content seems shocking for cable channel-surfing, but it's also plainly indulgent as if throwing in variations of the s word and moments of partial rear nudity will cause us to overlook the many flaws. It doesn't, and in the world of uncensored DVDs, the series looks all the lamer for trying to disarm in this manner of restrained titillation.
Arriving two weeks before Christmas and three before the Season 2 premiere on FX, the timing just makes sense for this Complete First Season DVD. Spoiler-free synopses of the thirteen featured episodes follow.
Disc 1
1. Pilot (54:50) (Originally aired January 2, 2007)
2. Blogan (47:38) (Originally aired January 9, 2007)
3. Ovophagy (48:02) (Originally aired January 16, 2007)
Disc 2
4. What to Expect When You're Expecting (44:04) (Originally aired January 23, 2007)
5. You Don't Know Jack (47:27) (Originally aired January 30, 2007)
6. The Secret Lives of Altar Girls (44:30) (Originally aired February 6, 2007)
7. Come Together (45:25) (Originally aired February 13, 2007)
Disc 3
8. The Thing Under the Bed (45:30) (Originally aired February 20, 2007)
9. This is Not Your Father's Hostage Situation (45:35) (Originally aired February 27, 2007)
10. The Sexxx Issue (46:29) (Originally aired March 6, 2007)
11. Pap Smeared (46:29) (Originally aired March 13, 2007)
Disc 4
12. Caught on Tape (44:04) (Originally aired March 20, 2007)
13. Ita Missa Est (46:37) (Originally aired March 27, 2007)
VIDEO and AUDIO
At first look, "Dirt" could easily be mistaken for a major feature film based on its stunning picture and engulfing sound mix, both of which reflect considerable production values. As far as I can see, the cinematic presentation -- 1.78:1 anamorphic widescreen video and Dolby Digital 5.1 audio -- is flawless. There's plenty of grain, but it seems to be a deliberate stylistic choice. English subtitles are provided for episodes and extras alike.
BONUS FEATURES, MENUS, DESIGN and PACKAGING
With the exception of the promo for current Disney/ABC TV shows on DVD that launches Disc 1, all of the bonus features are found on Disc 4. They begin with three short featurettes. "Celebrity Couple Gets Dirty" (5:12) covers the origins and development of "Dirt" with brief interview sound bites from a wide variety of involved parties A gag reel proves to be mildly diverting with its supply of botched lines, errant throws, funny faces, and laughter, although at 92 seconds, it runs surprisingly short for a 10-hour season.
Next come eleven deleted scenes collectively and individually introduced by creator/producer Matthew Carnahan and running about 19 minutes altogether. It's not always clear which episode or part the scenes themselves would fit in. They tend to be quick and unremarkable. A few things worth mentioning: a scene that was axed for Brent's "shiny shirt", a "sad cat man" who twice appears to Don, an unfinished blue screen dream sequence of Lucy, and an additional exchange with Leo's silent girlfriend.
Finally, "Season 2 Preview" (1:20) merely finds Carnahan talking in vague terms about how the series' imminent sophomore year will differ from the featured season.
Disc 4's Sneak Peeks menu offers previews for a trio of Miramax Films DVDs coming winter 2007: Becoming Jane, Golden Door, and Eagle vs. Shark.
The thematically appropriate 16x9-enhanced menus are all accompanied by loud, looped instrumental music. The only animation comes in a brief intro to the main menu. Though the episodes are each divided into seven chapter stops, as is often the case for TV series, there are no scene access menus.
The Complete First Season of "Dirt" comes packaged, like most Buena Vista series, in a glossy fold-out Digipak that is housed in a cardboard slipcover. There's a pocket for inserts, but the only one provided is an ad for the soon-to-air Season 2 on FX.
CLOSING THOUGHTS
"Dirt" lives up to its name by being one of the lowest and trashiest TV series I've encountered in a long time. It's practically dead on arrival, with its insider and tabloid staff looks at the entertainment industry registering as morose, phony, and highly unappealing. Shallow characters, an irritating tone, hokey ideas, and a tremendous paucity of values all ensure that this hour-long drama isn't any better in execution than it is in theory. I suppose FX has carved its own little niche with cable television that's nearly as edgy as HBO fare. The practice has earned devoted fan bases and critical acclaim, but if "Dirt" is representative of the programs' general quality, then I don't feel I'm missing out on shows like "Nip/Tuck" and "Rescue Me" and neither should you.
Buena Vista's DVD doesn't merit complaint in terms of presentation, with picture and sound being solid at least per the deliberate style. While far from overwhelming in quality, the featurettes and deleted scenes cover a satisfactory amount of ground in the obligatory supplements department, likely only disappointing those wanting audio commentaries. With only 13 episodes, there's not enough content to justify the set being given the same $59.99 list price as the twice as voluminous sets given to Disney's (much better) network shows like "Desperate Housewives" and "Grey's Anatomy." Then again, the tag isn't far off those of other FX dramas and it won't set you back nearly as much as the HBO shows being emulated. Still, even if you were able to snag this DVD for absolutely nothing, you'd still be at a loss for having acquired "Dirt."
|
Related Reviews:
Ugly Betty: The Complete First Season • Brothers & Sisters: The Complete First Season
Kyle XY: The Complete First Season • Popular: The Complete Second Season • The TV Set • Finding Neverland
Desperate Housewives: The Complete Third Season • October Road: The Complete First Season
New to DVD: Laverne & Shirley: The Third Season • Happy Days: The Third Season • Superbad: 2-Disc Unrated
New and Upcoming DVD Release Schedule | DVD Reviews | UltimateDisney.com | Search This Site
Reviewed December 10, 2007.